StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Three Dirges by Marshall Bennett Connelly - Book Report/Review Example

Extract of sample
Three Dirges by Marshall Bennett Connelly

One of the motifs used is the construction of images. The image of the direct confrontation with the Colonel presents the implicit and indirect message that the Colonel tries to intimidate Don Lazaro. Don Lazaro is ordered to kill five boys under his charge. The image of a cowardly traitor allaying the murders onto another man is clear. The Colonel is a dictator who seizes absolute control and passes sentencing without giving the accused boys the chance of a trial. Don Lazaro is in an extremely difficult position. If he disobeys the Colonel, he will get into trouble. If he obeys the Colonel, he has to answer to the five boys, their families and society. This chaos is set against the innocent and humble night when the second paragraph describes the night scene of San Martin Comitan. This natural, peaceful scenery contrasts with the un-natural, destructive order from the Colonel in the Paragraph 1. Paragraph 3 presents the vivid image about the fighting and unrest that is on-going with the Indian skyrocket violating the airspace. Its grey smoking trail 'racing above the center of the town', presenting the image of a tense battle in the midst of civilization.
In Paragraph 4, the narrative goes back to a scene in the mid afternoon of the day before this fatal order from the Colonel. The Colonel is presented as a strict and harsh man who does not hold any pretext at politeness because he does not waste time on 'pleasantries'. The fact that the Colonel has to tell Don Lazaro to sit down twice shows the great division between him and Don Lazaro. Don Lazaro stands to show defiance or fear. The image is also one of being reluctant to be there to accept orders. It may also mean that Don Lazaro does not dare to sit in the presence of a powerful ruler like the Colonel. Don Lazaro shows his suspicions about the Colonel by not accepting his invitation to take a seat.
Don Lazaro is reminded of the fighting with the sound of rockets in the distant background. He is again ordered to sit when the soldier in attendance places a rickety chair beside him. The Colonel presents the image of a commander who will not be disobeyed. He stands up with measured formality to impress upon Don Lazaro that he wants obedience. Don Lazaro 'gingerly took a seat on the front edge of the chair' (Paragraph 12). This gives the image of a man who still distrusts the Colonel and is afraid of him, getting ready to stand up should something unpleasant happen.
Paragraph 14 and 15 interposes the village's activity as a foil to remind Don Lazaro of his ties as the responsible Mayor of his village and how he is torn between the order from the Colonel and his moral duty as the Mayor. The reference to the background reflects the poignant image of how treacherous Don Lazaro may be feeling; being ordered to kill five boys because they were teaching the campesinos literacy. The Colonel then issues a more direct threat to Don Lazaro by accusing him of being among those who the boys were teaching to read by asking; ' "Maybe even you, eh"' (Paragraph 16). The image of a frightened Don Lazaro is evident to the Colonel as he forces Don Lazaro to continue to listen to instructions. (Paragraph 18). The Colonel and all those in power desire ...Show more

Summary

The "Three Dirges," An Excerpt from Requiem Guatemala, is written by Marshall Bennett Connelly. It relates the harsh political and social climate of Guatemala facing unrest. This essay explores the images and symbols used in the excerpt. The thesis states that this story is not a strictly historical account of Guatemala's past because Connelly imposes his personal opinions in an indirect way by using literary motifs.
Author : eldridge68
Three Dirges by Marshall Bennett Connelly essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Three Dirges by Marshall Bennett Connelly"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The Marshall Plan: America, Britain and the Reconstruction of Western Europe 1947-1952 by Michael J. Hogan
This particular plan is formulated in order to bring the reconstruction of the Western Europe and America had taken this up as one of its priorities post war period. It is not that the Marshall plan was made just for Europe. There were other countries that were also included as part of this policy but they were all peripheral.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Rhetorical Analysis of Three Cups of Tea
After spending time with the tribe and devoting his life to promoting peace in Pakistan, Mortenson concluded that the establishment of peace would rely heavily on the women of the area. According to Mortenson, empowering and education the women of the Middle East will help combat not only terrorism but also the other destitute aspects of Pakistan such as poverty and poor sanitation.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Book review the three faces of Eve
Thigpen and Hervey M. Cleckley, the two psychiatrists who had treated her. I would highly recommend this book to all those who are interested in becoming clinicians. The reason for this is because this book has taught me a lot about the impact of MPD on clients suffering from it, and how to deal with such situations and clients.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Samuel Walkers Three Mile Island
According to Walker in the book's preface, the near-disaster was "the single most important event in the fifty-year history of nuclear power regulation in the United States"2. What happened then was an accident that began in the early morning of March 28, 1979 that resulted into a core meltdown of TMI-2, one of the power plant units in the complex.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Praisesong for the Widow by Paule Marshall
Avey Johnson, a middle-class African American widow, pays for her annual cruises to the Caribbean with her two friends, Thomasina and Clarice. The parfait last night on the cruise ship, the Bianca Pride, has given her a sudden sense of dementia and stomach problems.
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths
Hence, while each of the monotheistic religions is cognizant of the two others religious regard for the city, its adherents assume that their claim supersedes all. It is, thus, that despite Judaic awareness of the sanctity of Jerusalem within the context of both Christianity and Islam, that Jews believe that they have the dominant claim to, and dominion over, Jerusalem.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Three Cups of Tea
Greg’s daring ambition to scale the summit of K2 deeply inspire us to have the deadly confidence and indomitable will to set the most difficult and unreachable targets. His belief that nothing is impossible is a strong stimulating factor to achieve the most
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
Three Cups of Tea
One moment is all that can alternate your perception and your thinking. It’s all about knowing the need of leadership, being a true leader and then doing something for a cause. This paper will review the leadership abilities of
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Book report on The Brass Verdict by Michael Connelly
Michael Haller is caught under serious circumstances when he pursues the murder of Walter Elliot who had been strangled to death. However, the police are also pursuing the case to establish who murdered
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Top Three Health Care Policy Proposals
I strongly concur with professor Miron on the notion that healthcare is not a right. If it were a right accorded to the people, then many would misuse it by over-relying on it. On the same breathe, cost and benefit is disregarded
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation