StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

National Identification Cards - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
National Identification Cards

After all, if the act was to proceed, states would be responsible for a humungous total of about $23 Billion, spread over a 10-year period (PFAW Capitol Hill).
Ultimately, the Act was intended to prevent terrorism by creating rigorous and consistent standards with regard to state-issued IDs for all the states to follow. States are commissioned to renovate the drivers' licenses and non-drivers' identification cards such that uniform security features could be included in them across the whole country (PFAW Capitol Hill). The law repealed Section 7212 under Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004, a regulation targeting the issue of national standards for drivers' licenses and personal identification cards where minimum standards were set and certain information were disclosed in the identification cards left to each of the states' discretion, thus sacrificing the consistency of the categories and criteria on who are eligible to obtain the drivers' licenses across the whole country. The new law as such reformed this by replacing each of all the states standards with a specific national one (Hann).
Technically, states are not mandated to accept these federal standards. But, refusing to do so would mean that their residents would be refused employment, then denied having social security or disallowed air travel. In a sense, instead of imposing a direct order on the states, the federal government is threatening them into complying underhandedly. Combating terrorism is the primary reason behind all these. But, proponents of these are actually forgetting that the criminals do not care about laws, not so much as to breaking them anyway. A terrorist would not so much bat an eyelash when he is not going to be dutifully able to obtain a federal ID card. People who disregarded the nation's immigration laws would not care so much if they were to disrespect these ID requirements, especially when any card can be forged and any regulating agency could be bribed. Terrorists can and will have a way to obtain national ID cards or just proceed with their operations without them. That said, the national ID cards are more for the tracking of law-abiding citizens and not these criminals (Ron). With such, the Act can already be said not to have an effective impact on the prevention of future terrorist and criminal acts. Even if this law had been in place in 2001, each of those hijackers would still have obtained a driver's license or board that plane, what will all the things technology can do in producing fake documents, or the ways in which these terrorists could have obtained legal documents through deception or manipulation (Hann). A problem with the national ID system is the formation of a category more dangerous than the classification of 'bad guys', that is of a bad guy that possess a good guy's profile, meaning the creation of a criminal having the capability to steal the identity of an honest person if he will its, especially if the system could be undermined. The Real ID Act does not do anything to alter this possibility (Electronic Privacy Information Center).
Part of the law is the provision in linking all of the states' motor vehicle databases. Drivers' licenses were made to expire at the same time as the immigration visas. The Department of Motor Vehicles therefore became designated to monitor the immigration status as well as enforce the federal immigration laws. This is not appropriate ...Show more

Summary

President Bush signed into law the Real ID Act of 2005 or HR. 418 on May 11. 2005. This was introduced by Congressman James Sensenbrenner, as part of the Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror and Tsunami Relief 2005 (Hann)…
Author : ykoch
National Identification Cards essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"National Identification Cards"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

National Identification System in the United States
The issue of having National Identity Cards has been a subject of debate for quite some time in the United States. Those in favor state that having national identity cards will improve national security as it will protect the Americans from terrorists, and likewise discourage illegal immigrants from entering the country.
23 pages (5750 words) Essay
Identification
The United States, unlike other countries such as Japan and Germany, has not employed this system of running the economy. Though the system has worked very well in the above mentioned countries, the United States continues to thrive well without its enforcement.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Identification
In the political world, one does not hide his or her standpoint like it happens in lecture rooms. It is therefore inappropriate to state that democracy is absolutely perfect. As matter of fact, it has been argued that democracy can also be a bad form of government (Ingram 2).
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Technological advances in criminal identification procedures
Ever since the discovery of DNA (Deoyxribonucleic acid) in 1954, it has been accepted as a measure of a person's identity as it contains an individual's genetic information (Gans and Urbas, 2002). DNA analysis offers a deeper identification method than traditional identification methods such as fingerprints, blood type, hair color etc.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Introduction to Biometric Identification Database
Such features help in establishing the identity of the person without any effort from the person concerned. In fact even if someone tries to conceal his identity, biometrics won't let it happen. Identifying a person with his face and voice have been the age old practices in the human civilization process.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
The U.K Identity Cards Bill and its implcations
Identity Cards Bill1 and the national identity project are high on the government agenda, despite criticisms from different quarters about its potential legal, security and policy implications. The Bill proposes to issue hi-tech biometric identity cards to 60 million British citizens within three years, and to make the card compulsory within ten years, as well as introduce a National Identity Register, with the stated objectives of combating crime and terrorism, tackling identity frauds, and deterring illegal immigration, in that way cutting down on illegitimate claims on welfare benefits.2
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Biometric identification
In the United Kingdom, the House of Commons passed a bill that biometric identification cards are to be made compulsory for every citizen by the year 2010. Biometric identification cards contain embedded chips that store personal information about the citizen like name, signatures, photos, facial scans and iris and retinal scans.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Oppose National Identification Cards
State governments wanted to dissent from this act as well but for financial reasons as participating to such means huge pecuniary burdens for them. After all,
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Identification
riences in two positions which are at Al-Adwa’a Institute as a training and development supervisor from January 10, 2008 to March 30, 2010 and summer training at Saudi Arabia Airline in the summer of 2008. In Saudi Arabia Airline, I worked in the Aircraft Reliability Program
1 pages (250 words) Essay
For and against a national animal identification system in the U.S
An individual Animal identification number (AIN) is a fifteen digit number that is unique and is supposed to stay with the animal for the whole life
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation