StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Critically evaluate Hope and Fraser's (1997) arguments and the reasons for their arguments - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Critically evaluate Hope and Fraser's (1997) arguments and the reasons for their arguments

After ascertaining this, the limits of the budget follows.
A budget, to be useful to a manager at any level, must reflect the organization pattern. When plans are complete and coordinated very well to fit into the departmental operations, the department budget becomes useful as an instrument of control.
Budgeting, Hope and Fraser (1997:22) argue, should be dispensed with because it: "strengthens the vertical chain of command and control rather than empowering managers. It constrains rather than increases flexibility and responsiveness. It reinforces departmental barriers rather than encouraging knowledge-sharing across the organization. It makes people feel undervalued as 'costs to be minimized' rather than assets to be developed. And it is bureaucratic, internally focused and time-consuming." That is quite a diatribe. Yet, it seems from anecdotal and other evidence that budgeting remains 'alive and well' in most organizations.
First, there is a risk of overdoing the budget by way of spelling out minor expenses in detail that deprive managers of the needed freedom in managing their units. For instance, a department head in a poorly budgeted company was hampered in a very important sales promotion because expenditures for office equipment exceeded budgetary estimates.
Such being the same, the new expenditures had to ...
Such being the same, the new expenditures had to be limited, even though his total expenses in his unit where within the budget and he had funds to pay personnel for writing sales promotional letters. In another case, a department's expenses were budgeted in such less important details that the actual budgeting cost of many items exceeded far the controlled expenses.
Another risk may lie in allowing budgetary goals to become more important than the organizational goals. As mentioned by Fraser, budgeting strengthens the vertical chain of command and control rather than empowering managers. Managers, in their desire to keep within limits, might forget that they owe loyalty to the organization's ideals and objectives.
In one organization with a budgetary control program, the sales department could not get needed information from the medical department on the ground that the latter's budget would not stand such expenses.
This conflict exists perhaps because there is no proper coordination; and normally, these are symptoms of inadequate management. Plans constitute a supporting and interlocking network and every plan should be clearly in a budget.
It is interesting to note that it is often common for managers to say that an idea is good but it is rejected because it is not within the budget. Sometimes, budgets often control the wrong things. They measure inputs but ignore outputs such as the quality of the product or customer satisfaction. These items may be difficult to measure; yet they may be the key to success or failure of the enterprise.
Some managers may no invest in research and development or invest in activities that will result eventually in greater market share because these investments normally do not show immediate results.
It is wiser ...Show more

Summary

Over the years, a widely used device for managerial control is the budget. Budgeting is the formulation of plans for a given period stated in numerical terms in the future. Budgeting is plans converted into money availabilities. In real sense, budgeting is at the hearth of the administrative process…
Author : sallypredovic
Critically evaluate Hope and Frasers (1997) arguments and the reasons for their arguments essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Critically evaluate Hope and Fraser's (1997) arguments and the reasons for their arguments"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Arguments
It is fundamental to realize at this point that San Diego has been given the nickname of “America’s Finest City”, and there are reasons to believe that this city is one of the best places in the nation to dwell in. significantly, San Diego has been one of the most attractive and serene places in the country, and it is a great location for peaceful living.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Critically evaluate feminist arguments against the present system of science
Most feminists share the same opinion that in western culture gender is a very important aspect determining social norms, laws, human relationships, and individual behaviour. The second-wave of feminism examined how male-centred, male-dominated societies marginalised and disenfranchised women, both to identify and abolish gender inequalities (Lederman & Bartsch, 2001).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
International Management: Critically evaluate the statement by presenting your arguments to address: 1. The drivers of globalisa
The emergence of globalisation has rapidly transformed the political influences of governments towards the augmentation of industrialisation. According to the present rapidly growing scenario of the global business world, it has been frequently observed that the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) have also been contributing a substantial growth towards the global economy.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Definitional Arguments
Whereas formal definitions are the description developed earlier such as those definitions in dictionaries (190), the operational definitions are those derived from the features or uses of a particular object in question (191). The process of developing a definitional argument involves formulation of claims, crafting of definitions, matching of the formulated claims to the crafted definitions, and considering the visuals and designs.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Arguments
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Arguments
rful beaches, adventurous people would end up heading the beaches for surfing and sailing purposes or diving along San Diego’s coastal beaches and bays (San Diego). As a common knowledge, increasing the number of tourists in the city also means business opportunity for the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Analyzing Arguments
However what is not explained is that one could assume that there is a plethora of different humanities courses that do not incorporate
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Arguments Table
Behaviorism claims that “there is a response to every effective stimulus and that response is immediate” (Watson, as cited in Arkin, 1998, p.45). This claim makes psychology a concept different than the study of mind and conscious
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Critically evaluate feminist arguments against the present system of science
The second-wave of feminism examined how male-centred, male-dominated societies marginalised and disenfranchised women, both to identify and abolish gender inequalities (Lederman & Bartsch, 2001). The movement also argued that science,
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
( Ontological Arguments )
This argument holds that God exists because our reality was caused by a “God-type” being that brought everything into existence. Furthermore, while this argument was only used by theologians and philosophers before, the 20th century witnessed science confirm that the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation