StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Divisive Issue of Immigration - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
The Divisive Issue of Immigration

History seemed to repeat itself but this time the mob was not trying to expel the illegal immigrants; instead, their supporters - relatives, friends and neighbors - banded together to become a mob fighting for their right to stay in America. In the same article Karen Tumulty recorded the events of the recent months and found something that according to her most Americans were caught unaware including the Senators who were supposed to be on top of the problem:
There was the scene in Apache Junction, Ariz., in which a few Hispanic students raised a Mexican flag over their high school and another group took it down and burned it. In Houston the principal at Reagan High School was reprimanded for raising a Mexican flag below the U.S. and Texas ones, in solidarity with his largely Hispanic student body. Tom Tancredo, the Republican from Colorado who has become Congress's loudest anti-immigrant voice, said his congressional offices in Colorado and Washington were swamped by more than 1,000 phone calls, nearly all from people furious about the protests in which demonstrators "were blatantly stating their illegal presence in the country and waving Mexican flags."
When the author intimated that the attempt to reform the immigration law was dividing the country it is clear that it was an understatement.
But looking at it from a purely social perspective is merely scratching the surface for there are more powerful forces encouraging the migrants from across the border to cross the line. Migrant workers risking life and limb to come over to the United States is simply in need of better employment. For employers the long line of workers responding to the help wanted sign means that there is a great chance of getting the best man for the job at a lower cost. And the incentive of employers to continually shield or encouraged illegal aliens t is simply a matter of exploiting a competitive labor market. Here is where differing interests begin to conflict, while two views of how a government should function comes to mind. The first view states that the federal government should function as an organism therefore each individual living in the United States is just part of the whole and therefore each person's welfare is subject to what will benefit the whole. The other view states the converse which is that the federal government is a mechanism created by the people to serve the people. An example of the second view coming to play in this national problem was addressed by Tumulty, referring to a particular minority - some members of the Republican Party- and this is what she said, "The business interests in the party base don't want to disrupt a steady supply of cheap labor for the agriculture, construction, hotel and restaurant industries, among others." Therein lies the bone of contention. To some, the illegal migrant workers are a boon to the economy while to those struggling to get a piece of the pie, they are a threat.
Welfare economics does not offer much help in solving ...Show more


In the April 10, 2006 issue of Time magazine an article by Karen Tumulty tried to shed light on the complicated problem plaguing the United States of America. Her reporting initially focused on Senator John McCain's setting a chain reaction of events that will modify the nation's immigration laws with the goal of transforming 11 million illegal immigrants into bona fide citizens of the United States…
Author : vida86
The Divisive Issue of Immigration essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The Divisive Issue of Immigration"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

The basic fact of immigration is that it has always been a reality, and the various types of benefits of immigration can be realized as the fundamental reason behind ever growing figure of immigration. Significantly, immigration is an international phenomenon and reality, and almost all the nations of the world are affected by this global phenomenon.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Criminal Justice Policy Issue (Immigration in Arizona)
President Obama makes an emphasis on the necessity of immigration regulating laws development and he considers this law “to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans, as well as the trust between police and our communities that is so crucial to keeping us safe” (Anti-Immigration Law).
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Illegal Immigration in the United States
Illegal immigration is an issue which evokes strong responses from diverse sections of society. Opinions are divisive, and usually range between two extremes. On one side is ranged the anti-illegal immigration groups which stridently call for the immediate deportation of all illegal immigrants.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Illegal Immigration: The Need for a Humane Approach
The researcher states that the best approach to illegal immigration would be a humanitarian one which takes into consideration both stands, and finds an acceptable middle ground. Call for a humanitarian approach is justified and it is necessary to address the fears of opponents to immigration by demonstrating that the adverse cultural and economic aspects of illegal immigration are negligible.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Farmingville the explosive issue of illegal immigration
The film, which assumes the form of a documentary, takes great pains to present an objective overview of the situation and to communicate both sides of the issue. As, however, it ultimately directs viewers' sympathies towards the plight of the Mexican day laborers and portrays several of the town's residents as unapologetically racist, "Farmingville" cannot be considered objective.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Are issues of immigration and refugee status questions concerning human rights or just the basic rights of citizenship
‘Immigration’ and ‘refugee status’ are considered from the point of view of ‘rights’. A comparison of the nature of rights of ‘immigrants and refugees’, rights associated with ‘immigration’ by itself and
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
This paper tends to discuss major causes of immigration, their effects, and subsequent issues. Various socio-economic and political factors cause
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Since the 9/11 attacks immigration policy has become a major issue within the United States. While the recent Arizona law that has been enacted to -- what some individuals argue -- profile Mexican immigrants crossing the border has received most of the recent
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Criminal Justice Policy Issue (Immigration in Arizona)
Therefore, in order to prevent illegal immigration in the American States, it is relevant not only to take strict measures, but also take into account human rights, the rights of immigrants and develop immigration policies in accordance with
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Issue of immigration
ould always remember that from the very beginning of its existence the United States has always been multicultural and multinational country and it was immigrants who made it powerful. That’s why immigrants are not only a part of national ideology but also a quite strong force
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us