Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Government Discussion Question ( ) - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Pages 2 (502 words)


Every public policy and political issue in America can be a subject of judicial review and any legislation or act by any branch of the government if perceived by the Court to be in breach of the provisions of the Constitution can be annulled by it. The way the American judiciary is empowered to delve into the country's polity raises the question if this can have a harmonizing relation with the country's commitment to democracy and such judicial review reinforces democracy given its limitations in policymaking.

Extract of sample
Government Discussion Question ( )

His observation was on the basis that the judiciary has "no influence over either the sword or the purse" meaning the Court could not influence either the legislative or the executive. Agreeing with Hamilton's views on the power of the Court, O'Brien in his analysis of the role of the Supreme Court in American democracy acknowledges limitations of the Court in the matter of policy making and bringing social change having by itself "no chance to resolve great issues of public policy". However, he contradicts Hamilton's contention that the Court is "least dangerous" and contends that it is no longer so. The Supreme Court, according to O'Brien, by getting increasingly activist has become a "storm center" of national politics.
Hamilton's vision of a completely independent Court has not materialized and instead the judiciary has found itself acting under external pressures from the executive, legislature and the public opinion. Devoid of the power of "the sword or the purse", the Court depends for the impact of its rulings and their influences on the policymaking on the political institutions of the country and the public opinion. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related Essays

Critical Thinking Discussion Question
Framing a problem before offering up solutions can influence the outcome.…
2 pages (502 words)
Discussion Question 3
It is also a good idea to have the questions checked by another person who is thoroughly knowledgeable with the subject of the questions.…
4 pages (1004 words)
Ethic management Discussion Question
Deciding whose life to trade in exchange for who's is inherently an unethical decision to make. It requires placing a higher value on certain lives and lower value on others based on immutable characteristics of those individuals, such as age, gender and station in life. If acting ethically essentially means doing the right thing, there is really no right choice to make in the nuclear fallout…
2 pages (502 words)
discussion question
Assuming there are 1 billion writers, is it not possible that there are exactly two the same sentences There have been some records indicating exactly look alike in images, what more with written lines when writing has been here since time immemorial Is not plagiarism a simple commerce hiding behind the facade of protecting the rights of others, while prejudicing the rights of some…
2 pages (502 words)
The American Revolution - Discussion Question Only
In 1838, President Andrew Jackson sent federal troops to enforce the treaty and evict the Indians from their native lands.…
2 pages (502 words)