Patient Autonomy and Healthcare Beneficence - Essay Example

Extract of sample
Patient Autonomy and Healthcare Beneficence

Donchin criticized Engelhardt approach to autonomy and noted that the power and authority of physicians to act as gatekeepers selecting candidates for non-therapeutic elective procedures raised the different set of issues about limiting patient autonomy.
Tauber notes that patients lose their ability to make free choices because they are never fully informed. In his perception, by employing the term of adequate understanding, the patients themselves recognize the limits of their freedom and are more concerned with the process of healing and autonomy is rather the aspiration of the curing process. Verkerk and Keller analyzed patient autonomy in the context of care perspective or feministic approach. The patient care is focused on becoming more active and committed caregivers instead of adopting the non-interference attitude and respect of patient autonomy. The ideal of autonomy in terms of independence and self-sufficiency is criticized, while the idea of interdependence is emphasized. Dworkin, on the contrary, has covered the issue of autonomy from different perspectives starting with the Kantian concept of self-governance and ending with the feministic approach to autonomy.
Even though Dworkin does not use the word autonomy in his works, while discussing the idea of treating peop ...
Download paper


Today patients have access to wider range of information than ever before and the concept of autonomy has much changed. The critical analysis of patient-doctor relations can be divided into three perspectives: traditional, philosophical and feministic. Rothman talks about autonomy as the part of other social movements…
Author : nicolaanderson
Download 1

Related Essays

Personal Professional Development in Nursing
The code of professional conduct calls for a high standard of professional behaviour from the nurses, regulating the nursing and midwifery practice in order to ensure standards and proving protection for the clients. Nursing, in essence, is a care system that springs from safe, caring, and competent and educated decision making, and nurse is a professional who is willing to accept personal and professional accountability for evidence-based practice (Wiseman, 2007, 167-173)....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Conflict Resolution in Health Care Setting
Conflict resolution in the health setting requires the presence of intricate and complex competencies. Appropriate and relevant strategies help to reduce or mitigate problems in the health care setting. This research paper will study the scenario of a patient suffering from acute kidney failure. The patient has refused to be treated with dialysis which can improve quality of life. The scope of the paper will be concerned about implementing appropriate, ethical, and realistic conflict resolution methods. This paper will seek to use diverse research resources in order to deduce accurate and...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
The Evolution of leadership
These are very essential in ensuring patient's wellbeing. Workers in healthcare sectors also deserve to be treated fairly in order to serve patients well. Ethical issues in healthcare sector have also evolved with time. Initially, leaders in the healthcare sector were greatly concerned about the patients' welfare only. Later on the government made decisions that greatly helped in running of healthcare facility smoothly. (Bridgit, 2005)...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Patient Autonomy
It is not mere desiring but evaluation and weighing of alternatives by a person and selection based on her priorities. There are many ways we can discuss patient's autonomy....
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Healthcare Ethics Case Study
As part of his training, Alex is rotating through the emergency room and has been asked to take x-rays of the head and neck of an alert yet seriously injured patient Mr. Hanson. The x-ray supervisor/instructor, Ms. Dubois, is present when Alex attempts the x-rays that require the patient to be manipulated into particular and potentially painful positions. Nothing is said to the patient other than "we are going to take some x-rays sir!" After three unsuccessful attempts, the patient complains about the pain and the x-ray supervisor takes over and completes the procedures with success....
3 pages (753 words) Case Study
Leadership in The Healthcare Sector
These codes can be viewed as a formulation of personal responsibility. The most identifiable significance being the mode of commitment that an individual possesses. In general, sense the code possesses all aspects of professional situation as both a human and a proficient member of the organization. It is obvious that an organization is formed with human aspects and for an organization to become ethical, it is important the human aspects be indulged into following the code. It is imperative that these codes of ethics would be subjective and open to individual interpretations but it should also...
17 pages (4267 words) Essay
Autonomy-in regards to decision making in healthcare and research
The medical professional is therefore within the confinements of ethical judgment that the individual autonomy is respected. Beauchamp and Childress (2008) highlighted the four main ethical principles as discussed below....
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!