Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Business and Society Ford Pinto Case - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : dubuquebeau


Different ethical doctrines or theories can likely create a very notable difference on how the executives carry out a decision. In the case of the operation of Ford Pinto, an ethical egoist's suggestion to Ford's executive at those times will most likely differ from that of a utilitarian…

Extract of sample
Business and Society Ford Pinto Case

In the Ford Pinto case an ethical egoist would most probably advise Ford's executives to continue the production of the car. With the fierce competition that the automobile industry in those days, it was wise that Ford would launch a product that will have a commanding competitive edge. Ford Pinto passed all the qualifications that would make the car a hot item. In terms of price, passenger convenience, fuel efficiency, and other criteria Ford Pinto is outstanding.
The car, however, had only one critical flaw, its safety. Its design makes it susceptible to put the car into flames that will endanger its passengers. Ford still manufactured Pinto despite the fact that its engineers were aware about the issue beforehand. Nevertheless, an ethical egoist's defense to Ford's decision is the huge cost that they would incur if they stop the production. As mentioned above, safety is only a small disadvantage of the car compared to its many benefits. Besides, it is the responsibility of the buyer to minimize the risk to accidents. Concerning the issue of the car's design an ethical egoist may argue that Ford has a patented fuel tank that is more dependable and robust compared to other car brands. Stopping Pinto's production will greatly affect the financial status of the company. This huge cost may cause the corporation to close. This will definitely harm the laid off employees and also the US economy. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Furthermore, I am able to give the appropriate pre-screening tests for shortlisting candidates in view of the job nature.…
4 pages (1004 words)
Fords Pinto
If the categorical imperative is to keep American industry competitive, the prime objective is to do that while balancing the other considerations present. It would not, for example, be proper to focus solely on the issue of competitiveness and forget other imperatives such as worker safety.…
3 pages (753 words)
Ford Galaxy
Ford Galaxy is a seven-seater luxury large Multi-Purpose Vehicle (MPV) developed jointly by Ford and Volkswagen and was first introduced in 1995. During the Frankfurt Motor Show held last September 2005, the latest Ford Galaxy model was unveiled. It will be available in the market in the middle of 2006.…
9 pages (2259 words)
Utilitarianism, business ethics
So every aspect must be examined to evaluate potential good and bad outcomes; if the goods outweigh the bads, then morally, the action can be deemed right. If there are more bad consequences predicted, then the opposite applies. As with all ethical and philosophical theories, there are more issues to be considered, nothing is quite so simple. Different forms of utilitarianism have been described over the centuries, like Bentham's pain - pleasure as bad and good consequences. (Ethics, 8), but all seemed to attempt to measure and define what 'utility' actually means. If utilitarians consider…
5 pages (1255 words)
Ford Pinto Ethics
The other three survived only because special measures had been taken to prevent the rupture of the tank such as (a) plastic baffle between the axle housing and the gas tank (b) steel plate between the tank and the rear bumper and (c) a rubber lining in the gas tank. The results of the test therefore show clearly, that the fuel tank failed, yet the Company did not take any action to remedy the defect. Three of the cars fared better when some special measures were introduced, and the Company had this evidence on hand as well but this still did not factor as significant enough to merit some…
2 pages (502 words)
Ford Pinto Case
This line of thinking is supported by the first principle in Rawls’ theory of justice: that each person is entitled to the most extensive total system of equal basic liberties (Oyeshile, 2008, p. 65). Among our human liberties, nothing is more basic than the liberty to be secure in one’s right to life and well-being. The intentional deprivation of one’s life and health becomes an unethical act and works against the theory of justice of Rawlsianism.…
2 pages (502 words)
Reflection Paper ( Business Ethics for Leaders )
In the given case of Pinto Fires, the questions have been answered in a broader context. There are possibilities that some of the steps of decision making process may not be incorporated directly, but it will be ensured that their core essence remains implicit while reaching at the conclusion.…
3 pages (753 words)