Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Victimology and Alternatives to the Traditional Justice System - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
College
Author : ioreilly
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 6 (1506 words)

Summary

There are emerging questions and arguments challenging the role of traditional justice system in preventing crimes. Traditional justice has been with us for quite a long time now but considering existing imprisonment statistics, it seems that there is a need to look into other alternative approaches when dealing with crimes (Zehr, 1990; Walker, 2000)…

Extract of sample
Victimology and Alternatives to the Traditional Justice System

And these values would soon drastically increase if nothing would be done about it (Raspberry, 2003).
The current justice system is basically grounded on retributive values wherein justice determines the crime or violation, then enjoins the victim, offender and the community to reach solutions of "repair, reconciliation and assurance" (Zehr, 1990;Walker, 2000).
Anthropologist Ruth Benedict states that the emphasis of using shame or guilt to control social activities could be a way of categorizing cultures. Some Asian cultures like China and Japan are considered shame cultures in contrast to European and modern American cultures like the US which is said to be "guilt-based." To illustrate, traditional Japanese and Ancient Greek society put more importance to the social consequences of "getting caught" than the feelings of guilt of the offender ("Shame," 2006).
The violation of shared opinions and expected behaviors causing the feeling of shame has proved to be efficient in guiding society's behavior. Shame is used against relational aggression and is considered effective in marriage, family and church settings. Also, it is used in the workplace as a form of covert social control ("Shame," 2006).
Shame is considered as a pillar of punishment. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Juvenile Justice System
The most important facet of all this is the "best interest of the child" theory that guided the courts lingers in the purpose clauses of juvenile codes throughout the world.4 However, it seems to have failed to address the concerns raised by victims or communities about the juvenile justice system. The therapeutic intervention and punishment models of justice also…
6 pages (1506 words)
Japan’s Criminal Justice System
Because the present Civil Code contains ambiguous and imprecise provisions with regard to evidence, judges seek to recompose and unify them in a simple form οf principles and exceptions: "if such facts exist, such a right shall be recognized, except when." It is likely that, rather than scrupulously reflecting the distribution οf the burden οf proοf in terminology, the drafters οf the Code did not have enough time to account for the opinions οf judges who only recently had taken up their duties. Although contemporary positivist judges do not directly criticize the Civil Code, academics…
15 pages (3765 words)
Colombian сriminal justice system
Inequality among citizens and various indigenous communities, weak governments, absence of citizen participation in governance, widespread corruption, and an ineffective legal system have been root cause of Colombia's problems and have strengthened criminals such as Pablo Escobar.Bowden's statement in the book 'Killing Pablo' that "Its government is weak, by design and tradition. In vast regions to the south and west, and even in the mountain villages outside the major cities, live communities only lightly touched by nation, government, or law" lays open the structural deficiencies of…
2 pages (502 words)
Cubas' Criminal Justice System
This led to the Spanish-American war of 1898 where Spain was defeated as a direct result of the intervention of the United States. After suffering a profound defeat, Cuba gained its independence from Spain only to realize that they were now under American rule (Library of Congress/Spanish American War, http:/www.loc.gov/rr/hispanic/1898/trask.html). For the next four years Cuba remained under American rule and obtained its independence on May 20, 1902. Cuba has since been a republic operating under the basic tenets of the Communist Manifesto as delineated by Karl Marx. The Communist Manifesto…
10 pages (2510 words)
CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE – VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, POSITIVE IMPACT, CONSIDERATION OF VICTIMS IN CJS, NEGATIVE IMPACT, DOES RESTORATIVE JUSTIC
Punishment and penal institutions, which, ideally, should be the answer to this malady, seem to produce an angrier, undesirable convicts more likely to become recidivists. Judicial systems and policy makers are, thus, under public pressure to find alternatives to traditional justice systems. Ruth Morris (1994) explains that a shift to alternative models is practical because, first, it is expensive to maintain prisons and finally, incarceration and punishment is unjust and immoral. “Our retributive justice system is based on a spirit of revenge which does not satisfy the primary healthy needs…
4 pages (1004 words)
Children Victimology: Issues in the Criminal Justice System
In the year 2001, more than three million reports related to child abuse were investigated by different child-related agencies, which indicated that enforcement agencies are informed of more than 2,000 children got missing during their process in the criminal justice system. (Gibson, pp. 23-25)…
Criminal Justice / VICTIMOLOGY
The reason that there are more non-violent offenders than violent offenders in our prisons is simply because there are more criminals committing non-violent crimes than are committing violent crimes. In fact, the number of violent crimes, and therefore incarcerated violent criminals, has recently reached an all-time low (Truman and Rand, 2010). Statistically, this is going to result in most of the space in the prison system being taken up by the non-violent offenders.…
4 pages (1004 words)