StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Miscellaneous
  • The approach of English law towards duty of care has been inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant

The approach of English law towards duty of care has been inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant - Case Study Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
The approach of English law towards duty of care has been inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant

The author is of the belief that it is when one looks at the cases involving gender orientation discrimination that one sees best how English law is inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant. The cases examined will demonstrate not only legal contortionism at play, but language contortionism as well. After all, as stated by Andrew Altman in the article Legal Realism, Critical Studies and Dworkin, (1986) the law is infused with irresolvably opposed principles and ideals, and this legal indeterminacy, as it is called, compels the judge to make a choice that is not dictated by law. Once-sacrosanct legal precepts are being dismantled, stare decisis as a doctrine is being reexamined, and the infallibility of the courts as repository of truth and justice is being questioned. The law is no longer a fabric of clearly-defined spectrums, but is rather a patchwork quilt of various shades of gray.
Taking this view is important in that it stimulates self-interrogation. It does away with the all-too-convenient givens of a legal system - that there is but one set of "correct" rules and that legal decisions are but logical outcomes of tested principles that are empirically-replicable. It aspires to expose the ideological content of the law obscured by layers upon layers of social conditioning by demonstrating how the large areas of legal indeterminacy provide fertile ground for the cooptation of the legal system to reinforce existing power arrangements.

This brings us to our discussion on tort cases involving gender discrimination. Conaghan (1996) states:

From a social perspective, feminists have argued that women suffer particular harms and injuries as women: their experience of pain and injury is indistinguishable, to a large extent, from the experience of men. This claim has at least two dimensions. On the one hand, pregnancy and childbirth, menstrual and/or ovulation pains are obvious examples of gender specific "harms". Men do not/cannot experience these traumas directly. On the other hand, the concept of gendered harm can also embrace those harms, which, although not exclusive to women in any biological sense, are risks which women are more likely to incur than men - the risk or rape, incest, sexual harassment, spousal abuse, or, more contentiously, the risk of harmful medical intervention.


By and large, there is no dearth of legislation prohibiting discriminatory practices against women. However, in practice, jurisprudence has made it difficult for women to raise tort-related claims. Certainly, there are cases that are cut-and-dried; for instance, when it is patently obvious that there is discrimination on the basis of gender. However, in this day and age, it is less likely to find a case wherein the discrimination is so obvious that it unquestionably amounts to an illegal act. One would be hard put to find an employer who would dare violate the stringent regulations against workplace-related discrimination, instance. There is a greater likelihood that the discrimination would be insidious, perhaps having to do with a careless statement loosely made that betrays the ...Show more

Summary

The Law of Tort is supposedly used to remedy damage inflicted where redress is not available in penal law. In cases of physical damage, law and jurisprudence have come up with rules that have made it relatively easier for claimants to seek redress, although it might be argued that recent decisions1 have actually raised the ante and made it more difficult for claims based on physical injury to prosper…
Author : dagmarwehner
The approach of English law towards duty of care has been inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"The approach of English law towards duty of care has been inconsistent, illogical and unfair on the claimant"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Torts Law Problem
In Lloyd vs. Grace Smith & Co, 1 the court held that a principle is variously liable for the fraud of an agent acting for a corporation. By employing this rule, John was an employee of MoreeRE and was making representations for the company in his dealings with Cathy.
5 pages (1250 words) Case Study
Tort Law Essay
Essentially, where there has been a situation where an individual suffers a loss and is injured as a result of the negligence of another, they may be entitled to claim losses from the negligent individual or party. Broadly speaking, in order for there to be a valid claim in negligence, there must be a duty of care from the plaintiff to the claimant; secondly, there must have been a breach of this duty; and thirdly, a causal link both factually and legally must exist between the breach and the harm suffered by the individual.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
Nullity of a Company in English Law
In order to answer both questions, and consequently determine whether the aforementioned statement correctly describes the legal situation, this essay will first describe the concept of nullity of a company by describing the concept, determining the legal entity that it refers to, and determining the effect that the concept will have on such entity.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
Company Law and Companies Act
The Company Act is the quintessential code of company law in the United Kingdom. The act of 2006 replaces Propositions of Company Law laid down in the years 1985, 1989, 2004. The new act brings in a number of changes as well. The changes are primarily in the areas such as Company formation, the rights of the shareholders, the liabilities and duties of the directors and the maintenance of share capital.
14 pages (3500 words) Case Study
Contract Law and Tort Law
There was a notice which said "All activities undertaken at your own risk." The boys, accompanied by Potter went to a cafe, owned by "Thrills and Spells", for lunch. The floor was unfinished and several rolls of linoleum were lying around. Edmund, one of the pupils, tripped over a roll of linoleum, hurt his head and became unconscious.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
English Contract Law
Even oral agreements become enforceable. The crux of the issue is that there is a contract made between Dodgy Tony Limited and Gordon and since there is a valid contract, both the parties to the contract are bound to fulfill the terms of the contract. Gordon is entitled to claim his money back which he has sent to Dodgy as the company has violated the terms of the contract.
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
Company Law - English law
Under its equitable discretion the court may disregard the apparent form of limited liability personae, and focus on the actual substance. Hence there are decisions which have distinguished the apparent form of a limited company to show it for This is sometimes referred to in the literature as 'lifting the veil of incorporation'.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
English Business law
While we are sorry for what happened, we would just want to highlight our position with regards to the issue as a way of showing our commitment with regards to upholding the rules and regulations guiding our operations. First and fore most the problem has
5 pages (1250 words) Case Study
Unfair Employee Discharge
As such, he had the right to raise any concern on areas of management competencies and policies. The purpose of holding annual general meetings is to inform shareholders of a company about the current state of affairs and answer to their concerns about the company.
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
Fair or unfair
Monitoring is meant to remove biasness (Zweig and Scott 227). However, it is unfair if the monitoring of employees takes place without them being informed. As cited by Zweig and Scott, on page 227, the costs of monitoring the phone calls of
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation