Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

International Volunteers in the Spanish Civil War - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
College
Author : fmckenzie
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 8 (2008 words)

Summary

This essay attempts to answer the question as to "whether it is justified to describe the international volunteers who fought for the Republic during the Spanish Civil War as the 'dupes' of Moscow." Proposing an answer is not easy when viewing the events from today's vantage point some seventy years after the war, thirty years after Franco's death, and fifteen years after the collapse of the communist government in Moscow.

Extract of sample
International Volunteers in the Spanish Civil War


There are several views on what the war was about. Rather than expound in such a short paper the wide range of perspectives depending on which side of the political and social spectrum lies each viewer and opinion giver, it may be sufficient for our purposes to identify two of the extremist views about the Spanish civil war.
On one side are people like Beevor (1983) who view the civil war as a military uprising against a legitimate communist government that was carrying out a revolution as part of a Marxist class struggle aimed at reforming the corrupt economic and social structures of the time. Inspired by the success of the 1917 Russian revolution and driven by new ideologies for the liberation of peoples, several agents of change inside and outside Spain saw the Russian model as an applicable and pragmatic solution to social problems. The people (proletariat), therefore, fought back and waged war against a military force that wanted to topple the legitimately elected government.
On the other side you Arrars (1968) and Carroll (1996) who see the civil war as a crusade fought to preserve Spain's culture, mainly their religion, and poetically compares it ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Civil War History
Not only was Ambrose plagued with lucklessness, he was also indecisive and reckless.…
6 pages (1506 words)
Spanish-American War 1898
President McKinley finally had no choices in the matter as a result of the sinking of the USS Maine. Foreign policy changed dramatically as a result of the consequences of this very short, very significant war that is often forgotten in view of the Civil War. The Spanish-American War, one where Theodore Roosevelt and his Rough Riders earned their place in history, brought about a great deal of change to the perception of the United States by others in the world. This war would cause major changes in the realm of American foreign policy in its wake.…
6 pages (1506 words)
Civil War in Georgia
There were reduced start-up costs for the civil war due to the accessibility of weapons from the Soviet and a ample number of volunteer fighters. In March 1992 and Kitovani was made the Minister of Defence- with this authority, Kitovani then organized the Abkhazia war in order to establish control over the transportation networks and valuable tourism industry of the province. In the end though, there was a total collapse of the informal and formal economy in 1993 which made it impossible to supply the troops effectively and that led to poor organization of military campaigns. Finally,…
2 pages (502 words)
Spanish Civil War and Literature
The authors of these literary pieces employ different literary devices in their works such as adjectives, hyperbolic language, use of allusion, etc and each of these devices has immense significance as the authors depend greatly on these in narrating their experiences of the civil war. The contrasting methods of the writers find most valuable in an understanding the different accounts of the experiences in the Spanish Civil War, and the authors have been effective in portraying the picture of the civil war. This paper makes a comparative analysis of the accounts of the civil war experiences by…
7 pages (1757 words)
How Far Was Foreign Intervention Responsible for the National Victory in the Spanish Civil War?
The war offered both Hitler and Mussolini an opportunity to test their equipment and military strategies. Hitler also expected Francos assistance in any future German war. Concerned about Hitler’s actions, British and French officials began to discuss an alliance with Soviet Union. But Soviet leader Joseph Stalin felt threatened by Hitler’s military actions and did not think British and French would protect his country. Hence in 1939, the Soviet-German nonaggression pact was revealed where each side agreed not to attack the other.…
6 pages (1506 words)
Spanish-American War
The war went smoothly for the Americans and proved devastating for the Spanish, which suffered defeat continuously. Although several drawbacks have been observed in the American military preparedness for this war, the same has been classified as “splendid war of short duration” by historians, even from outside America. Historian Harry Allen has described this event as “America’s swift and total defeat of Spain”(1). Due to lack of coordination between different wings of American defense forces, rivalry was visible between sailors and soldiers, while the war resulted in the charges of…