StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Critical Thinking and Extrasensory Perception - Case Study Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Critical Thinking and Extrasensory Perception

Thus, this scenario demonstrates some of the features associated with the fallacy of positive instances. Mike has recalled and relied on a solitary event (the "hit"), in this case a phone call from his old sweetheart, to justify his assertion that he has extrasensory perception. There is no evidence that Mike can accomplish this feat regularly; indeed, there is no evidence that he has ever done this before. The analysis, therefore, must rest on this single occurrence. The second major characteristic of the fallacy of positive instances is also evident; in this case, for instance, Mike seems to ignore or assign as irrelevant the fact that he was incorrect in predicting the identity of many callers in the past ("misses"). In this way, Mike is relying on an extraordinarily selective event to assert a larger truth. In this case, his assertion is not justified because he relies on a single hit to the exclusion of many more misses.
The romantic attractions of extrasensory perception are present in this scenario. That a psychic can appear in an educational setting, adorned with the trappings of intellectual discipline, and then successfully predict that two students will share the same birthday is impressive. A consequent sense of awe is natural. It is natural because of the statistical improbability of the psychic being correct. This scenario, because of this statistical characteristic, demonstrates the fallacy of innumeracy.
The fallacy of innumeracy assumes that individuals may opt to believe that a chance occurrence cannot be explained through any rational means; more particularly, lacking an understanding of statistics or probabilities, people may choose to believe that an event is impossible absent some extrasensory power or insight. This type of fallacy can be applied to this scenario. In this case, there are twenty-four students. The psychic chooses only two students as the basis for the prediction. He doesn't choose three students, two females, or three males. All of these choices affect probabilities and the psychic keeps his prediction as general as possible within the framework of twelve months and 365 days. In this way, it can be argued that the psychic enhanced the opportunity for making a correct guess by improving his odds.
1.3 Scenario Three: Baseball Dream
This scenario would seem to share features of different fallacies; however, given the quest for power and control that a major league baseball player seeks when facing ninety mile an hour fastballs, nasty sliders, demanding fans, and expectations of self, this scenario can best be analyzed using the willingness to suspend disbelief fallacy. The baseball player had a dream and uses it to justify an assertion that he has extrasensory perception. His dream may have reflected a subconscious desire to control his destiny, to succeed rather than to fail, and an aspiration to control the course of his major league baseball career. To be sure, dreaming of a grand slam or a bases-loaded triple is hardly unusual. The baseball player's assertion evinces his willingness to suspend belief in an effort to gain control over his livelihood; this is not to say that such a suspension of belief ...Show more

Summary

By citing this type of incident as evidence of his extrasensory perception, Mike is ignoring a couple of important facts. It is true that Mike had been thinking about Lupita. It is also true that she telephoned him while he was thinking about her. What is most telling about this scenario, however, is what information hasn't been provided…
Author : ekeeling
Critical Thinking and Extrasensory Perception essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"Critical Thinking and Extrasensory Perception"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Critical Thinking and Leadership
It simply says that to grow in size (physically and financially) and for a business organisation to develop into a more significant undertaking, it must strive to be and have to be different. Succinctly, it is quite easy to be different, the question is, how can one be different In its opening paragraphs, Yahoo was cited as a classic example of young companies which doesn't seem to have a clear-cut and a well-defined business strategy, nonetheless triumphed and is currently enjoying tremendous success over its antagonists in the midst of extreme competition and contentions, overnight mimics and replicas and customers who doesn't or wouldn't pay a single centavo of its services.
12 pages (3000 words) Case Study
Critical Thinking Assumptions
She will put the children in daycare. She'll have a 45-minute commute. The extra money will help Jim give up extra commitments. Economically, they will remain about the same but the burden will now be shared more fairly. She expects these changes will make the family happier.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Critical Thinking Case Study (Marketing)
Pat believes that the retail version of the original AcuScan scanner will be a big hit. If not the perfect version, a prototype can be developed by August, to which further changes can be made. If this deadline is not met, the competitor will launch their product before AcuScan Inc.
12 pages (3000 words) Case Study
Critical Thinking Master Case Study
pp280). This paper presents an illustration of Critical Thinking against a case study of AcuScan. When Pat asked him about the expandability & re-engineering aspects of iScanner Software, he thought she is just asking few questions out of curiosity. He never imagined that she is going to come back with a tough target for him to carry out these enhancements.
16 pages (4000 words) Case Study
Critical thinking paper
Business environment is undeniably one of the challenges faced by APNs. There are many health care and ethical concerns facing with APNs. One is conflict in the values when it comes to the country’s shift of health care policy from patient-centered to a population-centered
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Critical thinking
The whites/ Caucasians occupy the largest composition of the state, which is 1,935 people. This is 93% of the total population. The next in number is the Hispanics, and they
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Critical thinking
It was termed as “the biggest football joke of all times” by a number of newspapers in Norway. A commentator exclaimed, “Qatar has stolen the World cup.”(Rethven 2013) The success of the bid has resulted in a number of tantrums. This is because of the
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Critical thinking
inning of the days when videography, or motion picture, as it is said in the passage; was established, it has created a significant impact on our society. The writer tries to state his point that while this motion picture has put on smiles on faces, made people happy, amused
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Developing Critical/Clinical Thinking by Identifying Clinical Relationships
Mrs. Kelly previously lived independently in a senior apartment where it is expected she will return to. She is widowed and her two daughters are active in her care while here at the Skilled Nursing Facility and involved in her life. Monitor intake and output
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Critical Thinking Case Study
Due to the abundance of law suits, by civilians, against big companies such as pharmaceutical companies, there has been a backlog in the judicial system with cases taking years before any
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation