StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Health Care Obama vs. McCain - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Health Care Obama vs. McCain

At the heart of the debate over health care are the philosophical underpinnings that determine where the responsibility for health care should lie. Obama's plan is a much more government centered plan that relies on regulation and government mandates to deliver health insurance. According to Meckler, Obama "would create a new government-run plan as well as an "exchange" in which private companies would offer insurance to compete with the government plan". This would mandate complete coverage for all children, expand the SCHIP program, and bring in many millions of adults under government funded private insurance as well as Medicaide (Bivens and Gould). Each of these actions amounts to increased regulation and extends government control over the health insurance industry (Meckler). However, this increased government involvement would assure a greater number of people are covered under the Obama plan as contrasted to the McCain plan.
McCain's plan relies on market coverage and reduces the current dependence that workers have on company provided insurance. McCain's plan would drop the tax exemption for company paid health insurance and replace it with a direct tax credit. According to the Brookings Institute "Senator McCain has proposed replacing the current exclusion from income tax for health insurance provided by an employer with a refundable tax credit of $2,500 for singles and $5,000 for family coverage" (7). According to Bivens and Gould, "This change sets off a cascade of decision-making by firms and employees, the net effect of which would be to erode some of the incentives that employers and employees have to tie health care benefits to job-based compensation and encourage health care purchase through the individual market. It would also provide incentives for people to buy less comprehensive insurance coverage". The net long-term effect of the McCain plan is less coverage with little savings over the Obama plan.
A much larger percentage of the uninsured would be covered under the Obama plan. According to the Economic Policy Institute, "The Obama plan makes a much bigger dent in covering the uninsured population. On average over the 10-year period, the Obama plan covers over 47% of the forecasted uninsured population, while the McCain plan covers less than 5%" (Bivens and Gould). The McCain plan simply encourages employers to drop their employees and give them a small tax credit and this would initially result is a dramatic drop in the rate of employer carried insurance. "A study conducted by University of Michigan economist Tom Buchmueller and colleagues published in the journal Health Affairs suggests that the McCain tax hike will lead employers to drop coverage for over 20 million Americans" (Cutler, DeLong, and Marciarille). In addition, McCain's plan allows for individuals to purchase health insurance out-of-state, which would effectively remove much of the current state regulation in the industry.
While Obama's plan will cover almost 10 times as many of the existing uninsured as the McCain plan, the costs of both plans are not dramatically different over the long-term. Meckler reports on a report released by the Tax Policy Center and states, "Sen. Obama's plan would be costly, the center concluded: $1.6 trillion over 10 years. Sen. McCain's would cost nearly as much: $1.3 trillion over the same span. The center doesn't give either campaign credit for initiatives to ...Show more

Summary

The contrasts between the two major candidates in the 2008 presidential election are as stark as any in recent history. There is a difference in age, race, style, and experience. There are also major differences in policy and the effects they will have on the future of the country's health care system…
Author : miguelconroy
Health Care Obama vs. McCain essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Health Care Obama vs. McCain"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

OBAMA HEALTH CARE REFORM
During the period of recession, he took few steps to stimulate the economy of the country. Some domestic initiatives takes during his reign were in the form of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. This act is also known as the “Obamacare”. On July 14, 2009 the house of democrats presented a plan regarding the health care system.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Health Care Reform (OBAMA)
The difference this time round is that this promise was made, and the politicians who entered into office made good of their promise to reform the health care system in the US. The Obama administration possessed the political goodwill and ambition to drive the health care reform agenda in the houses of representatives, and through a lot of political lobbying; they were able to pass two critical bills.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Presidential Election. Barack Obama vs. John McCain
The reasons behind their choices will be discussed in detail. Quite a few people, it seems, are swayed towards choosing Sen. Barack Obama from Illinois as their next President. He is ahead in the polls by most accounts, and early voting will most likely favor Barack Obama.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Economic Policy of Obama and McCain
United States has been among the selected country which has gained expertise in wide range of activities, the country is renowned for its industrial services, manufacturing, food processing, textiles, agricultural products, construction, aerospace and aviation, automobiles, research and development and pharmacy, the volume of international commercial transactions in the favour of United States increased dramatically after World War II and countries' economies became internationalized with an increasing percentage of their GNP attributable to international exchange of goods and services.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
McCain and Obama
McCain holds a senior seat in the U.S. Senate. McCain, hails from a family of soldiers. McCain's father and grandfather were both four-star admirals in the U.S. Navy. Conversely, Obama has no military experience to speak of. Perhaps the largest disparity between these two candidates is their positions on two major issues affecting this country: The war in Iraq and the economic peril in which the country now sits.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Clinton vs Obama: Campaign 2008
There are highly qualified candidates that are challenging the current Republican administration. Add Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama to this mix and America is faced with some real decisions to make in the coming year and a half.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
The Better Man
They are about better policies. Assuming a self-centered view of every individual, it is safe to say that the better policy will be the one which supports specific interest groups or classes. In other words, American votes should
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Health Care Management and Obama health care reform
US has had many policies adopted for many years and changes have been witnessed out of these adoptions in the healthcare sector and it is of late that a major bill on healthcare was passed in Congress under Barrack Obama’s
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Obama Health Care Bill
The United States senate passed it on December the 24th of 2009, with Congress passing it four months later. However, many States, individuals and organizations have gone to federal court challenging its constitutionality. Two federal appellate courts have upheld it; a third
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Government health care vs private health care
Moreover another poll in the CBS News Poll showed that 85% of the respondents wanted some major reforms in the health sector (Why We Need a Public Health-Care Plan, 2009). The argument between private and public health care has always stayed in peoples
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation