StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Miscellaneous
  • A Comparison between Charles Taylor and Will Kymlickas views on Multiculturalism with Minority Rights

A Comparison between Charles Taylor and Will Kymlickas views on Multiculturalism with Minority Rights - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
A Comparison between Charles Taylor and Will Kymlickas views on Multiculturalism with Minority Rights

However, the implementation of equality and sharing of beliefs is the only way that discriminatory issues can be avoided and minority rights upheld, according to Taylor's philosophy. I personally tend to favor Taylor's point of view since it appears to have the most solidity in the view's being given. Of course he makes quite a few other interesting points in his writing, from my personal interpretation of it. Multiculturalism has a strong purpose in politics as when there are other nationalities living in a country they want to be able to feel they are a part of it (Taylor 1994). The only way this is possible is if they have awareness that they are included in the many political debates of the many topics concerning the country's needs or desire's for the people.Furthermore, Taylor shows the notion of multiculturalism gives identity to people as it defines them as human beings. If the politics of a nation where only centered around the natural origin of those living in a country, such as Americans in the United States, then there would be no sense of a multiculturalist identity for those who were of a foreign body that also dwelled in America as well. Therefore Taylor points out that it is crucial to acknowledge all people who reside in a country and that developing a political identity with the concept of multiculturalism is the way to go about creating equality and a sense of individuality for all of the various ethnic cultures within the body of a nation. A political body can not simply step up to a podium and refer to all people as Americans or Europeans and expect there to be unity in that nation. This is one of the strongest views of Taylor and this author feels it has a good relevance to the effect political bodies have on the citizens of a nation. If there is a lack of inclusion of one type of nationality there is going to be discord and inequality but if there is an inclusion of the whole concept of multiculturalism then it will make a nation stronger and the citizens of the communities will be united, or so it would appear. Also, Taylor also emphasizes the fact that recognition of different cultures is extremely important to provide equality in a nation. However, there can be various dilemmas with what people know about others and therefore the idea of misrecognition of a culturally diverse group can create just as many problems as actually not identifying their presence can create. For example people in a country often make assumptions about foreigners who live there. Before the facts are gathered false interpretations develop such as with Latino's, many people in America often identify all Latino's as being from Mexico and speaking the same form of language but this is the wrong impression. Latino's span out across many regions and they all do not look alike or speak alike therefore this is a simple example that can be given following Taylor's points of misrecognition of a culture between ethnicities.
In fact Taylor states that the wrong idea can cause severe harm onto a culture as they are then faced with many discriminatory issues and don't feel a sense of equality either, which is one of the problems that is prevalent in many countries today, especially in the United States in particular. This results in a distorted image of a culture and impacts them in a negative way as they begin to feel that the main representative cultural body within a country is not willing to ...Show more


With regard toTaylor's literature he clearly is pointing out that all voices should have a form of recognition, especially in the arena of politics, while Kymlicka states that some problems within multiculturalism simply can not be avoided…
Author : pedro25
A Comparison between Charles Taylor and Will Kymlickas views on Multiculturalism with Minority Rights essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"A Comparison between Charles Taylor and Will Kymlickas views on Multiculturalism with Minority Rights"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

A Critical Comparison between Laozis and Zhuangzis Views about Daoism
In another words, they believed that “Tao is the universal law of nature” (Ivanhoe & Norden 165). Scholars claim that these philosophers shared many similar concepts regarding the philosophy of Tao. But though these philosophers commonly believed so, they differ from each other to a great extent.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Yet some nations are completely against the idea and are ethnocentric in every sense. The chairman of the Commission for Racial Equality, Trevor Phillips, is one of those critics who is against this idea. Certain key members of the British nation have continued to promote multiculturalism and say that it is a concept that has been there even before large scale immigrations began.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Minority Shareholders Proprietary Rights
According to this test, there were two limbs that need to be satisfied. One, the amendment must be for proper use and second, the amendment should not be oppressive on the minority shareholders of the company. As in the case of Gambotto in Australia, in a number of cases, the courts have taken cognizance to the fact that even if the plaintiff does not request for the two tests, the courts may and can subject the amendment to these tests and see to their fitment to the same.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Majority Rule and Minority Rights Essay
On the other hand, the United States of America Constitution characterize minorities clearly too either be a product of culture, religion, topography, and earnings, otherwise those who suffered political or election defeat. These categories of people were provided the fundamental rights that all the other citizens enjoy.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Majority Rule and Minority Rights
Indeed, there are several places in the Constitution where suspicion of unchecked majority power is evident - from the Bill of Rights to the structure of the Senate to the Electoral College. To be sure, some historical events that ran relatively concurrent with the birth of the United States, primarily the French Revolution and its associated "Reign of Terror," provided ample illustration of the potential for majority rule to degenerate into mob rule.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
In line with the study of multiculturalism, the researcher will explain under what circumstances is multiculturalism an advantage and disadvantage in doing business with Asia. At the end of the study, the researcher will recommend some strategies to the Australian government on export to Asia.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Research Paper on a comparison of Charles Dickens and Alexis Tocqueville's views on America
It was with this generalized concept of America that two of this era’s most well-known authors journeyed to discern for themselves just what America had done right that Europe
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
United States-Centric Views Comparison
table-2 (see appendix-2). The common United States-centric viewpoints on the foretold groups, based on my opinion and my friend’s opinion are summarized below. Almost all of my opinions on Christian Americans are similar to my friend’s (see appendix 1 and 2). For
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Multiculturalism broadly refers to a society which caters multiple cultures. Policies that comply with multiculturalism are very important to a country like the USA where people from diverse regions around the globe live and work
2 pages (500 words) Essay
However, there have been some challenges with the management of multi-cultural firms that has made most human resource managers not preferred having to do with a multi-cultural workforce (Christensen, 2011). Such challenges notwithstanding, the advantages of
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation