StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Maxine Hong Kingston's Silence - Book Report/Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Maxine Hong Kingston's Silence

There are people who argue that Gould had been so illogical in his essay. On the other hand Kingston had acquired feminists' movements support and criticism from keepers of Chinese traditions stating that her essay is anti-Chinese culture. As of this moment, we will try to compare the two writers writing styles incorporated in these two essays. Is Kingston better than Gould
Looking at the ethos of both writings, let us first start talking about the credibility of both writers in dealing with the topic. In these two essays Kingston is more credible in terms of knowledge requirements. Yes, they both are trying to present an argumentative topic both dealing with "discrimination" among individuals that they both know exists in the time of writing their essays. Literally speaking, Kingston is fighting for women's right, while Gould is playing on a neutral stand in the debate of who is superior. Gould in the entirety of the topic did not mention of anything that would support his mastery of the topic, while on the other hand, Kingston showed mastery of the topic by combination of her own experience and real situations of the society. From their, the difficulty of the topic is very clear, Gould's topic is very scientific in contrary to Kingston which is dealing with ethical and cultural issue. Gould did not even prove by himself if brain size has something to do with intelligence. He just cited researcher's works and narrated them in the essay. In the entirety of the essay, he never even showed that he has personally conducted his own experiment or study with brain sizes and its relation to intelligence. He never sounds confident in this essay, perhaps he is just trying to excite people and reopen the debate that happened long ago. He just narrated events and mentioned his main characters-mostly "researchers", and did not even show that he has connection with these people. In his conclusion, he just expressed his own idea and it was not even derived from the researcher's works that he had cited. Perhaps he himself knows that the evidences he gathered are too weak to prove the issue. Well, it is good for him because he never boost by picking a side. His essay would even leave a question about his purpose of writing it, why did he write it Is he hiding an intention that only people like him could find out On the other hand, Kingston's topic is much easier to prove. Her evidences: customs, traditions, events are based on her own experience and observation of what is happening around her. She has incorporated more knowledge in the essay. Her point is clear, and he leaves no confusion about her purpose of writing it. In general, they may differ in terms of mastery, but they both showed sincerity.
Did their essay tackle ethical, cultural, and traditional issues For Kingston it is clear, yes She showed the effect of traditions and customs being observed in their society as of the time of her writing. She is giving a clear picture of the discrimination existing between men and women in the society. In Chinese culture, a woman who got pregnant out of wedlock commits a disgustful crime ...Show more

Summary

Maxine Hong Kingston the author of "Silence" showed the meaning of Silence and how it affects anybody's life. Although her essay is literally speaking about women's silence caused mainly by traditions and customs, and misunderstanding, but it could be applied in general…
Author : lacey25
Maxine Hong Kingstons Silence essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Maxine Hong Kingston's Silence"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Critical reader response (1 page summary, and 2 pages of critical response)
Initially, there was the perceived lack of participation in class discussions, described as Silences, among Hong-Kong-born Chinese students. These Silences were resented by their classmates, who were Canadian-born Chinese and non-Chinese students. A study used a close-observation method and this showed that the English-only policy in the classroom made Hong-Kong-born Chinese Canadian students “reluctant talkers.” In reality, the students were not actually unwilling to be active in school work, but they were silent due to fear of being ridiculed for their pronunciation of English words, also their being thought of as “showing off” in discussions.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Waiting For Godot: Silence and Death
This is the same case that is being portrayed in the play waiting for Godot. This is the major theme that revolves around the play. This particular play majorly centers on two main characters, that is Estragon and Vladimir as they wait anxiously for hope which should come through Godot.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
May Sarton's After a Winter's Silence
About the Poem: The poem, 'After A Winter's Silence' is based on and composed of numerous themes that we can highlight. The first stanza talks about the strength and tenacity of the varied manifestations of nature. Hard ice, that has been formed due to the strenuous winter gives way to snowdrops, that melt and form a pool by the wall.
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Robinson Crusoe by Daniel Defoe
Robinson Crusoe is a novel which was written by Daniel Defoe, and which was first published in the year 1719. This piece of literature is in fact considered as being the first novel in English, and it has been used to set examples and provoke influence in many different areas of the world, not only in the past, but in the present as well.
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
Maxine Hong Kingstons Women Warrior
All these stories initially confused her, but eventually helped her find her own identity in an American society with Chinese parents. These stories aren't only helpful in finding her self but also assisted her in understanding the power of language. Based on five such talk-stories, Kingston divulges her journey in search of an identity.
9 pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review
Mobile Commerce Market in Hong Kong
The stated scope covers the mobile commerce opportunity in Hong Kong market by providing a study of contributions made by mobile networks providers, the Hong Kong Post, and the Telecommunication Authority. It also provides a review of why the information market in Hong Kong is suitable for mobile commerce development.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Critical reader response (1 page summary, and 2 pages of critical response)
These Silences were resented by their classmates, who were Canadian-born Chinese and non-Chinese students. A study used a close-observation method and this showed that the
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Silence
The major cause of this is the amount of tension it brings into a story and consequently makes the story more interesting to review. Over time, many authors have integrated the motif of silence in their stories. Two of such stories are The
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Symposium Papers Review
However, the paper the references should be in column form. The paper follows the ASME formatting concisely from the formatting to layout. The paper has a conference title and number flushed top right, a title and authors aligned
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
Discussion
There is an irony that comes out of Gabriel’s prayer when he considers the cry of his sister as the cry of a sinner who is probably paying for his sins. Apparently, that puts in doubt all the Christian approach Gabriel believes in because he is judging
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation