StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Social and Cultural Philosophy - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Social and Cultural Philosophy

The political stakes in the modern split between high and low art were never more clearly articulated than in the debate between Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno on popular culture. When Adorno described his defense οf autonomous art and Benjamin's apology for mass entertainment as torn halves οf one freedom, he located their dispute within a speculative tradition that invests aesthetic experience with emancipatory potential. The origins οf this discourse can be traced to Romanticism and its reflection on the role οf subjectivity in politics and art. Benjamin's dialogue with Adorno marked an important turning point in this narrative by unmasking its twin protagonists--the autonomous individual and its collective other--as phantasms, figments οf the Romantic imagination. By analyzing the Romantic phantasms that haunted Benjamin's dialogue with Adorno, the present essay suggests how critical subjectivity might be reconsidered in an age in which the virtual reality οf cyberspace has become second nature for many individuals.
The debate on popular culture is primarily documented in two essays--one each by Benjamin on film and Adorno on jazz--published in successive issues οf the Zeitschrift fur Sozialforschung in 1936. (Wiggershaus 191-218) Both friends were living in exile--Benjamin in Paris and Adorno in Oxford--and the letters they exchanged provide additional clues to the positions they were elaborating. If the personal hardships f emigration influenced the tenor f their dispute, then contemporary events almost certainly contributed to its sense f urgency. Everywhere the new mass media seemed subject to manipulation: by totalitarian regimes in Italy, Germany, and the USSR, and monopolizing market forces in the USA. In the 1930s, questions f popular culture became political problems f the first order.
Adorno's primary contribution to the debate, an essay titled "Uber Jazz," has a relatively uncomplicated textual history. Benjamin's contribution, "Das Kunstwerk im Zeitalter seiner technischen Reproduzierbarkeit," is another story. At Benjamin's request, the essay was published in the Zeitschrift fur Sozialforschung in French translation. This translation was based on a second, revised version f the essay. After the French translation was published, Benjamin completed a second and more radical revision f the German text, in the express hope that Bertolt Brecht would have it published in Moscow. As it turned out, none f the German versions appeared in print until Adorno and his wife Gretel included the third version f the essay in their two-volume edition f Benjamin's selected works, in 1955. This is the version that served as the basis for Harry Zohn's translation, "The Work f Art in the Age f Mechanical Reproduction," the only one available in English at this date. It is also the version that continues to serve as the basis for most academic discussion f the essay, despite the fact that both earlier versions have been made available in recent decades. (Arendt 217-51)
The result f all this is that there exists no one authoritative text f Benjamin's essay, but rather three distinct documents f a work in progress. The differences that distinguish the three texts provide as much insight into Benjamin's debate with Adorno as any one variant read in isolation. For this reason, all three versions will be considered in the discussion that follows.
Adorno first identified the Romantic phantasms haunting his dialogue with Benjamin in a letter from 18 March 1936, written to critique an unpublished manuscript f Benjamin's essay. In an attempt to mediate between their divergent views, Adorno observed that autonomous art and popular film both bear the scars f capitalist exploitation, as well as elements f change. He did not, however, suggest that high art be privileged over low. Instead, he insisted that neither be sacrificed to the other, since this would mean losing the critical potential f both. Only if high and low art are ...Show more

Summary

When Adorno described his defense οf autonomous art and Benjamin's apology for mass entertainment as torn halves οf one freedom, he located their dispute within a speculative tradition that invests aesthetic experience with emancipatory potential…
Author : kkilback
Social and Cultural Philosophy essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Social and Cultural Philosophy"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Philosophy
Some see in myth the distinct character of particular cultures, while others see universal patterns. Some regard myth as "contemporary" and "alive", while others think of it as "ancient" and/or "dead." (What is Myth?). Myth is defined from Greek word mythos meaning story or word and a study encompassing myths or body of myths is demonstrated as mythology.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Science: A Social and Cultural Examination
People in general will give much credit to science for most of today’s conveniences and technological advances. However, it can also be said that society and culture has dictated the development of scientific movements. The thesis statement is that scientific development has been influenced by social and cultural mores.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Senior Philosophy Essays for Language Philosophy and Social/Political Philosophy
It is key to note that, when Wittgenstein suggests in Proposition 4.003 of the Tractatus that “Most of the propositions and questions of philosophers arise from our failure to understand the logic of our language. (They belong to the same class as the question whether the good is more or less identical than the beautiful.) And it is not surprising that the deepest problems are in fact not problems at all”, he is not suggesting that the solution he proposes, rectifying the improper use of language, solves all problems.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy - Social Justice
They argue that it is not possible to conceive people as inherently equal with entitlement to same rights and privileges (Dudley, p. 73) From such perspectives, it is not easy to get a definition of the phrase justice society that will be generally accepted across the spectrum.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy Cultural Relativism
What at that time was regarded as ethical proved to be totally immoral now, in the twenty second century. The legacy left for us from the previous generations living in the twenty first century showed the devastating outcome of their misdeeds.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The Philosophy of Social Science
The application and actual nature of this term is variable determined by the characteristics of the change it promotes in the society namely whether beneficial or detrimental to the condition and state of the social group. In the actual perspective, social change are varies in nature where manifesting as an act of advocacy, a sort of event or action, a social behavior, and others which all promote a change in the present or the normative state of the social condition.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Philosophy
Moral voice has direct link with religious beliefs and practices of the individuals on the one hand and cultural values and social norms on the other. The social norms and morality are the identification of the individuals of a nation.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Philosophy
Why is a quiet private life the best choice for the person who desires to be happy? Epicurean philosophy believed that the fact that Gods could mete out sufferings to humans even after their death, was a major cause of anxiety and apprehension among people.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
In what ways can the philosophy and practice of cultural proficiency offer solutions to unequal health outcomes for Indigenous Australians
Indigenous Australians are the least healthy as compared to the remaining Australian population, with lower life expectancy at birth, and greater burden of illness including higher rates of mortality, disability, and hospitalization (O’Connor-Fleming & Parker, 2001).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Cultural Representations of Social Class
There any forms of cultures that have been seen as a part of the social makeup. There are certain cultures that are refined in nature, while certain ones are not. The culture is a combination of a
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation