CompareContrast Nathaniel Hawthorne's heroines in The BirthMark and Rappaccini's Daughter

Undergraduate
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 5 (1255 words)
Download 0
Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-64) was one of the well-known writers of his time. Some of his famous works (for example, The Scarlet Letter) are set in the backdrop of puritanical seventeenth century society in New England, with the underlying themes of sin, evilness, repentance, and redemption…

Introduction

This has led to a few of them being described as "dark heroines" (Bell, 20); Beatrice Rappaccini, the bewitching daughter of the brilliant, but sinister scientist Rappaccini and to a lesser extent, Georgiana Aylmer, the beautiful young wife of the obsessed scientist Aylmer, are examples of poignant, yet powerful 'dark heroines'.
This short essay shall compare and contrast the heroines of two of Hawthorne's short stories, 'The Birth-Mark' and 'Rappaccini's Daughter' respectively. This essay shall cite appropriately from them and other secondary sources to show that, while both the heroines testify to their purity of character by their ultimate sacrifices, Hawthorne's portrayal of Beatrice Rappaccini more than Georgiana Aylmer, aptly suits a 'dark heroine'.
Both 'The Birth-Mark' and 'Rappaccini's Daughter' of Hawthorne warn the society regarding the excessive pursuit of science and technology without morality. The stories end as tragedies with the heroines falling victims to the evil obsessions of the dominant men around them. In 'The Birth-Mark' Hawthorne depicts his heroine Georgiana as a powerful image of beauty, that she is praised by her husband Aylmer as one who "came so nearly perfect from the hand of Nature" (The Birth-Mark 1021). She is young and beautiful, but for one "visible mark of earthly imperfection" (The Birth-Mark 1021) on her cheek. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

CompareContrast Nathaniel Hawthorne's heroines in The BirthMark and Rappaccini's Daughter
This has led to a few of them being described as "dark heroines" (Bell, 20); Beatrice Rappaccini, the bewitching daughter of the brilliant, but sinister scientist Rappaccini and to a lesser extent, Georgiana Aylmer, the beautiful young wife of the obsessed scientist Aylmer, are examples of poignant, yet powerful 'dark heroines'.…
Nathaniel Hawthornes "The Scarlet Letter"
Hester Prynne's strength of character as well as her willingness to accept her fate prove to be valuable qualities necessary to succeed in an environment of conformity. Winston Smith's lack of courage as well as his fear of unpleasant consquences prevents him from expressing his true self. Though both characters stive to overcome the pressures of society, it proves to be more difficult than they…
Man vs Nature in Hawthornes The Birthmark and Jack Londons To Build a Fire
The point is that although man cannot hope to overcome nature, some men are foolhardy enough to try. Such men usually get adequate warning and advice, and if they choose to ignore these, they are doomed.…
Rappaccinis Daughter
Beatrice suffers because of fatal experiments of her father who just kills his daughter with poisons in pursuit of medical knowledge. Hawthorne describes: "the monstrous offspring of man's depraved fancy, glowing with only an evil mockery of beauty" (Hawthorne). Also, Beatrice is isolated from the society, because of her father's bad reputation and diabolical experiments. Beatrice cannot protest…
Nathaniel Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown"
Following Maus (2002), the symbolic meaning of Faith in the story "is not only representative of Faith the individual but the faith of the individual-witness Goodman Brown's reply to the devil's comment about his tardiness, which contains both literal and allegorical truth" (78). From the very beginning, readers perceive characters and their actions through their symbolic names.…
Paper Daughter
It is a heartwarming story of culture shock and self-survival.…