Subverting the Processes of Peer Review - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Subverting the Processes of Peer Review

Hwang was indeed a brainy researcher. He had efficiently kept his collaborators, manipulating them with their own personal motives. With that, he had managed to maintain his established credibility within the span of his research and prominence.
Hwang was a national hero in South Korea and was rose to fame after claiming a series of remarkable breakthroughs in the field of stem cell research. Despite the notable absence of any of the scientific data needed to probe the validity of his research, Hwang's several claims were well received by the South Korean media and public. They have been so attracted with his claim of immeasurable economic prospect that his research was said to be promising (Wikipedia, 2008). With such renowned standing, he maintained and expands his research team. Building it in a rigid hierarchical structure had made him extremely dominant among his researchers regardless of their titles.
His collaborators worked for his fraud and some had even so consistent with their support despite the arousal of controversies. With their firm determination to back him up, he had managed to publicize his said noble study. Dr. Roh head of Seoul fertility clinic had agreed to collaborate with Hwang despite the anomalous way of obtaining the egg cell from paid donors and two of their junior researchers. ...
Download paper


The supposed noble stem cell discovery Hwang Woo Suk led should have been so significant that its controversy had become an issue on medicine, ethics, and politics. It had incurred an enormous funding both from public and private sectors in and outside Korea…
Author : boreilly

Related Essays

Peer Pressure
The negative results of peer pressure can be quantified in terms of truancy, delinquency, contact with law enforcement, and eventual incarceration. Indeed, there is an explosion of youth deviance, sexual activity, and violence that affects us all. The results of peer pressure may be overt, but the causes are often more subtle and elusive. Understanding peer pressure is a critical factor in understanding the teenage years and mediating the potential bad decisions that are made by teenagers as they surrender their judgement to a group's expectations and norms. Peer pressure is a destructive...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Peer Coaching
Program briefing for all teachers: 2 handouts namely: Briefing Handout and Peer Coaching Program Handout are to be given out to all teachers to be signed up and returned. Power point slide presentation on the Briefing handout is to include:
3 pages (753 words) Assignment
Peer Review
Increasingly, the threat of medications that are risky being placed on the market anyway is becoming a problem as well. The claim is somewhat justified by the numbers given later on in the paper, not to mention the possible side effects and warnings on Tylenol labels, etc. However, some of these claims are a bit irrational. Vitamin supplements being taken in excess is not a normal occurrence and it seems a bit illogical to put it in this paper, although it's a valid point. However, this weakens rather than strengthens the original point on which one is focused, which is basically whether...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Peer Reviewing
The main objective of peer reviewing is to undertake some sort of analysis about certain kinds of mistakes or making appropriate changes the work. Technically speaking, it means providing feedback on the work done by one another. Moreover, the concept of peer reviewing gives emphasis on improvement of the work.
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Peer review
Furthermore, the number of sources referred to is adequate, proof that a good level of research was conducted. The references contain all the necessary elements which means that the information provided can be easily traced to their sources. The paper is well formatted but not without a few lapses. The abstract for example is centered while it should have been left aligned. Yet another point of weakness is the lack of a title after the abstract. In any case, the body of the text should always begin on a new page, different from the abstract.
1 pages (251 words) Essay
Peer Review
This draft exhibits a clear understanding of the task at hand that shows a clearly researched assignment. However, the author confines herself to a superficial analysis of the issues and avoids making a personal analysis. The author largely quotes what other authors have found and, in my opinion, does not make analysis’ that are expected in order to provide a well-argued paper. This has the overall effect of reducing the effectiveness of the draft and this makes it unsophisticated and unreflective of the author’s level of study.
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
Peer review
each member, as well as the distinctiveness of each situation, would be able to apply the needed theoretical frameworks to address pressing issues at hand. Leaders and team members should thereby be apprised of the relevant concepts that would assist in developing cohesiveness which is deemed to be needed in high quality of performance, as well as in exhibiting exemplary productivity towards the accomplishment of goals.
1 pages (251 words) Book Report/Review
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!