StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

A critical response to Donald Davidsons views of self-deception - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
A critical response to Donald Davidsons views of self-deception

Such event, according to the theory, will "permit" the idea that an individual may at any given time cling to incongruous viewpoints and ambiguous judgments about her/him or about a given state of affairs. The concept, Davidson contends, is that if parts of the mind are, to some degree or level, independent, we can comprehend how they are able to entertain and embrace inconsistencies, contradictions and variations, and to intermingle and cooperate on a causal level. This, I beg to disagree. If we take a cursory glimpse, Davidson's account offers a fascinating depiction of self-deception. It seemed to naturally and readily settle the absurdity and the irony of the concept. Nonetheless, if we investigate seriously the sketch of this phenomenon on the "divided-mind" paradigm, grave doubts and opposing protestations will come to our mind.However, before explicitly elucidating my disagreement, let me first discuss another angle that runs parallel to Davidson's idea of the divided-mind occurrence - Freud's embodiment of the human mind consisting of an ego, super-ego, and id. To the Freudian picture, the ego matches up with the conscious part of the mind, while the super-ego and the id, to the unconscious. The id is steered by impulses, cravings and desires; as the super-ego flushes out the "undesirables" conceived by the id, the ego puts things into action. A Freudian version of self-deception, then, would justify for the absurd possession of diametrically opposed beliefs. The unconscious id discerns and understands that p, but is compelled by a desire to believe that not-p, so it "cooperates" or "works together" with the super-ego to deceive the ego. In this scenario, the agent may deliberately and knowingly assumes a belief this same agent instinctively knows to be false, but the fact that this belief is false is one way or another "concealed" from such agent. In this manner, self-deception becomes unequivocally comparable to interpersonal deception, with two agent-like structures misleading/deceiving a third into believing something they know to be false.
Though desisting to succumb to the Freudian concepts of ego, super-ego and id, Davidson concurs with Freud that particular facets of the mind must be put forward in order to explain self-deception or absurdity of any kind:
[First,]the mind is to be regarded as having two or more semi-autonomous structures.
[Second, we assign] a particular kind of structure to one or more subdivisions of the mind: a structure similar to that needed to explain ordinary actions.
[Third,]certain mental events take on the character of mere causes relative to some other mental events in the same mind. [I]n order to accommodate [this feature] we must allow a degree of autonomy to parts of the mind (Davidson 1982)

As Davidson puts it, one psychological event can be a cause of but not a sufficient reason for another mental event. Certainly, this framework can be a probable occurrence in interpersonal interaction. For instance -- I yearn for Mr. X to be inside my bedroom, so, I positioned a hundred scented candles of different sizes and colors in strategic places, allow some erotic music to reverberate inside the room and open the door a few inches apart just enough for Mr. X to have a wondrous peek of what's inside and what he can expect if he gets in. As he saw what's in store for him inside that room, he then craves to enter and will want to ...Show more

Summary

One of the most widely held notions of self-deception is that of Donald Davidson which makes the effort to elucidate the paradox through the view that there are simultaneous divisions within the mind itself …
Author : sgoyette
A critical response to Donald Davidsons views of self-deception essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"A critical response to Donald Davidsons views of self-deception"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Critical Response: Paper 3
They have discussed the period of 1945-61 which pertains to Vietnam and how varied aspects of its domains were highlighted in essence. The authors have also emphasized a great deal on the way under which the Japanese played their part at capturing Indochina so that the will of the Vietnamese could be exerted in essence1.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Hamlet is Essentially the Victim of his own Deception: A Critical Approach
Hamlet despises deception, and craves for truth and honesty more than most other characters do in the play. Ironically Hamlet himself resorts to deceptions and lies in order to discover the truth about the regicide, and, in the long run, he himself is ensnared in his own lie and deception.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Leadership and Self Deception
In other words it blinds people from the surrounding reality and tends to undermine the performance of others (Warner, 2002). Eventually, it results to conflicts between people. In relation to this, self deception stands so central to leadership since leadership focuses on improving situations.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Critical Response: Paper 2
Addressing this first issue, of the Korean War laying the groundwork for the Vietnam War, this item is clearly debatable. Many factors went into the Vietnam War, and the United
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Critical response
While doing this, she does not fail to depict how narrow-mindedness, racism and gender discrimination was instrumental in bringing her to the place she finds herself. Women are at time under turbulent situations because of the heap of responsibilities that the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Deception
The John McCain ad is considered to be a negative one against Obama as it tries to put him in bad light. In the Ad John McCain diminishes president Barrack Obama as the biggest celebrity in the world. In his ad McCain compares
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Critical Response
The other core component of liberalism is that the government has to limit the activities it conducts. Thus, the government should only carry out the activities, which it is supposed to carry and leave the rest to other agencies in society. One
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Critical Self-Reflection Essay
It is important as it allows one as an individual to view the world from a different perspective and get a better understanding of other people’s
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Critical Self-Reflection Essay
Critical thinking exhibits a measure of self-direction and aims at correcting the self. It is a pathway towards a more meaningful life because critical thinkers begin by conducting a critical analysis of the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Paper about self deception
Based on this definition, racial stereotypes include people’s perspectives about certain racial or ethnic groups which are generally false or unfavorable. Stereotyping others origin from the tendency to consider things in categories so that
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation