StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Radiographer Training in the Red Dot System: A Comparison of Articles - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Radiographer Training in the Red Dot System: A Comparison of Articles

These medical professionals are in need of further education and, though obviously dedicated, are most often "left with limited local educational support to continue in their clinical role in A & E." (McConnell and Webster 2000: 608) The question has been raised as to the effectiveness of offering a short course of training to these radiographers and, once further instruction has been completed, whether there is a statistically significant improvement in their performance. In the two studies cited above, the authors have undertaken the task of analyzing the skills of radiographers in various hospitals, providing them with a programme of instruction, and then evaluating any significant improvement in their performance. There are three quantifiable categories for this analysis: Sensitivity, which is the ability to spot traumatic abnormalities; Specificity, which is the ability to identify normal skeletal appearance; and Accuracy, which is the overall ability to provide the casualty officer with useful, precise information. The scope of this paper is to critically evaluate and compare the two articles.
The stated purpose and objectives of the two articles are clearly similar; as articulated by Hargreaves and Mackay, the studies are "aimed to investigate whether the introduction of a training programme for radiographers...could increase their ability to exclude fractures within a red dot system." (2003: 283) While both articles undertake and accomplish this task with varying degrees of clarity, the format and layout of the Hargreaves article provides a clearer statement of the intent of the study. The McConnell paper uses a textual abstract to frame the issue and, though sufficient for the purpose of outlining the content of the piece, it infers the objective more obliquely. The reader clearly understands the purpose and objectives only after reading both the abstract and the article. Hargreaves, however, provides a clear statement of the specific purpose at the beginning of the article, making the focus of the piece clearer from the start. This discrepancy can perhaps be accounted for by noting that the earlier article, McConnell, is addressing the somewhat narrower parameter of a "short course of study" within the context of a needs-analysis survey (2000: 608) while Hargreaves, which relies on McConnell as a source in its works cited, undertakes the broader question of generally improving performance through training without the constraints of survey parameters or course length. In terms of clarity, the more recent piece does a better job of stating the purpose and objectives through its format which allows the reader to come into the article knowing exactly what the purpose and objectives are.

Results - presentation and ease of interpretation
Both articles offer a clear presentation of their conclusions, substantiated by data tables or statistical figures. In their discussion sections, the interpretation of the data is clearly articulated and referenced. Both rely on the combination of narrative and tabular data sets to establish the results of their study. When the text of the discussion is read in conjunction with the data, the reader is able to easily understand the information ...Show more


The red dot system is a process whereby a radiographer marks any acute abnormalities he or she sees on a radiograph using a small red sticker (Hargreaves and Mackay 2003: 283). The casualty officer uses these highlights as guideposts in determining the best course of action in treating the patient…
Author : tomasa68
Radiographer Training in the Red Dot System: A Comparison of Articles essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Radiographer Training in the Red Dot System: A Comparison of Articles"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Comparison and Contrast of Two Articles
Beyrer’s (2010) “Online Student Success: Making a Difference,” on the other hand, investigated the effectivity of an online instructional course; that will orient students in the technicalities associated with taking a course via the web. The former article compared the two teaching platforms--online and face-to-face; and sought to analyze and evaluate the efficiency with which it channels student achievement.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Articles Comparison
The first essay also gives a description of people handling complex matters to some extent even without the interference of experts taking help of newly invented instruments. The purpose here is not only to give attention to common people but also making people aware of those great minds behind such extraordinary devices.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Resourcing Rewarding and Training System
Essay Resourcing Rewarding and Training System Welltasty, an organization which specializes in manufacturing pre-packed sandwiches and snacks is suffering from serious HR related issues due to sudden accelerated pace of growth in production. The workforce of the organization mostly comprises of unskilled workers, who are working as part time or agency workers.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Comparison between training day and adjustment buerau
It therefore means that ethics exclusively address the logical and reasoned ways of interpretation of the issues that we engage with during all activities in life. Ethics help and guide individuals in making rational decisions when faced with scenarios that need moral judgments that reflect personal values, by developing clear analytical skills in reasoning abilities to understand the crucial decisions that have to be made.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Windows File System Comparison
File systems may use a storage device such as a hard disk or CD-ROM and involve maintaining the physical location of the files, or they may seem virtual and exist only as an access method for virtual data or for data over a network. In this paper, only the different file systems being used by windows will be discussed.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
As Dawson et al(2004) state , "Two objectives at the fore of the NHS policy agenda are to develop systems for increasing patient choice and to find mechanisms that will increase effective capacity for treatment of NHS patients on waiting lists. The London Patient Choice Project (LPCP) was one of several initiatives in England to introduce elements of choice and to expand capacity.
30 pages (7500 words) Essay
Research Tools and their Effectiveness

The research under scrutiny is conducted in a sensitive environment where they are being tested using community health services in two different scenarios. It has two settings; one is before training while the other is after. This is to take note of the level of radiograph each scenario can administer with the community physiotherapists at heart.

8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Summary of 3 articles , comparison and discussion
In recent years, big data has gained increased popularity of sources comprising social media, user-generated content, mobile transactions and internet clicks (George, Haas and Pentland, 2014, p.321). Other added big data
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Comparison of research articles
As such, a huge number of parents and caretakers have developed fears concerning the likely etiological role that vaccinations might play
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Comparison of Political System
According to the report America was a colony of the British. America wanted to break free from the European ties of the old times and have its system. The need arose to create a political system that was different from other countries in the world. Americas system bases on federalism distributing power among the 13 original states while Britain is a constitutional monarchy.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us