Different Aspects of Evidence Law

Masters
Case Study
Miscellaneous
Pages 9 (2259 words)
Download 0
On a charge of rape absence of consent1 is very important and the prosecution has to prove that the accused, Phil had carnal knowledge of Jill despite her age without her consent. It is not an excuse that the complainant is a common prostitute; that she has consented to intercourse with the accused on other occasions; or that she is the accused person's concubine…

Introduction

Usually evidence of some struggle or resistance by the complainant maybe the best proof of lack of consent but this is not always necessary.
It will be recalled in the case D.P.P. v Morgan3 the House of Lords held that if an accused person believed that the woman was consenting he should not be guilty of rape even though he had no reasonable grounds for his belief. The mental element of rape is intention to have sexual intercourse without the woman's consent or not. The sexual offences (Amendment) Act 1976 amended the law relating to rape in England by providing that a man commits rape if he has sexual intercourse with a woman who does not consent to it; and at the time he knows that she does not consent to it or he is reckless as to whether she consents to it. The amendment in effect confirmss the decision in D.P.P. v Morgan. A similar case was reported in Jamieson v HMA4 This Scottish criminal case decided by the High Court of Justiciary on appeal held that a man does not commit rape where he honestly, albeit unreasonably, believes his victim is consenting.
For the facts of the case: Phil raped Jill in a lane close to the house that Jill shares with her mother, Bunty, and her two sisters, Joleen and Shula. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Law Evidence
So although Dennis states that we could include inadmissible evidence, it does not in essence be correct with the system in its fairness.…
Different aspects of auditing
In addition, in question 4 the responsibility in relation to external and internal audit toward the society has been discussed.…
Different aspects of domestic violence
It is this definition that has been the basis of evolution for policing policies as applied to domestic violence. The trend in policing today is for the police department to compose of a triage. For example, in many police departments across the United States, when an officer responds to a domestic violence call, he/she may contact the dispatcher, who will call the Crisis Center for Women 24-hour…
Different aspects of employe relations
The heterogeneity of women's preferences result in less coherence and a lack of conformity in relation to the development of social policy, a factor enabling the continuity of a patriarchal society supporting homogeneous men. This review will investigate trends in female employment patterns, in conjunction with Hakim's preference theory, identifying contrasting literature illustrating the limited…
Different Aspects of Ecotourism
Different languages are spoken. Municipalities also register an inevitable growth and they have to provide transportable roads lighting the roads, similarly and should be committed to provide amenities of international standard to ecotourism and also for its sustenance. Ecotourism is no more permitted, limited to a particular part of the world. It is exchanged in order to serve the public with the…
Different Aspects of Evidence Law
Usually evidence of some struggle or resistance by the complainant maybe the best proof of lack of consent but this is not always necessary.…
Evidence Law
In such cases, it is deemed that the confessions ceases to be reliable, and, as a result, may not tenable in a Court of Law. In such cases, what needs to be assessed is not what transported after the confessions was obtained, but what anteceded the confession, or in other words, the role of actions that led to the signing of the confessions by the defendants. "To justify the arrest, there had to…