StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE DOCTRINE OF FREE ACCEPTANCE - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE DOCTRINE OF FREE ACCEPTANCE

So murky are the waters that judicial acceptance of the concept through the years has been less than overwhelming. The farthest it has reached, according to Hedley1 is this: a considerable number of judges now recognize that there is an important subject called restitution and that in general terms, it concerns the removal of benefits that would otherwise unjustly enrich the defendant.It is not difficult to imagine that jurisprudence surrounding the much more limited principle of free acceptance is even narrower. To aspire for universality or even, less ambitiously, coherence, would be a futile exercise. The only discernible trend is, as Hedley somewhat cynically puts it, "the willingness to make quite spectacular changes in the law when the judge's moral feelings are sufficiently outraged."2
What this paper will attempt to do is to present a comparative overview of free acceptance, and to some extent, unjust enrichment, as it is applied in common law jurisdictions. By way of providing some form of context, it will also explore how the common law countries perceive these two principles, as opposed to civil law countries. The jury is still out on the question of what the future holds for these two intertwined doctrines, dependent as it largely is on the vagaries of the legal system and the constantly-shifting winds of judicial discernment and discretion.

II. Free Acceptance Not Freely Accepted: A Review of Scholarly Studies
To quote Birks, "a free acceptance occurs where a recipient knows that a benefit is being offered to him non-gratuitiously and where he, having the opportunity to reject, elects to accept."3 It is an alternative to incontrovertible benefit that cannot be disputed by the defendants, as in benefits that have accrued due to a clear and unmistakeable meeting of the minds. Birks proceeds from Goff and Jones4 who first propounded the idea of subjectively-determined benefit.

The most famous example of free acceptance is of a window cleaner who cleaned the windows of a homeowner, the homeowner being fully aware that the window cleaner believed that he was performing the service for valuable consideration and yet doing nothing to stop the cleaner from cleaning the windows. Per the argument of Goff and Jones and Birks, (though the latter partially retracted a few years later), he is deemed to have freely accepted the service and should be made liable to the window cleaner.

There is no dearth of legal theorists, however, who have found flaws in this example, flaws that render the entire principle of free acceptance vulnerable. Garner5 for example, stated:

A defendant may seek subjective devaluation of an objective benefit conferred on him by the plaintiff in two ways. First, he can appeal to his own personal, and perhaps, perverse tastes. While the reasonable man might like his house to have clean windows, the defendant may assert that he prefers his dirty. So if a window cleaner does work on his house by mistake, he may resist the window cleaner's restitutionary claim simply by denying that he has received a benefit. Clean windows are of no value to him. He has the right to be perverse. Alternatively, he may appeal to a particular (and not necessarily perverse) expenditure priority. He might concede that he likes his windows clean. However, he may have preferred to have done the job himself rather than pay somebody else to do it for him. He might have more important things on which to spend his money.


It is Garner's contention that more needs to be done than to "simply establish a conceded or acknowledged benefit the arguments based ...Show more

Summary

The road towards accepting free acceptance as an iron-clad principle in the law of restitution may appear tantalizing to some, but as many legal scholars have pointed out, it is a road fraught with many dangers…
Author : selenacummings
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE DOCTRINE OF FREE ACCEPTANCE essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE DOCTRINE OF FREE ACCEPTANCE"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Project Management Methods: A Comparative Study
In other words, it systematically organises a project and its components. A project is a one-time effort that is aimed at producing specific results in a specific duration. That is to say, a project has a defined beginning and an end. Further, a project is time-constrained.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
American Literature: A Comparative Study
In Norton American Literature et al. (1980s), she clearly wrote in a manner that her writing texture becomes no more vague giving perfect ideas of her thought towards the language importance. Language is what fundamentally makes a nation’s culture or even depicts the character and traits of the natives of the particular land.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comparative Study of US Dollar and Euro
Introduction The development of economies of countries worldwide is primarily depended on their potentials to promote their currency in regard to global trade transactions. US Dollar is used for measuring the value of petroleum and gold, goods that are of primarily importance for global economy.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Comparative Analysis of Free Market Economy and Mixed Economy
This essay primarily focuses on the identification of the distinctive features of two most common economic system in the world. Free market is an economic system that is determined by the price mechanism. A mixed economy is a combination of a free market and planned economies. Free market economy is deemed more effective compared to a mixed type.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Comparative Approach in the Study of Politics
(Baun et al, 1995) A common believe is that there are two paths to the development of a sort of political culture agreeable to the constitutional state, the internal formation of a single, consensual political culture, or the imposition and maintenance of constitutional principles by force.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Admission Acceptance
Although I do not consider it necessarily an exceptional hardship, as this is by no means a unique situation, I have only been in the United States about three and one half years. When I first arrived here it was somewhat difficult for me to become acclimated to life in the states.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Law - Restitution
So murky are the waters that judicial acceptance of the concept through the years has been less than overwhelming. The farthest it has reached, according to Hedley1 is this: a considerable number of
27 pages (6750 words) Essay
Critically analyse the extent to which the classical doctrine on communication of acceptance is relevant in modern contractual relations
As such, an agreement between two or more persons is a necessary ingredient of a contract. The offer should be accepted like mirror image in order to form an
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Introduction to comparative ethnic study
The need for the consideration and restoration of the curricula emanates from the lack of awareness amongst people on tolerance and
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Doctrine
Marx denotes productivity as “man’s spiritual essence, his human essence” (Sayers 610-612). Marx’s view of human nature depict that human beings have developed a complex affiliation with the environment through their works. The ultimate
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation