StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Martin Scorceses The Gangs of New York - Movie Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Martin Scorceses The Gangs of New York

Ken Burns' genius was to bring those photographs together in almost a cinematic way to make the war, and the people involved, more real.
Scorcese's movie, although it takes place during the Civil War, is really not about that War at all. It is more about the earlier- and later-arrived Irishmen, and how they inculcated themselves into a hierarchical society in New York City. The first great Irish immigration wave was during the building of the Erie Canal in the 1820's. Most of the Irishmen who were already there and under the leadership of Bill "The Butcher" Cutting were part of the 1840's Irish potato famine crowd-a rough time for Irishmen to enter the U.S. as there were few jobs after the depression of 1848, and an actively hostile reception both from established Irishmen and the WASP's who controlled the political machinery of New York.
Since Scorcese's movie focuses on the tension between "old" Irish and newly-arrived Irishmen, led by Leonardo DiCaprio's Amsterdam Vallon, the Draft Riots of 1863 are an inconvenient truth whose underlying issues are ignored in the movie. Without a knowledge of the actual historical events of the time, and only viewing the movie, one might be led to believe that the riots were about old versus new immigrants, contained by a WASP police force under the leadership of Boss Tweed. The reality was quite different: General USS Grant and President Lincoln needed hundreds of thousands of troops in order to maintain a numerical superiority over the South, and they regarded the Irish immigrants of New York as a ready source of human capital for the war. Those in New York who had few roots in the American culture did not want to throw themselves in front of Gattling guns and cannons on battlefields like Gettysburg and Appomatox.
So how was the "truth" injured by Scorcese's movie One might argue that he should have chosen a different era, perhaps before the Civil War and not related to the Draft Riots, to exploit the tension between old and new Irish immigrants. While the plot could have been truer to historical fact, the tension of the plot might not be there. Scorcese needed to have a dramatic tension, a build-up, in his movie, leading to an apocalyptic riot where all of New York was burning. The 1863 riots provided that dramatic backdrop, one which would not have been available in the past.
As contrasted to other movies covering the same time period, "Gangs of New York" offers three original contributions: (1) it features a part of the population during the Civil War that was not at the front lines, (2) it gives a young person's perspective, as compared to the older, in-charge leaders such as Boss Tweed and Lincoln, and (3) it is a group pastiche, rather than a concentration on one leader, such as is found in "Glory."
Perhaps the best comparison to "Gangs of New York" is the epic "Birth of a Nation" by D.W. Griffiths (1915). Like "Gangs," "Nation" was an ensemble piece, one which explored not just the leaders of movements, but the underlying motivations behind the resentments and conflicts-in this case, between blacks and whites at the time of the Civil War and just after. Of course, ...Show more

Summary

Martin Scorcese's "Gangs of New York" was a masterpiece of cinematic artistry, and brought to life a subculture and a time that is little covered in the movies. Most of the movies covering the Civil War refer to the battles at the Mason-Dixon line or into the South, from "Gone With The Wind" in 1939 to "Glory," featuring the black Massachusetts division under the leadership of Colonel Robert Shaw, played by Matthew Broderick (1989).
Author : jgottlieb
Martin Scorceses The Gangs of New York essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the movie review on your topic
"Martin Scorceses The Gangs of New York"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Review of Life Lessons from the Movie New York Stories
The second story “Life without Zoë” is directed by Francis Ford Cappola and is written by him and his daughter Sofia Cappola. The last story of this anthology film is “Oedipus Wrecks” and is directed and written by Woody Allen.
3 pages (750 words) Movie Review
Synecdohe, New York Movie Review
The film also depicts the aspect of Meta referential where a play within a play is portrayed. Thesis: The movie Synecdoche, New York, focuses on the self realization and the search for oneself. The movie deals with the self discovery of the protagonist of the story, Caden where he evolves through various stages of life with a quest of knowing himself and the causes of his suffering.
6 pages (1500 words) Movie Review
A Bright New Boise
A Bright New Boise A Bright New Boise is a dramatic play developed by Samuel Hunter, directed by Tom Ross at Aurora Theatre(Hunter, 2011). The main character Will reconnects with his teenagers in Hobby Lobby by applying for a job, after he fled from his rural hometown after the scandalous tragedy was occurred, involving his fundamentalist church.
2 pages (500 words) Movie Review
Martin Scorsese: Auteurism in Gangs of New York
During the 1950s, the auteur theory was coined by a group of French critics. This theory holds that a film epitomizes the vision of an individual artist and that as the writer is the author of a book or a painter the author of a painting, the director is likewise the author of a film (Scott para. 7).
5 pages (1250 words) Movie Review
Alone: Life Wastes Andy Hardy by Martin Arnold
The film is structural in terms of the methods used in creating it. Repetitive looping of scenes, in this case, micro-scenes, is a trademark of structural films. Martin Arnold is a true genius in revealing the “hidden messages” by magnifying them from those seconds-long scenes which he achieved by repetitive looping.
5 pages (1250 words) Movie Review
Diet for a new American
The movie tenders the correct picture about the animal kingdom and tells the viewers about the eating habits of humankind. The human system is not built to eat meat or the dairy products. The movie gives concrete details about the meat industry and
1 pages (250 words) Movie Review
The Overview of a Documentary Film about New York City
The film depicts the perennial complexity of the racial discrimination that distinctly revealed preference of the America elites that foster same injustices and similar inequalities in the present community. Moreover, the film is developed in the event before the trial and conviction, and mix of the new and the old.
1 pages (250 words) Movie Review
God in America: A New Adam
The Spanish friars proclaimed absolute salvation with intention attract the Pueblo population. The pueblo believed otherwise and fought against the intended plans to replace the native
2 pages (500 words) Movie Review
Respond to the videos, at least 4 pages paper detailing your take awaysdouble-spaced, 12 point, Times New Roman
In other words, business ethics has become an irreplaceable part of the modern ways of doing business. The first video which was a scene from the movie that is called
4 pages (1000 words) Movie Review
Industrial New York: Filthy Cities & Triangle Fire
The immigrants’ children particularly suffered disease breakouts due to their “inexperienced” immune systems. As a result, immigrant parents changed the way they organized and planned their families. Prearranged extortion, payoffs,
2 pages (500 words) Movie Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation