StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Most-Favoured-Nation - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Most-Favoured-Nation

MFN is regarded as an important standard code of international commercial transaction. It has been said that MFN clause is one of the commonly adopted principle in the international investment2 domain. The definition of Most favoured-Nation is3 well explained in Article 5 of International law commission Draft Articles4,
Treatment accorded by the granting State to the beneficiary State, or to person or things in a determined relationship with that State, not less favoured than treatment extended by the granting State to a third State or to person things in the same relationship with that third state.
The scope of Most Favoured nation is a two way sword creating controversies related to whether the international investment treaties covers jurisdictional or procedural matters. The inclusion of MFN clauses became a general practice in the numerous bilateral, regional and multilateral investment-related agreements till 1950.
The aim of MFN clause is to reiterate the importance of equality of treatment irrespective of the nationality of the investors5 and eliminate the discriminative forces.MFN clause had a variant approach towards different treaties leading to more problems in identifying the scope and extend protections based on different treaties and their conditional clauses.
Thi...
There are 2 differing hypothesis raised by experts on the scope of MFN clause such as

MFN clause could be extended to cover jurisdictional matter.
The scope of application of the MFN clause concerned does not cover procedural or jurisdictional matter.
The above hypothesis involves 2 conditional clauses to facilitate the jurisdiction concept. First clause is that the starting point of interpretation process should be a MFN clause. Second clause assumes that the MFN clause allows the incorporation of the provisions of the dispute settlement mechanism included in third-party BITs8.
Overview of Recent Arbitration Cases
Among the numerous cases brought to ICSID9 in recent years, two cases, Maffezini v. Kingdom of Spain10 and Tecnicas MedioAmbientales Tecmed S.A. v. the United Mexican States stand out as raising issues concerning the MFN clause. In Argentina and Spain treaty(hereinafter BIT) ,the claimant can avoid stipulations in the absence of the a friendly settlement and negotiation within six months period, the host state has eighteen months trial period to work on the dispute as the disputes are first filed at the local courts of the host state. Host state should make an attempt to resolve the dispute before the claimant approaches tribunal arbitration as the next step. The invoking of MFN clause by the claimant refers the Article IV (2) of the Argentina-Spain BIT that.
In all matters subject to this, treatment shall be no less favourable than that extended By each Party to the investments made in its territory by investors of a third country11.

The above article guarantees a fair and equitable treatment for the claimant and there can be a replacement ...Show more

Summary

Critically analyse whether the scope of application of the Most-Favoured-Nation (MFN) treatment clause in investment treaties covers jurisdictional or procedural matters, taking into account the recent arbitration cases.
Most-Favoured-Nation (MFN) acts as a binding force linking investment treaties with Jurisdiction…
Author : margaretteframi
Most-Favoured-Nation essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Most-Favoured-Nation"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

How can globalisation processes help alleviate poverty
Globalisation processes expands trade between countries and with this expansion additional jobs becomes available to the poverty stricken population. Globalisation is the result of the WTO and GATT agreements that calls for the internationalization of trade.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Internationl Economic Law
This paper discusses these two concepts in critical detail. Most Favoured Nation (MFN) The Most-Favoured Nation treatment principle is one of the most primary principles developed by the World Trade Organization (WTO). Countries that obtain the MFN status have the benefit of trade advantages by nations providing this treatment1.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Critically Assess the Scope, Meaning and Relevance of Non-Discrimination in WTO Agreements
The WTO rules permit tariffs and other varieties of restrictions that assist to safeguard a nation from unfair trades. Thus , the phrase “ free trade “ can better be explained as a market where business can happen in an open and a fair field where there exists no ingenuous competition.
17 pages (4250 words) Essay
Anti Trust
This shifts the risks and liabilities of the patient on the shoulders of the service providers. The objective of the thesis is to research a recent case related to a health care organization in United States that has been charged with anti-trust action. On the basis of this case and lessons learnt from analysis, the report advises and recommends the senior management on how it could avoid threat of Federal Trade Commission (FTC) investigation if the company were to merge with other health care organizations.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Foreign Investment
The MFN clauses connect investment accords by making sure that the parties to a treaty confer treatment favorably no less than the treatment they confer under other treaties in matters embraced by the clause. Thus, MFN clauses have become an essential tool for economic liberalization in the matter of investment.1 Further, by granting the investors the right in a country's MFN clause for the same treatment no less favourable than that of a country's major partners, MFN forestalls economic changes that would arise by way of more country-by-country liberalization.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Non-discrimination is a Cornerstone of GATT Law
Adherence by the U.S. to GATT has brought about numerous changes to the U.S. Patent System that brings U.S. patent law into closer harmony with the patent systems of other countries. (Oppedahl Patent Law Firm LLC, 1993). The GATT established trade principles that continue to be applied today.
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Critically analyse whether the scope of application of the Most-Favoured-Nation (MFN) treatment clause in investment treaties covers jurisdictional or procedural matters, taking into account the recent arbitration cases
The MFN clauses connect investment accords by making sure that the parties to a treaty confer treatment favorably no less than the treatment they confer under other treaties in matters embraced by the clause. Thus, MFN clauses have become an essential tool for
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC LAW Assignment
l reveal the reality that discrimination and inequity has endured and persisted even with the constitution and noblest intentions of the united super body. Indeed, the consultative and collegial nature of the WTO proceedings evince a democratic process under the one nation one
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
How can globalisation processes help alleviate poverty
ties, standards and services – that could enable them to play the roles, meet their obligations and participate in the relationships and customs of their society (Townsend, 2006). Globalisation processes expands trade between countries and with this expansion additional jobs
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Business Environment Analysis and Research - Political Trade Arguments
Since each dispute has different background and justification, it would be very challenging to reject or accept any argument. However, if certain arguments insist that the uninterrupted trade relations would add acts of terrorism, international
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation