StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Law Relating to Murder - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Law Relating to Murder

The actus reus of Murder therefore requires that the defendant should have caused the death of the victim through an act of his/her own. Death should be caused within the Queen's peace and three years of the act of the defendant. In this question the defendant Zak has killed Julie. Murder is a consequence crime and therefore accordingly requires causation to be proved in order for the actus reus of murder to be proved. It is in essence proving that it was the act of the defendant that caused the death of the victim. Causation is a 2-stage test and requires firstly causation in fact. The test for causation in fact is the 'But for test' (but for the act of the defendant, would the victim still have suffered the consequences and if not then there is causation in fact). The element that has to be proved is that it was the act of the defendant that put the victim in a certain setting; in which he would not have been but for the act of the defendant. In this instance it is not difficult to prove causation in fact, as had it not been the act of Zak, Julie would not have died. Once causation in fact is proved the second test of causation has to be satisfied.
The second stage of the causation test is causation in law. ...
In this question it seems that in relation to death of Julie there is causation in law as the act of Zak was the operative and substantial cause of Julie's death. Neither had the act of Zak exhausted its effect and further it was also the significant and sole cause of Julie's death. It seems therefore that the actus reus of the offence of murder is proved as Julie dies in the fire and the place of his death is within the Queen's peace.

Mens rea for the Murder or the lack thereof

This takes us to the next issue in the question, whether Zak had the requisite mens rea for murder. The mens rea for murder is intention to kill (express malice) or cause grievous bodily harm (implied malice). Traditionally the mens rea for murder is called "malice aforethought". In Smith & Hogan Criminal Law 9th Edition malice aforethought has been defined as:

'a mere arbitrary symbol for the 'malice' may have in it nothing really malicious; and need never be really ' aforethought'.

Therefore the requirement today is that the defendant should have intended either death or grievous bodily harm as a result of his/her act. Malice aforethought is generally taken to mean that the defendant should have intention to bring about either of those two consequences. Intention can be defined as the either the purpose of the defendant's act or even if it not the purpose of the defendant's act, intention can be inferred from certain subjective foresight on part of the defendant. In other words if the defendant realizes that the consequences are virtually certain as a result of his act then the courts can hold that the defendant intended the consequences as a result of his act.

The problem here is that Mens Rea for this murder seems doubtful as it has been stated in the question. ...Show more

Summary

This question requires a discussion of the law relating to murder and whether based on the defence of intoxication Zak is able to get his sentence extinguished or based on the defence of provocation or diminished responsibility he can plead manslaughter to a charge of murder…
Author : pourosdarlene
Law Relating to Murder essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Law Relating to Murder"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The reason for the murder
This study is conducted in an attempt to stop the current trend of acquitting spouses who conspire to inherit estates of their victims. Close relations of murder victims are highly affected by the death of their loved ones. In some cases it is the spouse who kills their partner with the motive to inherit their wealth.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Murder
In the world of the legal experts, they have separate opinions with regard to the degree of motive or intent that is needed for the conviction of these two distinct crimes. Similarly, the quantum of evidence needed to satisfy the conviction of the crimes- murder and involuntary manslaughter, both require guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Law Relating to Payment and Trade Finance
Even among stakeholders in various continents, there are such attempts to make the flow of good and services across borders as easy as possible. To this effect, there has been the creation of economic and trade zones such as the European Union and the Economic Community of West African States.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Family Law - relating to divorce
Legal provisions on divorce in England and Wales form part of a larger group of family laws including legal provisions on adoption, wardship, parental responsibility, and child abduction (Manning & Cohen, 2012). All family laws, including divorce are heard in both county courts and magistrates courts (Family Proceedings Courts) which are regulated with codes of Family Procedure Rules.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Crime of murder/Criminal Law
Malice or intention specified in this section can be express or implied. Express malice is a deliberate intention in the mind of the person committing the act of taking another's life and implied malice is a situation where there is no provocation or reason for the accused committing the crime of murder.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Murder
He is also described as a sociopath, totally incapable of normal human emotions and a serial killer. His tendencies were identified by his adoptive father when he was still younger, that he supported Dexter and persuaded him to channel them into rather socially useful, such as killing bad guys specifically pedophiles.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Critical analysis of the legal principles governing the withholding/withdrawal of life sustaining treatment in incompetent adults and neonates
This presumption of duty is subject to patient's self determination and not absolute. Doctors have no obligation to commence or continue a treatment outcome of which is futile and not in the best interests of the patient. The burden of treatment is disproportionate to the positive outcome.
33 pages (8250 words) Essay
Law on Involuntary Manslaughter
Precisely, manslaughter can be classified into two. The first one is voluntary manslaughter, and the other is involuntary manslaughter. Voluntary manslaughter can be distinguished as homicide if the death of a person is caused by an intentional act provided that the special requirements for the offences of murder, manslaughter, homicide at the request of the victim, complicity in suicide or infanticide are not fulfilled.
31 pages (7750 words) Essay
Criminal Law
s the discussion here will be based upon a detailed analysis of the law relating to the offence of Murder and relevant offences of Provocation, Diminished Responsibility and Intoxication. Murder is the killing of a human being by a human being within the Queen’s peace, death
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Criminal Law
In a case involving Patrick Kennedy of Louisiana, the accused was charged with molesting his step-daughter, and was given the death penalty. However, the Supreme Court overruled
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation