StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis

In 1983, she told her life story to Elisabeth Burgos Debray, which resulted in a book called in English, "I, Rigoberta Mench". Over the years, Rigoberta Mench has become a strong advocate of Indian rights and ethno-cultural reconciliation, and has garnered many international awards for her work.
After more than a decade from the publication of "I, Rigoberta Menchu", a controversy sparked regarding the veracity of the details contained in the publication, largely initiated by anthropologist Dr. David Stoll. Soon after various academics and journalists published their own studies related to the issue, including essays and articles about the genre used in Rigoberta's book, the testimonio.
The controversy revolves around the overarching question of whether or not an autobiography should represent the exact details of a person's life; whether or not this is a uniquely Western expectation, and whether or not the expectation of "truth" is the same from a non-Western genre such as a testimonio or oral autobiography.
This essay takes a look at the issue of veracity or truth in "I, Rigoberta Menchu" and the various positions taken by different authors on the subject. It also discusses the concept of the testimonio genre and the position taken by various authors on why the understanding of this genre is central to the Menchu controversy. It concludes with the position taken by this essay's author on the extent to which the problems of truth in Menchu's book matter, as well as the author's position on the debate related to the testimonio genre.
The Issue of Truth
David Stoll (1999), in his book "Rigoberta Mench and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans" claims that Mench's book "is not the eyewitness account that it purports to be". He also poses the question, "If part of the laureate's story is not true, does it matter" Stoll's answer to his own question is that it matters. The contradictions between Rigoberta's version, that of neighbors, and the documentary record creates confusion on the reasons for why the killings took place. According to Rigoberta's version (Menchu, 1984), the killings were part of military oppression of the peasantry. According to Stoll's findings, from interviews he conducted, the killings were caused by both guerillas and the military. Stoll proposed that the reason of Rigoberta's particular version is actually propaganda to further the cause of the guerillas and solicit international sympathy. Stoll also argued that "truth" is important because it has international repercussions in the way human rights violations are reported, how people will react, and how events will be interpreted as to implications for the future world of human rights activism, journalism, and scholarship. Stoll seems to further argue that since Rigoberta Menchu has become a symbol for a cause, especially since she has become a Nobel laureate and has told a story that is largely true, the contradictions in her version with other accounts should be put to straight.
Dinesh D'Souza is a writer and public speaker who had written an article in The Weekly Standard in 1999 regarding his own views about the Menchu controversy. In his article he mentioned his book called "Illiberal Education" wherein he had criticized "I, Rigoberta Menchu" as a bogus ...Show more


Rigoberta Menchu Tum was the recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize in 1992. According to Les Prix Nobel (1993), Rigoberta Mench came from a poor Indian peasant family and grew up in the Quiche branch of the Mayan culture. She became involved in social reform activities through the Catholic Church, and became prominent in the women's rights movement…
Author : irunolfsson
Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis Essay essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Rigoberta Menchu Controversy Synthesis Essay"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Rigoberta Menchs I Rigoberta Menchu and Peter Winns Weavers of Revolution
As a means of providing a particular level of inference based upon these two nations, the following two books will be analyzed: Rigoberta Menchú’s I Rigoberta Menchu and Peter Winn’s Weavers of Revolution.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Synthesis Essay
Thiederman focused on how the workplace becomes a venue that these distinctions and acknowledged the huge contribution of culture on this differences. Even if aggravating and frustrating, Thiederman regards the different communication techniques used by men and women as a source of fun.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Rigoberta Menchu
Like South Africa, the Indians in Guatemala are lacking in even the most basic of human rights. Indeed the so-called forest Indians are being systematically exterminated in the name of progress. But unlike
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Rigoberta Menchu An Indian woman in Guatemala
Her story was given in the form of a series of interview in 1982 and later published in the form of a book in 1983 named “Me Llamo Rigoberta Menchu Y Asi Me Nacio La Conciencia” later translated into English as
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Synthesis Research Essay
lows: “Examination of a model of multiple sociocultural influences on adolescent girls’ body dissatisfaction and dietary restraint” by Dunkley et al (2001), “The healthful art of dancing: Luther Halsey Gulick, Gender, the body and the performativity of national
6 pages (1000 words) Essay
Synthesis essay
The author gives the main reason for not owning a computer is that he does not want to fool himself as he believes that one is able to write well with a pencil that when there is use of a computer. In a reply to the
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation