StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Martha Stewart - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Martha Stewart

She was the CEO of her own multi-million dollar empire who was now facing felony time at Alderson Federal Penitentiary for what amounted to pocket change for Ms. Stewart. How could things have gone so wrong for Martha? Could her attorneys have done something to present a more strategic defense for her case in an effort to minimize her sentence? Martha's case was a classic white-collar crime, and her troubles began shortly after selling ImClone stock based on insider information, a crime known as insider trading. She was contacted by the FBI and US Attorneys in January 2002 and scheduled an interview with them for the first week in February This was the first of several legal errors made in Martha's case. Martha, absent an attorney, ended up lying to the investigators during her initial interview
A good defense would have been to exercise her right to remain silent. (Bennett, 2006). Defense attorneys familiar with white-collar crime all generally agree that cooperating with the authorities is not a good thing. The most common legal advice is, "not to give statements or otherwise cooperate with investigators until you’ve talked with an attorney" (Bennett, 2006). The most common defenses against financial crime are insanity, intoxication, incapacity, and duress. Most of her contemporary white-collar criminals say simply they were out of the loop and just did not know. This is known as the "Absence of Intent" defense which Enron, WorldCom, and others have popularized in the recent months. Entrapment is another common defense used in white-collar cases. The defendant claims they could not have committed the crime without the aid of the investigators. This defense is most often used after lengthy undercover investigations and would not have been usable in Stewart's case.
Martha's initial error of lying without legal counsel was compounded by her attorney's failure to reach a plea agreement and allowing the case to go to trial. As many as 87% of federal fraud cases are settled with plea agreements and there is a sound legal reason for it. Sentencing can be negotiated during a plea agreement, but a judge is under strict restrictions and has to conform to federal guidelines when imposing punishment after a guilty verdict in a trial (France, 2004). The issue of Martha not testifying in her own behalf has also been criticized, though when a defendant takes the stand in a white collar case the defense runs the risk of the jury forgetting that the government has to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt (France, 2004). The jury found Ms. Stewart guilty of lying to investigators and she received a sentence of 5 months in prison and 5 months on home detention. This was at the minimum end of the federal guidelines and below the national average of 15.7 months prison time (US Sentencing Commission, 2003).
The simple sale of a stock for what amounted to a few dollars drastically altered Martha's world. In a statement shortly after her release she commented, "The experience of the last five months ... has been life altering and life affirming" (Porteus, 2005). However, the damage that the trial did to Martha's image will be long lasting and costly. As a convicted felon, there will be restrictions placed on her ability to operate in certain financial positions. She has been denied entry into Canada and the conviction has scarred her status as a product spokesperson. The price of Martha Stewart stock took an initial beating and after 4 years has just returned to the level it was before the indictment. With the incident behind her, Martha has moved on with some new television programming, a successful talk and domestic show, and "Living". It just goes to prove that it's hard to keep a good thing down. ...Show more

Summary

Martha Stewart, America's best known Domestic Diva, was recently charged with securities fraud, convicted of obstruction of justice and sentenced to Federal Prison. Stewart had earlier been forced to resign from her position on the board of directors of the New York Stock Exchange. …
Author : knienow
Martha Stewart essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Martha Stewart"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Staples Organization Essay
Its headquarters is in Massachusetts in the United States. Also, Staples does business with enterprises in various countries in Europe operating as Staples Advantage (Staples Advantage, 2012). As an organization in the retail industry, Staples sells promotional products, business services, technology, office machines, and furniture both online and in stores.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Martha Stewart Unethical Practices
Martha’s website offers an entertainment product classification. The classification offers current and prospective customers to buy her regularly printed Mart’s Entertaining journal. The classification offers products relating to cocktails.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Case study of Union carbide and Bhopal
Either insider trading can be legal or illegal depending on whether the information relied upon is public or non-public. The presidents of the firms, foremost shareholders, lawyers, accountants and other imperative employees are among the populace who may perhaps have right of entry to the non-public information.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Martha Stewart and her Insider Trading
Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia is a foremost supplier of unique ‘how to’ substance and products for the home. The ‘Martha Stewart’ brand is leveraged across four business sections - Publishing, Television, Merchandising, and Internet/Direct Commerce.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Martha Stewart's Case Analysis
es beyond these factors to consider the personal life of Martha Stewart herself as a potential factor to take into consideration given the central importance of her personality to the success of the business. The MSLO business model report highlights the focus of the business
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
The trial of Martha Stewart essay question type
There was some information that suggests that this agreement was tampered with. Stewart denies this allegation. Stewart claims that she did not knowing sell her shares on that date because of anything other than her preexisting agreement, while testimony from
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Staples
As an organization in the retail industry, Staples sells promotional products, business services, technology, office machines, and furniture both online and in stores. This discussion will focus on Staples Organization;
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Text of chapter 7 has been downloaded and attached -Resources: Ch. 7 of Society Compose an APA formatted 200- to 300-word response to the following:
According to Merton, the strain between our culture’s emphasis on success and the lack of the means of some to attain it may encourage some people—especially the poor—to do drugs and to steal.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Martha Stewart unethical practices
Martha’s website, http://www.marthastewart.com/crafts, displays many of her business products. The business products include kids’ accessories, Crepe –paper
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Martha Stewart fraud case - Codes of ethics in business
She became one of the popular business entrepreneurs through her written electronic commerce books and magazines. Martha Stewart convicted of several legal charges, such as ImClone insider trading affair in the year 2004.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation