StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Military Tribunals and the American Court System - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Military Tribunals and the American Court System

International agreements define the proper treatment of prisoners and the acceptable treatment of civilians during times of war. This has had a practical reason as it has traditionally prevented field commanders from committing atrocities that would so inflame the enemy that they would seek widespread revenge on their opponent. To assure that armies would keep war civilized, special processes have been set up to deal with those that transgress the rules and prearranged agreements. A court martial is often used to prosecute individuals of one's own armed forces. However, when the enemy is conquered and has violated the principle and sensibilities of the victor, they can become the defendants in a military tribunal, a seldom used process to handle unusual cases in unique situations.
This paper will explain the process of the military tribunal. It will discuss the history of US tribunals and their relevance to international events and conventions. It will define the difference between civilian courts, courts martial, and the military tribunal. It will further explore the requirements and rationalizations for holding a military tribunal as opposed to civilian courts. More importantly, it will discuss the constitutional evolution of the military tribunal and will examine key cases from the past. ...
This paper will not form any legal opinion on the constitutionality of the military tribunal. It also will not offer a social or political opinion of the process. These are beyond the scope of this research. It will, however, offer the rationale used by the courts and government officials to arrive at their various opinions. It will include both sides of the controversy as seen by those that are most directly involved. It will highlight the unusual cases in history that have created the controversy over congressional and presidential power with respect to military tribunals.
To begin a discussion of the military tribunal, it needs to be put into the context of more conventional and familiar court systems. The military tribunal differs from our civilian courts and a court martial in their purpose, approach, rules of evidence, and method of operation. Court martial is used to prosecute members of the military for criminal offenses that may be a violation of the articles of war or crime such as theft, violence, or criminal activity. They are similar to civilian courts in their guarantee of rights except that they make no allowance for a jury of peers. The jury is composed of appointed military officers. They do follow the same rules of evidence and due process for the defendant.
Where a civilian court is used to prosecute civilians who violate the civilian law, tribunals have historically been used for the purpose of prosecuting an armed service's personnel who have violated the articles of war or international agreements. However they have occasionally been used in extraordinary situations to control the civilian population. The war on terror has brought about new definitions of 'enemy combatant' and the current ...Show more

Summary

Since man began to go to war eons ago he has set out to make war more civilized. Over the centuries, this effort has culminated in national and international rules of war that are accepted, at least in principle, by the warring factions. These rules spell out the proper conduct of soldiers and the punishments for violations…
Author : dedrick27
Military Tribunals and the American Court System essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Military Tribunals and the American Court System"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Explain the federal court system in its entirety. Be sure to state and explain each of the courts that comprise the federal syst
The Federal Court system comprises of the trial courts, the Appellate Courts and the High Court. Each level follows a hierarchy of jurisdiction beginning from the most basic of trial courts that is the federal district courts until the court of last resort that is the Supreme Court.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
American Court System
The American court system was informed by the English common law and the English court system due to colonial ties. There were colonial courts with legislative and executive functions presided over by the local influential citizens appointed by the colonial government. They were closed down during the American Revolution and later re-established.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Are court and tribunals in the English legal system now indistinguishable in all important respects
Rather than exploring these very many arguments, we can somehow get around this by introducing a number of features that are associated with law are identified to highlight some of the characteristics of law in a practical sense. These include the features associated with law like a defined area where the law applies which in this case is the United Kingdom and the content of the law.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
The American Court System from Michael Savages View
Personified as people having to do with the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the National Lawyers Guild, and other extremist left-wing groups, they may appear to be invincible. However, if all freedom-loving Americans unite against them, they could cause this force to fall apart, Savage said.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
International Courts and Tribunals
Specifically, it defined parameters for crimes against humanity as a vital part of law. Though both tribunals at Tokyo and Nuremberg , and all successive trials held by various military tribunals, left inapplicable guidelines regarding war crimes and violations of human rights.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
American Criminal Justice and Terrorists
To what extent this is true has been contended in many articles by Times itself and later by a number of magazines. The cases of Arar3 and an estimated one hundred and fifty people are testimonies to the American Secret Extraordinary Rendition program. American legal system does not allow torture but then every terrorist or suspected terrorist undergoes torture of multiple varieties to a varying degree by the American Law Enforcement.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy
e during which, seeing how the American philosophy and the rule of law was being violated, “sued the president and secretary of defense over the new military-tribunal system”, Brenner writes in her article. Swift saw the torture his client had been going through. Salim Ahmad
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Unit 2 IPIntroduction to American Court System
Personal jurisdiction is the constitutional right of a defendant that he may have some interaction with the council of the court, so that the court can implement its power over the defendant. While, subject-matter
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Unit 3 Introduction to American Court System
Moreover, the interest of the parties ensures disclosure of significant evidence and highlights the limitations of the opponent’s case. For example, if a defendant in a case has a strong incentive to settle out of jail,
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Unit 4 DB Introduction to American Court System
Furthermore, the enforcement officer maintains the discretion of either charging or not charging the suspect on offences (U.S Department of Justice, 2012). The prosecutor’s discretion at the pre trial stage pertains to the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation