StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Lau v. Nichols - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet
The situation was then addressed in Lau v. Nichols, which was instituted in 1974 as a remedy, but the decision did not specify a teaching method, and the approach could be "bilingual instruction, English as a second language (ESL) classes or some other approach" (Crawford, para. 1). This broad interpretation has caused a great deal of controversy over the years.
Lau was intended to give limited-English-proficient students (LEP) the opportunity to gain the proficiency they needed, but, unfortunately, according to Crawford, a symposium held twenty years after Lau indicates there has been little improvement in the effort to create equity for LEP students. Without one specific method of teaching LEP students, the effort becomes lost, with well-designed programs staffed by qualified teachers available to only a fraction of LEP students.
The term "bilingual education" has come to mean a "range of instructional programs for children whose native language is not English," while the best way to accommodate such children has been and continues to be an area of debate. As noted in a research project by the Westchester Institute in New York, the debate centers on the "role of native language in instruction-whether it should be used and for how long" (Westchester, para. 3). Supporters of native language instruction recommend aggressive development of the primary language prior to introduction of English, while proponents of all-English instruction feel that the English curriculum should be introduced at the very beginning of the student's school experience with minimal use of the native language (Westchester).
English Immersion in California Public Schools
If the use of bilingual education actually meant learning two languages equally well, it might be a feasible program for all students, not just LEP students. Unfortunately, the concept has not been incorporated in public schools, and according to Ron Unz, advocate of English-only instruction, what is called bilingual education actually consists of mostly Spanish language instructions with little English incorporated into teaching. Since over half of America's LED students were born in the United States with most of the remainder coming here at a young age, the argument that older students have a more difficult time learning English covers only a small percentage of LED students (Sailer). Comparing the English immersion program with the bilingual program, English-only instruction would appear to be more successful, not because it is necessarily a better program but because the bilingual method is not being well utilized.
Respected author Maxine Hong Kingston was born in California and in her biographical novel Woman Warrior: Memoirs of a Girlhood Among Ghosts, she recognizes the language and cultural barriers she faced during her childhood. She attended both public school and Chinese school, and her family mostly consisted of Chinese immigrants, who labeled anyone not Chinese as "ghosts." The idea of a bilingual education at that time did not exist, and Kingston had to learn English in order to communicate with English-speaking students, teachers, and business people. Even so, for her, the cultural barriers were far more difficult to overcome.
Propositions 227 and 203
Proposition 227, passed in 1998, ...Show more

Summary

Prior to 1974, children in the United States without previous knowledge of the English language were not always given the opportunity to learn it and were therefore deprived of an equal education, since classes in public schools were conducted in English. In 1971, the San Francisco, California, school system was integrated as a result of a federal court decree (Beyond Brown)…
Author : rutherfordking
Lau v. Nichols essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Lau v. Nichols"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Henry V
Derek Jacobi is the narrator, also known as the Chorus. He appears at various times of the story interjecting lines from the original play by Shakespeare. The film received immense critical acclaim for the direction and genius acting of Kenneth Branagh, who was nominated for an Oscar for the great Shakespearean language and acting.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
History of ELL and Bilingual Trasition Education
Statistical data reports that Arizona contains a total of 1,742 public schools and 48% of this tally accounts for minority students. In other words, this means that 16.1% of the total numbers are ELL students and an additional 19% languish in poverty. The main goal for this proposal in repealing the existing inconsiderate education laws and conventions and transform the laws for them to embrace the provision that all teachers must teach all classes in English.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Florida v. Harris and Florida v. ardines
Various concurring and dissenting opinions are revealed during the hearings of the cases and all circumstances are carefully accounted for before reaching final conclusion. References to past legal cases are very critical as situations of most of the cases resemble to those in older ones
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The Rise of Public Education
Producing good citizens was to be the goal of education. Plato envisioned two tracks for education. One system was for the lower class (made up of artisans and craftsmen), those he did not consider to be citizens. Plato
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Roe v. Wade or Miranda v. Arizona
on, made without any assurance of protection or threats and “with complete familiarity of his legal privileges, including any declaration which he made might be employed against him. Later, Miranda’s admission was allowed into testimony at the trial, and he was sentenced
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Creating a Plan for a Culturally Diverse Classroom
Entry and exit procedures for bilingual programs have been severely criticized over the years. Children have been inappropriately assigned to native language classrooms due to the use of unreliable tests. Once enrolled, students have been wrongfully kept in bilingual programs, years beyond the time they needed it.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Work Life Balance: A Study To Examine Flexibility In The Workplace And Its Contribution To Organisational Efficiency at Harvey Nichols'
Moreover, the advantages of having a flexibility option within their company include permitting employees to pursue their interests and
40 pages (10000 words) Essay
Henry V
war and conflict is thematically expressed in Henry V where the previously rash prince claims the throne after the death of father in a chaotic environment. As Henry V assumes the responsibilities of a King, further issues await him including rebuilding the trust of his people
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Henry V
war and conflict is thematically expressed in Henry V where the previously rash prince claims the throne after the death of father in a chaotic environment. As Henry V assumes the responsibilities of a King, further issues await him including rebuilding the trust of his people
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Roger Ebert Review Nichols, Why are Ethical issues central to Documentary Filmmaking
The directors often get sued when they fail to respect the dignity and social rights of their subjects. Michael Moores, the director of Roger and Me, is an exemplary
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation