Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis

In 1983, she told her life story to Elisabeth Burgos Debray, which resulted in a book called in English, "I, Rigoberta Mench". Over the years, Rigoberta Mench has become a strong advocate of Indian rights and ethno-cultural reconciliation, and has garnered many international awards for her work.
After more than a decade from the publication of "I, Rigoberta Menchu", a controversy sparked regarding the veracity of the details contained in the publication, largely initiated by anthropologist Dr. David Stoll. Soon after various academics and journalists published their own studies related to the issue, including essays and articles about the genre used in Rigoberta's book, the testimonio.
The controversy revolves around the overarching question of whether or not an autobiography should represent the exact details of a person's life; whether or not this is a uniquely Western expectation, and whether or not the expectation of "truth" is the same from a non-Western genre such as a testimonio or oral autobiography.
This essay takes a look at the issue of veracity or truth in "I, Rigoberta Menchu" and the various positions taken by different authors on the subject. ...
Download paper


Rigoberta Menchu Tum was the recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize in 1992. According to Les Prix Nobel (1993), Rigoberta Mench came from a poor Indian peasant family and grew up in the Quiche branch of the Mayan culture. She became involved in social reform activities through the Catholic Church, and became prominent in the women's rights movement…
Author : irunolfsson

Related Essays

Synthesis Essay
The author applies these differences specifically in the way the sexes manage a business organization. While women "tend to soften their demands and statements," men opt to give direct orders. Generally, women are also apt in asking more questions than man. The article stressed that culture is pivotal in this distinctions. Women are raised to be more nurturing and maintain harmonious relationships while men aren't. The author, however, emphasize that generalization about the characteristics of men and women based on the way they communicate are invalid.
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Rigoberta Menchs Book
I am 23 years old. I would like to give this testimony live that I have not learned from a book and neither have I learned alone yet that all this have I learned from my village. It cost me much to remember all the life that I have lived, so many times there are times very black and there are times that, yes, are enjoyable also but the most important is, I believe, that I want to emphasize that I am not the only one, so have lived many people and it is the life of all. The life of all the poor Guatemalans and I will try to give a bit of history. My personal situation includes all the reality...
6 pages (1506 words) Scholarship Essay
Unilever AxeDove controversy
Unilever AxeDove controversy
8 pages (2008 words) Case Study
Controversy in Television Advertisement
Cigarette manufacturers were one of the first industries to advertise widely on television ("Lighten Up & Light Up," 2006). Tobacco advertising is the promotion of tobacco use (typically cigarette smoking) by the tobacco industry through a variety of media ("Tobacco advertising," 2007). Usually, this is more attractive to the younger population because of their overexposure to tobacco commercials shown on television. Considered as "one of the most-highly-regulated forms of marketing," it is banned by many countries around the world.
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Accounts from Guatemala: Critical Reception of the Works of Rigoberta Menchu
The situation in Guatemala is similar to South Africa, where the black majority is ruled with absolute power by the white minority. Like South Africa, the Indians in Guatemala are lacking in even the most basic of human rights. 'Indeed the so-called forest Indians are being systematically exterminated in the name of progress. But unlike the Indian rebels of the past, who wanted to go back to pre-Columbian times, Rigoberta Menchu is not fighting in the name of an idealized or mythical past.' (Menchu xiii) Rigoberta is working toward drawing attention to the plight of native people around the...
6 pages (1506 words) Book Report/Review
synthesis essay
However, Hennessy Youngman whose Art Thoughtz take the form of tutorial to educate his viewers about the contemporary art issues; has successfully taken the issue of racial segregation based on skin color by it horns. Whenever blacks are ridiculed, they get angry and sometimes could act violently to their opponents; Youngman reminds the black who get angry that their anger is marketable (Rankine 33). He does not address the actual anger that can turn into a physical fight, but rather the anger built upon through experience and the quotidian struggles against dehumanization that every black...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!