The Milgram experiment - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
The Milgram experiment

This particular aspect also contravenes ethical principal A: Beneficence and Nonmaleficence ("Ethical Principles", 2003).
However it should be commended that when offering payment of $4.50 an hour, the participants were told that they would receive the payment whether or not they completed the experiment, this was the most ethical thing to do as then payment wouldn't be the motivator of the participants actions.
Looking at all the facts given above, it can be argued that the researchers should have been honest with the participants about the nature of the experiment being a study in obedience and not that of memory and learning and that the experimenter should have reminded the participant/teacher that they are free to leave at anytime, instead of using verbal prods to ensure they continue with the experiment. While this is correct we should keep in mind that the experiment results would not have been accurate if the above suggestions were followed even though it may have made the experiment more ethical.
...
Download paper

Summary

This document will look at the ethical attributions of the Milgram experiment and argue for and against the experiments according to the ethical principles of Psychologists and code of conduct set out by the American Psychological Association.
Though the researchers obtained the consent of the participants the researchers were deceptive when they said the experiment investigated memory and learning knowing it actually investigated punishment and obedience, this is an infringement of section 3.10 of APA code of conduct ("Ethical Principles", 2003).
Author : fconn

Related Essays

Stanley Milgram
The respondents ("teachers") should switch on electric shocks of different voltage if "learners" (persons recruited by Milgram) made mistakes in their responses. The experiment showed that "65% of his subjects, ordinary residents of New Haven, were willing to give apparently harmful electric shocks-up to 450 volts-to a pitifully protesting victim, simply because a scientific authority commanded them to" (Milgram Basics). So, there is a question: is it possible that an ordinary person (e.g. the teacher) will obey authority so blindly that they will harm another (e.g. the learner) As the...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
EnronBlack GoldP2P
This is a documentary film that is based on the book "The Smartest Guys in the Room". Basically, it dramatizes the rise and fall of Enron. It is quite entertaining due to smart use of storytelling devices, imagery and soundtrack. In fact, it is amazing to look on leading role played by banks, financial media, accounting firms and government. The film Enron is weak on clearing up how the company brought up its image from a simple gas pipeline business to a post-modern corporate megalith. One of the most important things regarding the film's strength is in its representation of the massive group...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Quasi Experiment
Trochim, in this type of research design the most often used group is the intact groups which we think are similar as the treatment and control groups. Two significant characteristics of the NEGD are clearly manifested in this experiment. First, the sample group that is used in the experiment is practically similar in the sense that these kids all have high self-efficacy in playing softball. The second characteristic is the non-random manner of choosing the group. All the components of the group have high self-efficacy in playing softball. This clearly shows that the components of the group...
1 pages (251 words) Research Proposal
Organisational Behaviour Master Essay
Take one prisoner as an example; he is kept inside a closed room with only one opening ornamented with hard iron rods but, what happens when one good human being is put in an evil place Does humanity win over evil, or does evil triumphs...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Social Psychology - The Stanley Milgram - psychological experiments
The case was taken as the punishment given to a victim member by giving some shocks by a member in a group. This shows his harsh obedience to his leader. But the member stopped the shocks when the victim refused to give answer further. The member showed tension in the member's mind. This study showed many behavioral aspects which were observed in this study of obedience....
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Milgram's Experiments.
After World War II, in the Nuremberg War Crimes trials, a common defense of those accused of these crimes against humanity was "obedience.". The prevalence of this justification is what prompted Stanley Milgram to perform his experiments. Milgram's experiments focused on the conflict between obedience to authority and a person's conscience. ...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
The Original Milgram Experiment 1961
the subjects to any actual risk, except exposing them to a moral pain, which was temporary and in a way necessary to the very nature of the experiment....
1 pages (251 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!