StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Intradermal Injections Traditional Bevel Up Versus Bevel Down Article Critique - Lab Report Example

Extract of sample
Intradermal Injections Traditional Bevel Up Versus Bevel Down Article Critique

This is a traditional technique and widely accepted. Thus, the authors in this paper studied if the comfort levels vary in the two techniques.
The authors use students with no experience what so ever as nurses in this study. They claim that it is important to have un-experienced candidates as nurses as they do not have any preferences towards the bevel up or bevel down technique. They call these nurses as having no "psychomotor skills". Is it a good idea to have nurses with no skills to test the technique
The authors do not discuss on the effect of the technique on the cause itself. A bevel down injection might result in the medicine flowing into the lower layer of the dermis. Thus, a bevel up injection may be better as it is important to get the medicine deposited in the upper layer of the dermis. It might not have any effect but still some discussion on the effect of the technique on the cure would have helped.
One of the most important factors of the experiment was to measure the size of the wheal. The reason is that it is a scientific factor to evaluate the effectiveness of a given technique. The size of the wheal probably correlates with the effectiveness of the technique. May be the wheal is not at all necessary for the effect to take place. This is necessary in-order to evaluate the results better.
Page 2Page 278 "Please rate on a scale of 1 to 5 your comfort when receiving the intradermal injection, with one (1) being no discomfort and five (5) being 'hurts a lot'." Below this sentence was a row of five numbers with "no discomfort" above the "1" and "hurts a lot" above the "5." The subject circled a number. The form was then taken by the investigator, and the subject was given a second form with the same content for the second injection. In addition, it asked "Which injection was better" followed by"
This is more or less the procedure used to analyze the technique. i.e., psychological analysis to differentiate between the two scientific methods - bevel up and bevel down methods of intra-dermal injections. This should have been the title of their paper. Apart from the psychological analysis, the authors should have evaluated the technique based upon some scientific tests. Unfortunately, they have not even mentioned any such experiments. This is a major draw back of the paper.
Page 278 ".45 administered the intra-dermal injection bevel up the first time and 53 of them used the bevel-down technique the first time." And then on the page 279 "Subjects administered the bevel-up injection ...Show more

Summary

In the given paper, the authors study the comfort levels of the bevel up versus bevel down procedures of the intradermal injections. They use statistical measures on the experimental data. The parameters considered for the test were correct placement of injectate, leaking or bleeding, time to administer injection and comfort of person administering and receiving an intradermal injection…
Author : matteo46
Intradermal Injections Traditional Bevel Up Versus Bevel Down Article Critique essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the lab report on your topic
"Intradermal Injections Traditional Bevel Up Versus Bevel Down Article Critique"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Nursing Article critique
The authors have tried to deal as many areas as possible for writing a good article. Even then, an article cannot be written with 100 percent accuracy and completion. The authors of this article have developed a title which provides important information about the main idea of the article.
2 pages (500 words) Lab Report
Critique on the Article, An Anorexic's Recovery. by Leanna Rutherford
(Anti Essays) defined anorexia nervosa as "a relentless pursuit of excessive thinness that interferes with the fulfillment of responsibilities to the self and to others because it produces an intense and irrational fear of becoming fat, an obsession with food and weight control, and a life threatening weight loss" (n.p.).
4 pages (1000 words) Lab Report
Critique the study of the article
Measurement scales, Patient Satisfaction Scale, Nottingham Health Profile, EuroQol 5D, all have been elaborated well with their use if different research studies. The description about their use for various purposes, patient satisfaction or clinical interventions, or health outcomes has been stated.
4 pages (1000 words) Lab Report
Article Critique on article critique on Preferences for Friends and Close Relationship Partners: A Cross-Cultural Comparison. that I found in Academic Search Primer. Journal of Social Psychology, Aug 91, Vol 131 Issue 4, p579-581
Buss has measured such attributes with reference to cross-cultural differences in his research in 1989. Bond has made his research on the subject by a comparative analysis of two different nations based on the
6 pages (1500 words) Lab Report
Article critique
tly, unlike absolute majority of researchers who stick to conventional methods of analysis the authors provide a new fresh look on the problem of nurse shortage. Secondly, the authors do not simply demonstrate the problem, its origins and possible consequences, but also propose
5 pages (1250 words) Lab Report
Article Analysis
Theory Y is the exact anti thesis of theory y, it states that people are inherently motivated to work to achieve goals and also to accept greater responsibility. Theory y also states that if people are given the right working conditions then they would feel motivated to
4 pages (1000 words) Lab Report
Chronic pain management- article critique
This work attempts to explore the feasibility and effectiveness of multidisciplinary team management of chronic pain where collaborative care is offered. Pain
8 pages (2000 words) Lab Report
Article
The study argues upon the different reasons, which enforces a lady to get down in the dumps. The reasons can be biological or psychological and mostly it is
3 pages (750 words) Lab Report
Business Administration (Research Article Critique)
The main theme behind the article under study is to find out if there exists or not any relationship between work-life balance of a professional and development in his personal as well as professional life. The writer submits to state that though balance is
4 pages (1000 words) Lab Report
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation