StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Critical Analysis of the article provided - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Critical Analysis of the article provided

These two approaches are the most applicable to the situation prevailing in the healthcare industry, as revealed by the author.
The first ethical issue that is obvious in the article is the practice by pharmaceutical firms to entice doctors, with lavish fees and expense, into promoting their own drug as against the other drugs present for the same medical condition. This is achieved through the screen of "medical education." However, this education provided by paid doctors is entirely one sided and favors one company's drug, in comparison with other drugs used for the same medical condition. This practice may lead to the promotion and use of harmful drugs, as has happened several times in the past. The companies get the credibility of the doctors, who they pay for promotion, to promote even under-researched drugs which are known to cause harm to the users.
Another ethical concern is that concerning the doctors, who agree to become drug representatives by forgetting the moral responsibility that comes with the medical profession, and suppressing their critical faculties in exchange for monetary compensation. The author was himself one of the doctors who became a drug representative for a particular drug - at first with a clear conscience and in the belief that he is helping to educate other doctors in the benefits of the drug in question, then with a guilty conscience, in withholding some negative information that he came across about the drug he promoted. The author says that the monetary and other benefits provided by the pharmaceutical firms are so large that it clouds the critical faculties of the doctors involved and makes them commit immoral behavior.
Another concern brought forth is the unethical marketing strategy used by the pharmaceutical firms in order to make the most profits, even from under-researched or harmful drugs, before the harmful effects of the drugs become full public knowledge leading to a ban on such drugs. The profit motive leads them to commit further unethical acts by recruiting doctors to promote unscrupulous drugs by attracting them with large amounts of money and other benefits. They involve other institutions in this unethical behavior, such as the pharmacies, the American Medical Association, medical research firms and others.
There are two basic approaches applicable in this situation. These approaches are used in analyzing the above concerns as below.
Utilitarian Approach
The Utilitarian theory of ethics is also a consequential or teleological theory. It believes in the "happiness principle" of ethics. "Utility" or "Greatest Happiness Principle" is the foundation of morality according to this theory. Actions are right in proportion to the happiness they promote and wrong in proportion to the pain they produce. So, any action that "promotes the greatest good to the greatest number" is morally and ethically correct according to this theory. There are two types of utilitarianism: Act utilitarianism and Rule utilitarianism.
Act utilitarianism postulates that any action that promotes pleasure and an action that leads to the greatest pleasure or good to the greatest number of people, even if produces pain in a few, is basically morally correct. In this sense, the action of the author and other doctors, and the firms which are employing this particular marketing strategy for untested drugs are actually promoting the greatest good ...Show more

Summary

The article "Dr. Drug Rep" by Daniel Carlat, published on Nov 25, 2007 in the New York Times, brings to the fore the ethical issues raised by the marketing strategy, employed by pharmaceutical concerns, of employing doctors to promote their own drugs in order to lend more credibility to the marketing of their drug…
Author : hkoepp
Critical Analysis of the article provided essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Critical Analysis of the article provided"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

A Critical Analysis of Article 5 of UCP 600
A Critical Analysis of Article 5 of UCP 600 Introduction The International Chamber of Commerce’s (ICC) Uniform Customs and Practice 600 (UCP 600) revised the practice rules relative to letters of credit in 2006 and thus replaced UCP 600 1993.1 Pursuant to Article 5 of UCP 600 cautions that banks do not deal with goods and services and are confined to dealing with documents.2 Therefore Article 5 of UCP 600 sets forth the rationale for the autonomous nature of the letter of credit and segregates if from the contract to which it relates.3 There are some problems that can arise from the autonomy of the letters of credit.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Critical analysis of an article
In addition, the essay will explain whether there is any background information to consider if there is any evidence presented. Moreover, the essay will focus on whether the language used is influenced by the where it has been published or its audience. Furthermore, the essay will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of the article and the additional research I would do if I wanted to investigate further.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Summary and critical analysis of journal article
Ghost walk Tourism in Savannah, Georgia refers to different type of tourist experience offers to the tourists. They are able to experience dark tourism, it refers that the tourists are able to explore other than planned tourism where the people can visualize with the limited time frame and place .Here the Tourists have got more flexibility in interacting with the local population, business, culture, knowledge of buildings, history, people of the past and their way of life.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Critical Analysis
It is understood from the article titles that student motivation and the teacher status factors have become pressing issues that require immediate attention. The articles present accurate pictures of the said topics
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Critical Analysis
The article is not basically emphasizing on the use or availability of condoms but is based on the parent-child relationship and open discussion on sex and other issues. A thorough and deep
3 pages (750 words) Essay
One page analysis of news article provided
t in Wisconsin where 200 boys were molested by priests to the current issue in Europe where 67 people have come forward claiming the same thing has occurred to them. In both incidents the children were highly vulnerable ‘deaf’ children, and in both incidents there appears to
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Critical Analysis of the Research Designs in a Peer- Reviewed Article
The inherent inquisitiveness of man provides the impetus for invention, innovation, and research. Research is a better tool that has assisted man to move ahead. Aquino (1981, 3) defined research as the systematic search
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Critical analysis of an article
Moreover, the essay will focus on whether the language used is influenced by the where it has been published or its audience. Furthermore, the essay will highlight
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF AN ARTICLE
xplanatory in nature; it explains what the study/article is about, for instance, it tells the reader that the article is about a control framework that results from strategic lean manufacturing initiative. It should be noted that, the abstract for this article is brief, concise
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Critique the article provided
The study relied on health belief model to inform theoretical framework. The study population of the study included 70 individuals who manifest a
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation