StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The movie rating system should be revised - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
The movie rating system should be revised

However, the rating system is not viewed as an effective and substantial body and has been criticized for a variety of reasons.
The first criticism against the motion picture rating system has been presented by film critic Ebert who claims the rating system to place more importance on the minute details of the movie rather than the movie itself. This argument stands against the system's choice of picking on intricate details of the movie like the number of times a profane word is used or the number of scenes containing violence. This allows the rating system to escape from the throes of presenting the true message of the movie. For instance, a movie with sex and violence could be discussing the consequences these activities could teach to the audience. Adult ratings should be limited to those movies which show an immense degree of sex and violence. This would help in the removal of NC-17 which allows a greater number to access a variety of movies. Ratings of movies like Passion of the Christ should not have ratings that limit individuals under 17 from watching a movie (Ebert 2004). This is because the rating system creates a loss in the true message of the movie in its quest to censor the content.
Another idea that stands up against movie rating systems is the belief that filmmakers are forced to change movies because the content affects the personal sensibilities of the members of the censorship board. Farber, a film critic talks of how filmmakers were threatened with an X rating to make them remove content which offended the board members (1972). This is seen as biased behavior on the part of the rating systems board because of their inability to provide a decision based solely on the judgment of creating a rating that will be friendly to the audience. Instead, the board is apt on creating ratings that will inadvertently be influenced by their personal beliefs and opinions.
Another idea that talks of the flaws in the rating system is the lack of public opinion that is involved. There is a call by both conservative and liberal parties to make the rating system's methods and techniques more public thus allowing a degree of public scrutiny into their decisions. However, this idea seems a little impossible because it is impossible to pin point exact standards set up by the rating system. Movies today touch a variety of topics and issues. It is impossible to set up every method up for the public because it might not apply to each movie. Thus, setting up a public forum would be problematic because every individual's ideas vary and this could be chaotic and unhelpful.
The rating system is criticized for its inability to present an equal treatment to the independent studios. This criticism lies on the belief that independent studios are not meted out with the same ratings as those given to major studios. Thus, independent studios are given a harsher rating system which is a great setback in the creation of new and diverse films. An instance of this is evident in the rating given to the movie Saints and Soldiers. The movie was created by an independent studio and created a limited amount of sex, profanity and violence. Yet, a single scene where a character is killed made the movie get a PG-13 rating (Deseret News). This is an obvious sign of bias against independent studios which can be of great harm to the creativity and emergence of unique ideas in the motion picture industry.
Thus ...Show more


The movie rating system has been established in different countries for the movies their areas produce. Its aim is to classify films according to the degree of sex, violence, profanity or any other mature content they might contain which is unsuitable for certain audiences…
Author : ygerhold
The movie rating system should be revised essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The movie rating system should be revised"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Films and the rating system
Today, each filmmaker thrives hard to go into a new direction; they try very hard to be different from others. That is why, we got the mind bending ‘Inception’, the visually stunning ‘Avatar’ and the poetic ‘The Tree of Life’, just to name a few.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Rating Sites
Now there are sites which rate professionals like lawyers and doctors, and also services. Pfeiffer claims that since all these sites are anonymous, we can't say whether they are genuine. Since anonymity is the essence of the internet, it is not possible to find out who is posting the ratings.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Movie Rating
Again, the way that heavy consumers of movies rate movies is quite different from the way that light viewers rate them. For the heavy viewers, they rate obscure movies lowly and rate hits highly. The popular movies will still be watched even with the introduction of the internet since those who are light viewers are interested in these hits.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Housing Health and Safety Rating System
It is a new way of evaluating that whether the dwelling are posing any potential health risk on the tenants or is it completely fit. However, if any deficiencies are found in the dwelling or the actual conditions are less than the specified standards than actions are taken under enforcement guidance.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
The Effect of the Revised Large-Scale Retail Stores Law on the Japanese Distribution System
Retailers – individual/group who ultimately sells the product or service to end users or customers. They can be grouped according to ownership (independent, franchisee,
17 pages (4250 words) Essay
Two movie about criminal justice system
One of such realities with different perceptions is the criminal law system. With a great influence in every individual, the criminal justice system is viewed as the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Is the MPAA Rating System Fair
Is truly the so-called rating system of MPAA flawed? This seems to be a question of fact for the viewers as well as independent filmmakers. According to my personal opinion, though the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Revised proposal
Conversely, this method does not put into consideration the effects of these processes on the ecosystem especially the harvesting of bi-halves in high numbers
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Revised proposal
Conversely, this method does not put into consideration the effects of these processes on the ecosystem especially the harvesting of bi-halves in high numbers
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Job analysis project (rating system part)
The mean is just the average of the response of respondents in the criteria of frequency, importance, flexibility and difficulty and tells how common is the specific task
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment