Uncle Tom's Cabin and Benito Cereno - Book Report/Review Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Uncle Tom's Cabin and Benito Cereno

Stowe herself had always thought that her novel depicted the favorable side f slavery, and the fact that she did so should have appeased the South. The typical Southern reaction, however, did not reflect such an awareness. Indeed, in the eyes f most contemporary Southerners (even those who had never read Uncle Tom's Cabin) Stowe's novel was an abomination, utterly false and therefore a full-fledged misrepresentation f the institution f slavery (Johnston 263).
Whereas, in one respect, Southern criticism regarding the veracity f Uncle Tom's Cabin was justified, most contemporary Southern readers f the novel failed to give Stowe the credit she obviously sought. Still, in both overt and subtle ways, Stowe had consciously attempted to appease the South. Like Melville's Benito Cereno, one such concession in Uncle Tom's Cabin, which has been overlooked by previous critics, is found in chapter 19 when Augustine St. Clare recounts to his wife Marie an incident in the past when he conquered an unsubmissive slave with kindness. He does this in response to Marie's complaint about a lazy slave her father had once owned who did not want to work.
A sensitive, kind, and effeminate man, St. Clare purchases from his brother Alfred an unruly slave named Scipio. ...
Download paper


The use f racial stereotypes adds credibility to the long-standing notion that both Stowe and Melville consciously made concessions to the South in Uncle Tom's Cabin and Benito Cereno. As Forrest Wilson has pointed out, "the kindest, most philanthropic, and most upright characters were, with some minor exceptions, all Southerners and slave-holders" (276)…
Author : sandy90

Related Essays

Uncle Tom's Cabin and Surfacing
In contrast,…
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Uncle Tom's Cabin and Surfacing Book Report/Review
Set in the wilderness of Canadian islands, it is a hauntingly evocative mystery story. Although the stories of both the novels are separated by a century and a half, and take place in different countries, they both leave an indelible impression on the reader's mind. While Eliza in Uncle Tom's Cabin faces many hardships before she attains freedom, the narrator of Surfacing deals with the internal upheavals in her mind to attain emotional freedom. Both the women refuse to think that they are weak and powerless .…
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Huckleberry Finn or Uncle Tom Cabin
ano)-to a slave trader. Although Emily Shelby despises such an idea as she had assured her maid that her child, in no way , would be sold; Emily's son, George Shelly (Thomas Fritsch), detests to see Tom leaving as he finds him as his great friend and guide.…
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Frankenstein and Uncle Tom's Cabin
In Uncle Tom's Cabin, Tom and Eva share a friendship that not only change them but it changes other who witness the bond that these two friends share. Both stories demonstrate how seemingly, small, insignificant events can impact our lives in a positive way; we simply need to recognize that they are there. Surprising incidentals teach us that sometimes the best things in life are unexpected.…
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Frankenstein and Uncle Toms Cabin
Victor's monster, on the other hand, does just the opposite in responding to his difficult circumstances in that he lives his days bent on revenge and will settle for nothing less. Each character illustrates the power of personal choice and free will for because they each made a conscious decision and remained true to that choice. Tom emerges a better man because he decides not to let slavery destroy his self-esteem and appreciation for life. The last image we have of Victor's monster is a dejected individual swimming in pain for the rest of his days. These characters demonstrate the…
3 pages (753 words) Book Report/Review
Uncle Tom's Children/Uncle Tom's Cabin Essay Assignment
ies “Big Boy Leaves Home” and “Down by the Riverside,” Wright uses the technique of literary realism to illustrate just how terrible the treatment of black people by white people really was.…
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!