StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'

The administrators objected to having to enforce the principle of zero tolerance on the grounds that they would have to go in with a police escort, even on the basis of a sliver of a rumour about a picture you don't like. Defenders of the policy reply that it indicates a greater willingness to take such complaints seriously.
This type of policy of reversing the burden of proof is a species of argumentum ad ignorantiam of the following form: if you can't prove that you are not guilty, then it is presumed that you are guilty. Normally, the burden is on the accuser to provide evidence or corroboration of the charge. Admittedly, where an event took place privately between two people, with no physical evidence of harm, it is generally hard to prove such objective corroboration. The solution advocated by the zero tolerance principle is to shift the burden of disproof of the charge onto the side of the accused party. If he can't furnish such evidence, the conclusion we should draw by the ad ignorantiam argument is that he is guilty.
Is this a reasonable or fallacious use of the argument from ignorance This is a hotly disputed question at the moment. Defenders of zero tolerance argue that the application of the argument from ignorance, as a reasonable argument in this instance, is justified by argument from consequences: namely, those women are at present suffering from abuse to such a degree that anyone who opposes zero tolerance is causing the deaths of women. Opponents of the principle also base their opposition on the argument from consequences. They argue that the policy of zero tolerance is producing many innocent victims of false charges of abuse, and having a disastrous effect on families.
Opponents of the policy also argue that the advocates of zero tolerance are focusing only on the consequences as they affect one group, and ignoring the impact on anyone who is not a member of this group. They see this as a form of self-interested bargaining or advocacy dialogue taking the place of a more rational and objective type of deliberation or critical discussion that takes all points of view into account.
At any rate, on this controversial issue, the central question directly relates to the argumentum ad ignorantiam as a type of argument. Is it reasonable or fallacious in this case And what are the grounds for justifying one opinion or the other
Significantly, zero tolerance policing, with its more assertive and control oriented message, seems to have struck a chord in recent years.

An increasing number of public-initiated police contacts are crime-related, especially in inner-city areas and in a time of stretched resources many have argued that police duties should be more closely restricted to crime-work. This was the dominant message behind the setting up inquiry into core policing tasks, which, despite denials, was envisaged as clearing the way towards the privatization of alleged 'peripheral' police-work. While the conclusions of the ...Show more

Summary

Borrowed from the Reagan-era war on drugs, the phrase "zero tolerance" is now being applied as a judicial model by universities and government agencies in investigation and prosecution of charges of harassment and discrimination. The principle of zero tolerance is that once an accusation is made of, say, sexual abuse, violence against women, or profanity in the schools, it should be followed by immediate arrest of the alleged perpetrator, even if the accusation was made anonymously…
Author : westleyromaguer
Does Zero Tolerance Policing work essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Zero Tolerance
This article is about zero tolerance policies in the work place. Zero tolerance policies refer to strategies that allow for meager compromise on consequences of certain work place mistakes (Punch, 2007). This may relate to scenarios such as violence, harassment, internet and intranet policies.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Bullying and Zero Tolerance Policies
emotional and psychological. In this study we are trying to find out the extent of the problem and to see if the policy of zero tolerance will be effective in reducing bullying incidents that are taking place. The data has been gathered from a multi-cultural society to ensure that the results are not biased and represent the whole society not just a sub-sector.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Hierarchical Leadership Style in Policing
This behavioral pattern of the human nature makes the subject of criminal justice an interesting concept to follow. However, it could thus be mentioned that as there is a certain amount of highest common features among the nature of the human kind towards crime it would well be logical to standardize the process of judicial system and thus making the system more clear and approachable.
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
UK Zero Tolerance Policing
To achieve this, the department of Zero Tolerance Policing should be made independent so that it may be free from any external interference by "the invisible hand". In the United Kingdom, this policy has been widened to even cover the internet misuse and sexual harassment that were initially not covered.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' Discuss in relation to crime control, social control and social justice
cusation is made of, say, sexual abuse, violence against women, or profanity in the schools, it should be followed by immediate arrest of the alleged perpetrator, even if the accusation was made anonymously. This principle, in effect, reverses the burden of proof. The
15 pages (3750 words) Essay
Dissertation Proposal - The traditonal hierarchical leadership style is not the only option for policing, change to transformational leadership style is possible
This behavioral pattern of the human nature makes the subject of criminal justice an interesting concept to follow. However, it could thus be mentioned that as there is a certain amount of highest common features among the nature of
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
What is collective efficacy and, how, if at all does it affect local crime rates
On the other hand crime is a very diverse term which can be used in different situations with entirely different meanings. However, as
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
EVALUATING THE IMPACT OF ZERO TOLERANCE POLICING. Metropolis Police Service intends to introduce a zero tolerance policing policy in an attempt to cut crime. A zero tolerance policy forbids police officers from exericisng discretion and imposes automatic
1). This project therefore seeks to discuss the impact of zero tolerance policing, in an area where Metropolis Police Service intends to introduce the strategy in an attempt to alleviate
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Violence and Teachers Perception of the Zero Tolerance Policy
Cases of knife stabbing, mass shootouts, as well as, physical bullying continue to be significantly challenging issues, especially in public schools. It is irrefutable that, even a single case of student noncompliance poses a significant
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Zero tolerance policies
However, various incidents have confirmed that the effectiveness of the zero tolerance policies is minimal and depends largely on the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation