StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

History of the Middle East, 6001453 - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
History of the Middle East, 6001453

When the aforementioned is compounded with the fact that neither really knew the other and that, ultimately, the Christian Crusaders were entering into a territory alien to them and which, historically speaking, they had no territorial claim over, prejudices only deepen. These prejudices color historical accounts, as is amply evidenced in the contrasts which exist between the European and the Muslim accounts of the First Crusade. While there is consensus over historical events, these accounts are markedly different in terms of portrayals/depictions of the other.
Consensus prevails with regard to the history of the first crusades. As Gibb (1950) explains in his article, "The Arabic Sources for the Life of Saladdin," the two most prominent of the recorded eye-witness accounts, those by William of Tyre and Ibn Al Athir, similarly report Christian military victory over the Muslims. Indeed, Ibn Al Athir, as does William of Tyre, writes that when the Crusaders first came to the Arab lands in 1095-1096, they achieved tremendous victories over the Muslims. The Europeans, according to both, overtook several Muslim provinces, such as Toledo, Andalusia and Sicily, extending their armies to invade Antioch and most importantly, Jerusalem (cited in Gibb, 1950). The implication here is that there is agreement over the basic historical facts.
Consensus also prevails over the reasons for the Muslim defeat and European victory. As is evident from Amin Maalouf's (2001) account of the Crusades as recorded and reported by Muslim historians, Arab defeat was an outcome, not just of petty rivalry among various Arab leaders and factions, but of the Crusaders' utter and unshakable conviction that they were doing the work of God. This belief propelled the Crusaders towards victory, while lack of cohesion among the Muslims quite effectively determined their defeat (Maalouf, 2001). The Arab and European accounts of the Fall of Jerusalem do not differ much in this respect.
The above identified similarities should not obscure the fact that there are marked differences between the two accounts, especially with regard to depictions of the other. A reading of Ibn Al Athir's account of the encounter evidences the extent to which the other' was perceived of in terms of prejudiced stereotypes (cited in Gabrielli, 1984). For example, Usama's account of "Frankish Medicine," expresses the idea that, irrespective of Christian victories, the Crusaders had neither civilization nor knowledge. Indeed, Usama claims that European doctors killed, rather than cured, their patients practicing a form of medicine that had little to do with scientific knowledge (cited in Gabrielli, 1984). Other eyewitness accounts advance Usama's perceptions of the Crusaders as an ignorant and uncivilized people through unflattering descriptions of their lifestyles, style of eating and personal hygiene (Gabrielli, 1984). Indeed, it would hardly be an exaggeration were one to assert that Muslim eyewitness accounts of the encounter tend towards the portrayal of others as uncivilized savages.
Interestingly, Christian accounts of the encounter tend towards a similarly unflattering description. This is amply evidenced in Mansses II's congratulatory letter to the Crusaders. Within the context of this letter, the victory is applauded in terms that speak of religious conflict and an ...Show more

Summary

In 1099, the First Crusades ended with the Fall of Jerusalem, from the Arab perspective, and with the Return of Jerusalem to Christendom from the Christian perspective. An understanding of the sensitivity of the Crusades and the reason why historical accounts differ so vastly is predicated on an appreciation of the implications of the event…
Author : medhurstelian
History of the Middle East, 6001453 essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"History of the Middle East, 6001453"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Middle East History Questions
The American Revolutionary War was both bloody and costly but the American republican army regained strategic control in all regions and rebuilt the new nation founded with ideological precept of independence, enlightenment and liberalism which became the pillars of Republican worldview.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
MIDDLE EAST
Gokalp spread the message that Turkish nationalism was impossible without Islam. 2. Sati al-Husri – a founder and supporter of Arab Nationalism, a philosopher of Syrian origin born in Yemen. Husri built his ideas on the principles and values of German romanticism.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Middle East History: Arab Identity
He begins his essay emphatically by stating “The day Islam gave a new concept of values and standards to mankind and showed the way to learn these values and standards, it also provided it with a new concept of human relationships. Islam came to return man to his Sustainer and to make is guidance the only source from which values and standards are to be obtained, as He is the Provider and Originator.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Contemporary Middle East History
Colonized by the Ottoman Empire during the 17th century and much of the 18th centuries and during much of the 18th and 19th centuries by Britain and France, the Middle East has endured the reign of foreign influences affecting its modern day political realities.
25 pages (6250 words) Essay
Middle East
The basic reason for the conflict is over the land they share. While examining the conflict between Israel and Palestine, this paper will cover the history of the two groups, more recent issues and a solution to resolving the issue. The "Israel-Palestine Question" may not be resolved anytime soon, but a better understanding of the situation may start the process.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Middle east history
Most of the Islamic empire had already fragmented into separate states and rules wherein the caliphs lost their power to autocrats in their territories. Add to this the sudden threat the foreign incursion of the Berbers of Africa, the Crusades of Pope Urban, the Turks and the Mongols posed to the region.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Middle East
pments of the countries in the region making it hard for them to achieve considerable growth since most of these countries resources and finances are diverted to the security measures. The root cause of the said conflicts includes ideas, persons and events .One of the events was
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Middle east
These issues are not focused to address European and American interests rather to point out the upcoming trends in demographic and social characteristics. People have now demanded more than what they have been getting in terms of democracy and equal opportunities, in short
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Middle east
in the region?  Before oil was discovered in Middle East, this region had become a major target for a myriad of religious conflicts and wars, which were fought over the rich resources found there and the amount of land. When the Ottoman Empire
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Middle east
The main reason why Israel has maintained disputed settlements in Gaza and West Bank is the need to control water resource in the region. The Middle East and North Africa are the driest
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation