StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Conjoined twins issue - Case Study Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Conjoined twins issue

In conjoined twins, these chemical messages do not work properly.The results can be bizarre, like a single organism with two heads, two hearts, four legs and arms.
Jodie and Mary were conjoined twins. They each had their own brain, heart, lungs, other vital organs and each of them had arms and legs. They were joined at the lower abdomen and it was decided by the medical authorities of the UK that they could be successfully separated upon. However, this operation would kill the weaker twin, Mary, because her lungs and heart were too weak to oxygenate and pump blood through her body. Had she not been born a conjoined twin, she would not have been able to live and resuscitation would have been abandoned. She would have died shortly after birth. She was alive only because a common artery enabled her sister, who was stronger, to circulate life sustaining oxygenated blood through her body. Separation would require the clamping and then the severing of that common artery and within minutes of doing so, Mary would die.
However, if the operation did not take place, both would die within three to six months, or perhaps a little longer, because Jodie's heart would eventually fail. The parents could not bring themselves to consent to the operation. The twins were equal in their eyes and they could not agree to kill one even to save the other.
As devout Roman Catholics, they believed that their children's afflic...
The medical classification of this type of conjoined twins is termed as Ischiopagus tetrapus and in such twins there is a fusion at the pelvic level often with a sharing of genitourinary structures, rectum and the liver. The consequence of the surgical intervention was that Mary quickly died and Jodie survived.
Conjoined twins exist on the margins of our notions of embodiment and individuality. They challenge the boundaries of medical, ethical and legal possibility and permissibility and their existence poses a threat to entrenched social values about the worth of lives that differ from the norm of one individual, one body2.
Numerous instances of the high profile sacrificial separation of conjoined twins have highlighted the fact that separation decisions seem to be reached on a case-by-case basis. Further, these decisions have been made based on their perceived merit, which does nothing for the internal coherence of the reasoning in the case. Since, judges may agree on outcomes but for different reasons, this presents a problem in the application of precedents, or for the case's coherence within the law, and a deserving outcome in one case may cause tensions in related law. As is often said, 'hard cases make bad law'.
In Airedale N.H.S. Trust v Bland in House of Lords, Lord Browne-Wilkinson gave a judgment, which was at the same time excellent and most instructive in respect of euthanasia. In this case, withdrawal of life support systems was permitted3. The common law in UK allows people to decide for themselves, whether to agree to have surgery or medicine and further, that this right also implies the right to refuse such treatment even if such rejection results in death. This point in law has always been recognized by the courts.
Robert Walker ...Show more


Conjoined twins are formed from a single egg, which develops into two almost separate balls of cells. In normal twinning, each ball becomes an identical twin.As a result, cells in conjoined twins become confused about where they are in the body - indeed which of the two conjoined twins they are actually in…
Author : schimmelanika
Conjoined twins issue essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"Conjoined twins issue"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

The Paradoxical Twins: Acme and Omega Electronics, John F. Veiga
However, the employees are generally dissatisfied with the lack of information they receive about the company and its decisions. As the employees have a minor role in decision-making processes, they feel alienated from the company and its decisions. As a result, the system is not at all innovative and the management receives no constructive suggestions from lower-level employees.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Case Study: Mary morrison's ethical issue
However it has also brought to the fore, various setbacks – software piracy being one of the critical ones. The free availability of pirated software coupled with the ability to access, download and use the same without impunity has only accelerated the growth of piracy in the virtual world.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Issue in case transaction
While Gumpbell does her valuation based on the USD currency, Hen Hao on the other hand conducts her valuation based on the Hong Kong Dollar currency. This is a pure case of International trade and hence the businesses are likely to be affected by both transaction risk as well as financial risk.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
Contemporary Health Issue
This paper is exploring the issue of hypertension or high blood pressure and various historical and socio-political factors that have influenced the occurrence of the disease. (Guyton, 2006) Very many people in the society today are suffering from high blood pressure.
7 pages (1750 words) Case Study
Legal Issue Analysis
This paper will discuss what happened and why it was considered illegal. This was not the first time they made the mistake of continuing to use this exam or it might have gone easier for them. This time the Judge tells them that this cannot be considered benign neglect.
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
An Issue of Two Courts
Nevertheless, one can state here that for a criminal set of charges to stand fast in court the plaintiff must prove the mens rea requirement. This would in turn encompass proof that the defendant acted with criminal intent or a guilty mind. In the absence of a 'smoking gun' letter or memorandum attributable to a specific officer or director, or the testimony of a whistle blower willing to admit that, he or she was present when the officer consent to the activity with a criminal intent of mind, the conviction of the individual officer in question would be nearly impossible to obtain.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
The diagram above presents the dilemma in a paradoxical way. Facing the unavoidable gulf between law and morality the judiciary is faced with the process of "applying the law". One of the most controversial areas of jurisprudence then becomes the still unresolved dilemma of whether morality and law should overlap during judicial and legal reasoning or should be regarded in isolation.
24 pages (6000 words) Case Study
Issue of obesity and airlines' policy
After the incident, there were a lot of people who were from the point of view that Orto should have been allowed to fly. But critically analyzing the situation, one comes to know that the Airlines personnel was only doing its duty by questioning Orto as by boarding him with only one seat booked would not only have made him uncomfortable.
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Technological issue in homeland security
In carrying out its operations, Homeland Security Department makes use of technology since, without using technology, dealing with terrorism could be a predicament. In this paper, I will discuss how information technology has impacted the Homeland Security. In
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Ethical Issue Case Study
Therefore, once a patient is presented in the hospital, the health care providers must give them all the pertinent information that they might need in order to decide whether to undergo a risky procedure or not.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us