StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Homework # 2 - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Homework # 2

There are several ways in which to impeach a witness at trial. Here, because the proceedings are criminal in nature, we would be dealing with the federal rules of evidence and also the federal rules of criminal procedure. Impeachment tools such as opinion, reputation and specific Instances (Fed. Ru. Evid. 608), is based upon opinion or reputation testimony.
This type of evidence is only admissible after the character of the witness is attacked by evidence of any form. Here for example, since Ralph noted on his application that he never had an accident, his driving record could be introduced as evidence to impeach his testimony, the testimony being Ralph's application (which is considered to be a federal document because it is submitted to the port authority which is a government entity) and demonstrate that it was false, thus proving that Ralph has a propensity to lie. Furthermore, any witnesses on Ralph's behalf would be properly questioned in order to impeach Ralph's character for truthfulness as well. (Fed. Ru. Evid. 608).
It is true that Ed Norton would testify that Ralph is a great guy and a terrific friend, but he has no business or employment relationship with Ralph. It should be noted that Ed as a character witness will be questioned about specific instances of conduct on part of the Ralph as the principal witness to test his knowledge on Ralph's character. Thus Ed may be questioned on whether Ralph ever told him about his high school suspension. It must be noted that any defense attorney worth their salt would immediately object to the question if at the time of Ralph's arrest, the high school suspension was over ten years old. This rule applies if more than ten years has elapsed since the later date between the following: (1) the date of the conviction and (2) release of the witness from the confinement imposed for that conviction .
Here, it is true that Ralph was not convicted at the time his suspension for a crime related to it. One might first think that the suspension would not find its' way into trial however there are exceptions to this rule of evidence. Specific instances of misconduct that did not result in a conviction can be admitted for impeachment purposes if the scope of its admission is to demonstrate the witnesses character for truthfulness, in the discretion of the court the probative value of the question outweighs any prejudice to the defendant; the evidence is offered in good faith; the act has a direct bearing on the veracity of the witness with regards to the issues being litigated. It cannot be understated that extrinsic evidence of specific instances of prior bad acts is not permitted when their only relevance is to impeach the witnesses credibility. Thus, it appears that Ralph's high school suspension would be admitted at trial. It should be noted again that the trial court enjoys immense discretion so the ten year limitation may be construed by the court to apply to non convicted prior bad acts. For example, if Ralph is 25 at the time of trial, the suspension may be admitted, but if he is 35 at the time of trial, it most likely will not. Finally, we do not usually see this type of evidence offered unless the parties know each other.
Fed. Ru. Evid 613, applies to the prior inconsistent statements of a witness. Here, Ralph is prepared to testify that he never said "That could just as easily have been your head." In examining a witness ...Show more

Summary

The purpose of impeaching a witness during trial is to discredit him, and annihilate with as much force as possible, if possible, the weight and effect of his testimony. The rules relating to the impeachment of a witness apply to the defendant when he becomes a witness very much the same as applied to other witnesses…
Author : dixie24
Homework # 2 essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Homework # 2"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Banking in the modern world Homework 2
Duration (years) Dollar Amount (millions) Investment Grade Bonds - L 15.00 $65.00 Commercial Loans – A 3.00 $400.00 Consumer Loans – A 7.00 $250.00 Deposits –L 1.25 $600.00 Nondeposit Borrowings -L 0.50 $50.00 $1365 A. What is the weighted average duration of the Blue Moon’s asset portfolio and liability portfolio?
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Student Homework
They are there for your reference. If you can locate the actual page numbers in the book please replace the ones cited with the correct ones. If you need me to cite each web page chapter I can do that, but it seems less academic that way.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Homework Debate
They have some subjects that are easy for them and others that are very difficult. When they have to take work home, it takes away from the opportunity to rest and relax. All children need the opportunity to move away from school and do something
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Homework
Under the new law, John Adams had allotted “Midnight Judges” so that Federalists could take control over the federal judiciary before Thomas Jefferson. This action was an effort to impasse the Democratic Republicans. But in order to take effect of the new
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Homework
In order to reduce the rate of unemployment from 8.2% to a lower rate, the government requires increasing its spending and lowering the rates of taxation. Through lowering the rate of taxation, individuals will be capable of borrowing at low rates,
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Homework 2
In the paper, the data was obtained from the World Fact book. According to the records in the book, it is clearly seen that the Gross Domestic Product of the 22 Arab League members was 2649.6 billion US dollars. The
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Business ethic homework 2
Business should comply with all three of the C’s of doing business in an ethical manner if they want to continue to attract customers and avoid legal charges. 2. Kant promotes the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Homework
237) Traditional file environment does not guarantee data security while database environment stores data in electronic form and that is what guarantees security of the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Homework
The batch size would therefore comprise of the average number of times that it would add up to form the average inventory. The need is to find out how average inventory is formed up since the batch size may or may not be changed at
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Homework 2
They also self organize by encouraging their physical co-location or close collaboration online of all members of the developmental group (Rubin 103). Such team members also conduct
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation