StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Bilingual Education Curriculum - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Bilingual Education Curriculum

It is then necessary to lay down the reasons why despite several convincing arguments on the effectiveness of bilingual education, the arguments and debates continue. And to shed light on the cloudy controversy, Crawford (1998) presented the ten misconceptions or common fallacies about bilingual education as follows:
1. English is losing ground to other languages in the United States. More of a panic view than an empirical one, Crawford (1998) acknowledged that there are more world languages spoken in the US now more than ever but quantitative, he argued and not a qualitative change from earlier periods. He pointedly added the concentrations of non-English language speakers common in the 19th century provided for by laws authorizing native language instruction in several states and territories. Children in big cities and rural areas attended bilingual and non-English schools with a diversity of French, Norwegian, Czech or Cherokee while "English survived without any help from government such as official-language legislation," (Crawford, 1998).
2. Newcomers to the United States are learning English more slowly now than in previous generations. Another unfounded belief, Crawford (1998) argued that recent immigrants "appear to be acquiring English more rapidly than ever before" while minority language speakers grow, bilinguals fluent in both native and English language "is growing even faster. Waggoner (1995) reported that between 1980 and 1990, the number of immigrants who spoke non-English languages at home increased by 59%, while the portion of this population that spoke English very well rose by 93% . Likewise, Crawford (1998) added that only 3 percent of US residents reported speaking English less (as compared to well and very well) while only a very insignificant portion spoke no English at all. Also, Veltman (1998) found that about 3 in 4 Hispanic immigrants were reportedly able to speak English on a daily basis after 15 years of residency, and that 70 percent of their children became monolingual English speakers
3. The best way to learn a language is through total immersion. Rodriguez (1982) and de la Pea (1991) were often cited to have "succeeded in school without a special program and acquired a very high level of English literacy," (Krashen, 1997) but it was found out, both had substantial advantages. Rodriguez grew up in an English-Speaking neighborhood in Sacramento, California instrumental in his informal immersion from classmates while de la Pea had the bilingual education advantage in Mexico until fifth grade, and was placed two grades backwards in his schooling in the United States. Crawford (1998) further argued "there is no credible evidence to support the "time on task" theory of language learning-- the claim that the more children are exposed to English, the more English they will learn" emphasizing quality over quantity of exposure while Krashen (1996) pointed out that second language input must also be comprehensible to promote second language acquisition. Crawford (1998) added that children left alone to learn on their own in an all-English classroom setting with little or without help via native lessons, English learning will be of little use. And that native instruction will make learning ...Show more

Summary

In 1900, Kloss (1998) reported there were about 600,000 elementary school children instructed either in part or in whole in German and no legislation aided English to survive. There are more languages spoken in the United States today (Crawford, 1998) with English growing to become the global language…
Author : noelia51
Bilingual Education Curriculum essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Bilingual Education Curriculum"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Bilingual/ESL Education
Berhanrdt identified this difficulty as a “boxed-mindset”, which incapacitates the researcher to comprehensively examine and explain variables involved in multilingual research theme. The reason is that such researcher would be “inherently biased toward a particular surface structure (all current reading models are right branching, for example) and a particular view of literature (literacy is for everyone).” (Bernhardt 2003, p.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Bilingual Education in United State History
Garcia and Baker (pp.89) indicate that over the years, Bilingual Education underwent massive changes. Some of these periods were smooth sailing, while others were extremely difficult to handle. The United States welcomed numerous immigrants into the country from the twentieth century.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
History of ELL and Bilingual Trasition Education
Statistical data reports that Arizona contains a total of 1,742 public schools and 48% of this tally accounts for minority students. In other words, this means that 16.1% of the total numbers are ELL students and an additional 19% languish in poverty. The main goal for this proposal in repealing the existing inconsiderate education laws and conventions and transform the laws for them to embrace the provision that all teachers must teach all classes in English.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Policy and Practice In the Education of Bilingual Children
According to the paper bilingual pupils have an acquaintance that they cannot articulate ideas in English. During a practice as a teacher in Tower Hamlets Primary School, it was noted that the teacher’s assignment is to tap into the pupils’ accessible comprehension and familiarize with it as the groundwork for their teaching strategies. Using bilingual pupils’ home language and cultural background in the teaching and learning atmosphere is a vital initial approach.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Bilingual education benefits everyone
For the student who speaks only a minority language, bilingual education is a controversial program that not only enhances their education, but also benefits society as well. Bilingual education is not a recent development in America. As early as 1839 Ohio enacted a German-English program to teach immigrant students.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Bilingual Education
However, his brilliance, does not equate to his being right about the lack of need for a bilingual education. Even though his argument against bilingual education is based on personal opinion, rather than scientific fact, Rodriquez is neither a fool nor dupe.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Bilingual Versus Dual Curriculum Instruction
Lambert advocates that dual-language programs are the most advantageous alternatives currently available, to resolve problems caused by the unusual and widespread dichotomy between foreign language and bilingual education in the American schools. The main objective of a second language instruction is to assimilate the people with the natives.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Emergent bilingual
In contrast to other groups of bilinguals, the deaf bilinguals use two different languages; that is a sign language and the oral language. According to García & Kleifgen (2010), Bilinguals
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Bilingual Education
Proposition 227 is a law passed in California in 1998 whose main objective was to ensure all children in public schools be taught in English. According to the proposition, English learners whom it defined as children whose native language is not English would be placed in temporarily in transition classes for a period not exceeding one year.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
LANGUAGE, PEDAGOGY AND CULTURAL DIVERSITY. Policy and practice in the education of bilingual children
This paper will focus on and analyse Cummins’ 1986 empowerment theory and linked to related literature and observation and policy of present bilingual education in the UK. This paper will demonstrate an understanding of the policy and practice in the education of bilingual
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation