Should circumstantial evidence be the sole basis for a conviction in capital cases - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Should circumstantial evidence be the sole basis for a conviction in capital cases

When a prosecutor brings a capital case, which is also called a death penalty case, she must charge one or more "special circumstances" that the jury must find to be true in order to sentence the defendant to death. (http://www.nolo.com/definition.cfm/term/52557AC3-B765-4BEE-B51CE8A9811D2939, para 1) These circumstances should be able to give enough proof that a capital crime is committed by the accused beyond doubt. These "special circumstances" should be able to lead the prosecution to the person who has truly committed the crime.
Circumstantial evidence is just as important as direct evidence. These are evidence of facts from which inferences or presumptions can be drawn. Providing circumstantial evidence from a capital crime aids in the conviction of the right person responsible for the crime committed. Prosecutors are able to create a picture of how the crime may have been committed given the circumstantial evidences. It may even lead them to further investigation of the crime that may lead them to the direct evidences that might give them clues as to the actual crime scene. Circumstantial evidence may at the same time provide the investigators a guide to get the right convict. ...
Download paper

Summary

Capital cases are death penalty cases that require an intense investigation on a given case. Evidences obtained from the scene of the crime should be scrutinized diligently to avoid circumstances of laying down a wrong verdict on the case. Being meticulous about the given evidences regarding the crime committed by the assumed convict is normal in such a way that the verdict given may be laid down to the wrong person…
Author : cartermaddison

Related Essays

Evidence
It is well known that most people tend to retain more of what they see than what they hear. This lends to what some see as an advantage for the prosecution, but demonstrative evidence must pass several tests before admission in a trial. First, there are specific rules pertaining to each type of demonstrative evidence. For instance, if presenting a police sketch as evidence, there is a possibility that it may not be admissible because it is ruled to be hearsay. Second, there are rules for demonstrative evidence in general. For instance, an accident reconstruction chart presented as evidence...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Capital
The results of the strategy are dependent of the performance of the companies....
14 pages (3514 words) Essay
Marketing Cases Problem Solving
A.1. can also try to develop its own tie-ups with the distributors of its product, like the grocery stores and restaurants....
4 pages (1004 words) Case Study
CU Boxes, Inc. Capital Budget Recommendation on a New Boot Sole Machine
The CFO has been tasked with offering a recommendation as to whether to stay the course with the current machine, delay the purchase, or buy the machine. For the purposes of this budgetary review and analysis the following assumptions are made: CU Boxes, Inc.'s discount rate shall be 10%. Let's see how the CFO tackles this request....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Evidence Law
In such cases, it is deemed that the confessions ceases to be reliable, and, as a result, may not tenable in a Court of Law. In such cases, what needs to be assessed is not what transported after the confessions was obtained, but what anteceded the confession, or in other words, the role of actions that led to the signing of the confessions by the defendants. "To justify the arrest, there had to be evidence that would lead a reasonable person to suspect that the arrestee had committed the offence." (What is a citizen's arrests 2007)....
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Criminal Justice on the Memphis 3 boys
Misskelley was able to point to the police the boy who was castrated which was not yet publicly known at the time the confession was made....
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
I have chosen to look at the Death Penalty in America. Each state in the US has a different view on what is and what is not a capital crime and how it should be addressed. My paper will look at several states that support the death penalty and do not.
Some states like Wisconsin, Michigan, New Jersey, Hawaii and the District of Columbia have already abolished the use of death penalty while states like California, Georgia, Florida, North and South Carolina, and Texas among others still enact the practice (Galliher et al. 6)....
8 pages (2008 words) Research Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!