StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Ethics, Genetics and Reproduction Philosophy - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Ethics, Genetics and Reproduction Philosophy

Had the things been that simple, any type of intellectual debate would have become a mere travesty that would have predominantly remained confined to evaluating the emerging social and ethical issues by the established yardsticks. However, this was never to happen. Luckily, such a travesty of intellectual and ethical catechism is infact next to impossible in the contemporary technology driven society where the emergence of latest scientific discoveries and novel possibilities infact more then ever impinges upon the collective human consciousness to see and analyze the emerging issues in a multifaceted context. In such a mature and liberal social scenario, issues related to fertility, reproduction and surrogate motherhood assume special significance in an ethical, legal, theological and philosophical context that attract the attention and interest of thinkers and intellectuals from all the spheres of social life. In her work 'The Case against the Legalization of Contract Motherhood', Christine Overall defines surrogate motherhood as, "a reproductive practice in which a women agrees before becoming pregnant, to surrender the baby she gestates to a man who has commissioned the pregnancy, usually in return for a set fee (112)." As is evident to any thinking individual, the issue is doubtlessly open to a variety of conflicting opinions and is fraught with contention, so far as its ethical and legal ramifications are concerned. It not only invites a debate on the issue of the 'right to reproduce', but also implores whether the criminalization of commercial surrogacy contracts infringe upon the right to reproduce. A whole spectrum of opinions exists on the issue under consideration that vary from being outright endorsing or reprehensive to those somewhat being mild, liberal and situation based. The case of Mary Beth v/s William Stern litigated in the Supreme Court of New Jersey infact raised more issues that are relevant to the given topic then coming out with ample inalienable and irrefutable conclusions and guidelines.
Many of the outspoken feminists hold that commercial surrogacy amounts to trivializing the whole concept of labor and motherhood. The very fact that such activities are coordinated and conducted by astute brokers makes the whole thing sound more of an industrial activity then the scared and sensitive experience of becoming a mother. This issue is fraught with grave possibilities, so far as the status of the women and the children in the society is concerned. It can not only thwart the society's onward march to achieving sexual equality, but has the potential to infringe upon the rights of the children. The problem is that most of the heard of opinions till now, pertaining to this issue were forwarded by theologians and conservatives. This temporarily obfuscated the logical and rational moorings of the whole issue and made it seem anti-science and recidivist. Still, there is no dearth of critics who are outright modern and contemporary in their perspective and who denounce the idea of contractual surrogacy on the more understandable grounds of human exploitation and the blatant commercialization of the ability to reproduce.
There exists a school of opinion makers of ...Show more

Summary

Ever since the times of the Greeks and the Romans, to the onset of the biblically inspired doctrines in the West, the course of free thinking and ethical evaluation has been vehemently opposed to any stark homogenization of values. Contention can sometimes turn out to be a positive attribute in the sense that the emergence of contentious issues in a social set up is often indicative of a vibrant and evolving society…
Author : sashapagac
Ethics, Genetics and Reproduction Philosophy essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Ethics, Genetics and Reproduction Philosophy"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Philosophy Ethics
Mill explained that Rule Utilitarianism was the rule that worked towards maximizing happiness. According to this rule an act is moral and correct if it brings about happiness for the maximum number of people. In the same way it puts an action to be morally incorrect if it brings about unhappiness and is the cause of displeasure for the maximum number of people.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
According to Nietzsche, master morality is based on strength and what is strong is good while that which is weak is wrong, therefore, those who have master morality are strong and have created their own morality and they judge themselves. For master morality, bad is seen as a failure and a defeat as well as loss of power (Solomon132).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Ethics Philosophy
Mill maintains that this, "the other party," knows better than to want to and choose to exchange places with a lower being, pig or fool, basing his assertions a number of reasons. First, he says, the party that has a range of higher faculties at their disposal would not trade places with an inferior being, even given that being's range of faculties, it's "fullest allowance of pleasures." (326) Nor would the intelligent, superior party be convinced that the inferior party is better off overall, no matter how happy or how much happier-except, maybe, Mill notes, in the case of a truly miserable human who would do anything to escape his/her sufferingeven if this means lowering him/herself.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Philosophical JournalDiary reflecting one's own thoughts and opinions upon several topics. Details below
Their views differ in claims and rights of the patient. The pro choice group insists on the autonomy that gives a right to refuse life support treatment in case of painful living. The opposite group talks about the choice of decision maker who can offer necessary pain relief treatment even in the context of shortening of life.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
The paper also throws light on the ethical issues raised in human life while entering into interaction with others in everyday life. The term ethics simply stands for the rules or principles prescribed, adopted and followed by some specific group,
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
Consequently, an act admirable in one culture and an overwhelming majority of the population follows the same, while the same rule is viewed to be condemnable and shameful in some other society. Thus, different societies observe divergent social norms,
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy Ethics
The paper is also interested in developing a powerful professional code of ethics, which will not allow the corporations and organizations to violate
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
REPRODUCTION
When a woman is pregnant, it illustrates a new life growing inside her womb thus; she bears ethical obligations to the fetus. This serves to limit pregnancy termination as a viable option by
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Reproduction
The paper will focus on the process of spermatogenesis in the male’s testis as well as oogenesis in the female. The process of spermatogenesis is a complex thing that takes place in the male. The male reproductive system comprises of a
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation