John Stuart Mills Harm Principle - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
John Stuart Mills Harm Principle

If we count mere hurt, offence, annoyance, and mental distress as harms, the principle will countenance political interference with nearly every activity, and liberty will amount to naught. On the other hand, if we count only physical damage to persons as harm, most every activity will be permitted and there will be little scope for the political protection of persons. (Kernohan, 1993, 2-5) Certain harms, however, had an interesting structure which straddles these extremes; sometimes activities which, individually, are merely annoying, innocuous, or even beneficial add up to doing physical damage or severe harm. Following Feinberg, R.V Brown call these "accumulative harms," and argue that, even on a stringent conception of harm. Mill's harm principle should be interpreted as requiring political interference to prevent them.
There is a related ambiguity in the interpretation of the harm principle. Should the principle offer protection against harms or only against harmful conduct Harmful conduct is activity done either maliciously or recklessly that causes harm to others. ...
Download paper


Similarly, in an early essay in 1973 entitled Moral Enforcement and the Harm Principle-an essay which would sketch the contours of his later four-volume treatise on The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law-Professor Joel Feinberg rehearsed Mill's harm principle and he, too, pared the principle down to its original, simple formulation
Author : wbartell

Related Essays

Theories of Karl Marx and John Stuart Mill
Each of these theorists have contributed towards twentieth century political influence, with both socialists and libertarians using these works as cornerstones of activism and individual beliefs. Marx's supporters tend to believe in community support, with individual needs oppressed in favor of the society; Mill's theories are concerned with the right of pursuit of individual happiness, against the demands of a society for conformity and participation in accepted beliefs....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Readings in Social Science John Stuart Mills
Through adapting these works toward the social commentary of the day, we find that in the same article of work by The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy is that "Mill's defense of the view that we ought to pursue happiness because we do pursue happiness, has been the object of savage attack by, among others, F. H. Bradley in his Ethical Studies 1874 and G. E. Moore in Principia Ethica 1903." This would be aptly served by the situation of today's social policies in that it seems quite apparent in how his insight many years ago would have been a service to those governing today. "But others have...
9 pages (2259 words) Essay
John Stuart Mill's On Liberty as applied to an issue of modern times
He was concerned that this majority would stamp out diversity, repress individuals whom failed to conform to herdlike values, and stifle dissenting views....
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
John Stuart Mill and Liberty. How morality is related to liberty?
Before discussing the justification of liberty, we would talk about the idea behind liberty and how Mill links liberty to morality1. ...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
john stuart mill (for history of psychology class)
He left Scotland four years later and went to London. James Stuart's London life has been divided into three periods: that of struggle - 1802-1819, the period of his most successful works - 1819- 1829 and the last one, from 1830 to his death, in 1836, when he both enjoyed fame and had been made Head Examiner in the India House....
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
John Stuart Mills Theories
The essay concludes that Mill's proposed limitations on legitimate interference with the individual has limited sustainability, and can only be applied in a system which has already liberated its citizens through education and cultural revolution....
21 pages (5271 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!