Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults

The researchers are all eminently qualified in the fields of research, nursing, education and management. Their vast combined experience and the geographical position from which they operate suggests a thorough knowledge of the topic. Both Shreffler-Grant and Weinart have researched and published in the areas of Holistic Nursing, Hospices, (Shreffler-Grant) Small Rural Hospital Care, (Shreffler- Grant), Rural Women (Weinert), and Chronic Health Conditions (Weinert). Bette Ide has developed a Farm/Ranch Stress Scale, published on Ethical issues in the quality of care and health related hardiness and service use of rural older adults, while Elizabet Nichols has vast managerial and educational experience. Their qualifications include PhD., R.N., and professorial positions, all quality attributes which give confidence in the study and report. The article, as published in Public Health Nursing Vol 22 No.4 in July 2005, does not give a clear statement of when exactly the work was carried out. Page 326, para 3 has a reference (Shreffler 1999) and p325 mentions a paper published by an undergraduate as a result of involvement in this work, dated 2003.
While the Abstract directs us to the Objective and hypothesis, there is no clear framework or map as such. ...
Download paper


The title does not entirely describe the study and nor does it contain the variables. It needs to clarify what is meant by 'older', which 'rural' areas were involved and define the variables. An alternative title could be:
While the Abstract explains the purpose of the study, it is vague in parts…
Author : chills

Related Essays

Depression in Older Adults
Taking this finding into consideration, offering mental health practitioners strategies on how to properly assess and make referrals for depression in older adults during primary care visits is a key function of the book. The suggested strategies are rated with letter grades indicating their strength based on the relationship between the strategy and empirical evidence that supports its effectiveness, making it an efficient reference material. With medications allowing for people to live and work for longer period, treating depression and increasing functionality and quality of life are of...
2 pages (502 words) Book Report/Review
The use of complementary atlternative medicine (CAM)
What we have seen with Mr. Cohen is his oxygen saturation varies with torso position, physical activity, and Albuterol treatments. In terms of torso position, Mr. Cohen tends to keep the head of bed up with helps keep fluid flow away from his solar plexus which helps him breath easier, but it cause lower back pain. Percocet helps relieve the pain. Sometimes, Mr. Cohen leans over his bedside table to assist his breathing by increasing pressure on his solar plexus region to augment pulmonary diffusion of oxygen. When he does this his lungs sounds clear but diminished on both sides. His oxygen...
2 pages (502 words) Research Paper
Research Critique on Nursing Healthcare
It allows the reader to easily interpret the content of the study. The title is informative and it indicates the focus of the study. It allows the reader to easily interpret the content of the study. The locale of the study, the population involved, and the period when the data were gathered were all omitted on the title but were indicated on the description of participants on page 347 of the research. It was broad enough to include all aspects of the subject matter studied or to be studied. Hence, the title indicated what the readers should expect to find inside the thesis report. It was...
16 pages (4016 words) Book Report/Review
Physical Activity for Older Adults
Apart from the drawing conclusions, the authors of the article have found little nuggets of information that have been overlooked by other researchers, for one reason or another. They are such nuggets that give distinction to the work and make it not only credible but also innovative.
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Extensive Critique on Complementary therapy practice: defining the role of advanced nurse practitioners.J Clin Nurs. 2003 Nov;12(6):816-23 using problem stateme
The aim was to determine the nurses’ knowledge, attitudes, and use of complementary/alternative therapies (CAT). Eighty eight percent of those surveyed were open or eager to use CAT, and 60% reported moderate or greater desire to use CAT. This was in spite of barriers like lack of knowledge, time, and training. The level of knowledge was highest for diet, exercise, massage, prayer, and music therapy. From this, it was concluded that “critical care nurses are open to CAT use and many use them in their own practice” (Tracy MF, Lindquist R, Watanuki S, 2003). Increasing the scientific base...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Nutrition assessment in older adults
s defined as “faulty or inadequate nutritional status; undernouishment characterized by insufficient dietary intake; poor appetite, muscle wasting and weight loss” (Chen et al, 2001: 131).
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
asure would be to develop an appropriate intervention program that not only screens the elderly population for depression and other suicide risk factors, but educates, informs, supports, and helps the elderly know that their thoughts are not taboo, but need to be talked about.
6 pages (1506 words) Research Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!