Judge Making the Decision - Case Study Example

Summary

Before this court is the age old issue of venue. Plaintiff, Lynn Cheney has alleged that the defendant Dick Cheney, has been engaged in an extra marital affair with Rush Limbaugh. Defendant, Dick Cheney, has denied the allegations and in support of his motion to dismiss the divorce complaint has attached a supporting affidavit of Limbaugh who has explained that there is a misunderstanding and that "sometimes oxycotin makes me do crazy things" (Affidavit at 4)…

Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful

Read Text Preview

Subject: Miscellaneous
Type: Case Study
Level: College
Pages: 3 (750 words)
Downloads: 2
Author: nfunk

Extract of sample "Judge Making the Decision"

Download file to see previous pages

If the court discovers it does not have jurisdictional rights to hear the case it will not be accepted or it will eventually be dismissed. The requirements stand thus: No divorce shall be granted unless the plaintiff has resided in this state for sixty (60) days immediately preceding the time of filing the complaint, or the marriage was solemnized in this state and the plaintiff has resided in this state from the time of the marriage until the filing of the complaint. A married person who at the time of filing a complaint for divorce resides in this state is a resident although his spouse may reside elsewhere.

A divorce may be filed in the district court of the county in which either party resides. (Wyoming Statutes - Title 20 - Chapters: 20-2-104, 20-2-107 and 20-2-108). The Complaint for Divorce must declare the appropriate Wyoming grounds upon which the divorce is being sought. The appropriate lawful ground will be that which the parties agree upon and can substantiate, or that which the filing spouse desires to prove to the court. The divorce grounds are as follows: To obtain a No-Fault divorce the plaintiff must allege Irreconcilable differences in the marital relationship.

To obtain a divorce based upon Fault, the plaintiff must allege that defendant is incurably insane and the insane person has been confined in a mental hospital of this state or of another state or territory for at least two (2) years immediately preceding the commencement of the action for divorce. (Wyoming Statutes - Title 20 - Chapters: 20-2-104, 20-2-105) Here, plaintiff merely alleges a homosexual affair. Assuming arguendo that the allegations are true, they amount to nothing more than a charge of adultery which is not grounds for divorce in this state.

Furthermore, plaintiff has not alleged in her complaint the requisite jurisdictional predicates for this court to take jurisdiction of this matter. She merely alleges that the parties own land in this state. The record reflects no reason for this court to presume that the plaintiff resides in this state or that she has for the past sixty days. Accordingly, and based upon the foregoing the complaint is dismissed without prejudice.

...Download file to see next pages Read More

Cite this document

APA
MLA
CHICAGO

(“Judge Making the Decision Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Judge Making the Decision Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507270-judge-making-the-decision

(Judge Making the Decision Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Judge Making the Decision Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507270-judge-making-the-decision.

“Judge Making the Decision Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507270-judge-making-the-decision.

Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judge Making the Decision

The Role of Judges in Making Law in UK Courts

The legal systems of United Kingdom owe their origin to judges who made laws in the course of their decision making.... An expression made by a judge as a basis of his judgment becomes the precedent making it binding on future decision making until its validly controverted by another judge.... The thesis of this paper is how judges help molding of law through their decisions and help future of course of action by law making body i.... (Commentaries pp 88-9) Later Lord Esher said in 1892 that there was no judge made law as such since the judges did not make law but only applied prevailing law not previously applied authoritatively (Willis v Baddeley) However these views are refuted by late professor Cross stating "a rule stated in a precedent is law properly so called and law because it was made by the judges, not because it originated in common usage, or the judge's idea of justice and public convenience" (Cross R 1991 p 28) Cross holds that Lord Esher's view that application of existing law to new circumstances actually is similar to statement of...

9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Appointment of Supreme Court Judges

Of course, the qualification, experience, and decision making capabilities are also analyzed and form an integral part of the appointment process.... owever, there are instances where Supreme Court decision was opposite to what the President would have wanted.... egardless of the nomination and appointment process of the Supreme Court Judges, the American citizens believe and trust that the Judge would evaluate all facets of the case before making his/ her judgment....

2 Pages (500 words) Literature review

The Impact of Race on Sentencing within the US Criminal Justice System

Supreme Court decision was that these burning acts are part of the First Amendment benefits.... The society today often causes irrational behavior among the members of society even to the point making them violate the law.... The Society in the American horizon confronts daily challenges when its institutions that are mandated to bring equality to the justice system in society do not meet the benchmark in terms of justice....

10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Doctrine of Precedent

The doctrine of precedent is defined as 'The common law principle which binds a judge or a magistrate to follow a previous similar decision of higher courts in the same hierarchy; also known as stare decisis' (Vickery & Pendleton 2006), which implies the decision stands.... There are binding and persuasive precedents, of which binding precedents are known as 'ratio decidendi' when the final order or 'res judicata' by the court is made to the immediate parties, and it has a legal effect based on the key reasons for the decision....

9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Decision-Making of the Judge Advocates General

The paper "the decision-Making of the Judge Advocates General" discusses the law-governed system.... However, the same reasoning makes deliberation and decision-making processes difficult because the officers have to consider the informant.... During the hearing, the judges claimed that they have proof against the prisoner, making him a threat to humanity....

8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Influences on Judicial Decision Making

the decision making process is critical in making any judgment as it can mean that justice can be administered or not.... Judicial Precedent-in some cases the decision made in one case acts as a link or Influences on Judicial Decision Making al Affiliation the decision making process by various judges is influenced by various factors as we shall establish in this activity.... the decision making process is critical in making any judgment as it can mean that justice can be administered or not....

1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Legal Interpretation is an Arbitrary Activity

A judge might cite several aspects from which he or she makes the decision.... This is a difficult question to answer because normally the decision comes from the judges and they are the ones who know what they look at before reaching the decision4.... An arbitrary decision can be defined as one that is determined by impulse and chance and not by reason or principle.... This type of decision is made based on individual judgment or preference....

8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Judges Make Law and Legal System of the United Kingdom

The author outlines that the judges while making the decision should take into account the existing laws, precedents, and statutory requirements.... the decision of a judge can be binding at a later stage for other judges to follow while deciding the comparable cases.... This work called "Judges Make Law" describes the judge's power to make law indicates that the law-making power is not unbridled.... n in-depth study of the English legal system identifies its dependence on the judge's made laws emanate from the decisions of the competent jurisdictions....

8 Pages (2000 words) Essay