Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Criticism of Taylor and Browns 1988 study that positive illusions foster mental health - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : alexanne81

Summary

Taylor and Brown's 1988 study that looked at how positive illusions foster mental health is considered by many to be a work of genius. By others, it is considered a highly flawed, inaccurate study that purposely misleads people into believing that narcissistic self beliefs can actually be positive…

Extract of sample
Criticism of Taylor and Browns 1988 study that positive illusions foster mental health

will necessitate a positive future (Colvin and Block 1994).
While all of these concepts may be see as correlated to increased positive self image, Colvin and Block suggest that while this behavior may also be typical of normal subjects, it does not compel the reader to recognize these behaviors as healthy, when current psychological practise prefers that people have a realistic self image, as apposed to a highly illusionary self image (Colvin and Block 1994).
One of the primary criticisms Colvin and Block suggest is the use of the terms "balanced" and "evenhanded." They criticise these terms, in that Taylor and Brown do not give a definition of either term, and their meaning can be ambiguous. While Taylor and Brown's article suggests the terms to mean "a subject ascribes to self a relatively equal number of positive and negative characteristics" (Colvin and Block 1994). ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Mental Health and Mental Disorders
He worked out Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy. This author stated that emotions derive from "an interaction between events in the environment and beliefs and expectations which we have". (qtd in Clark, p. 130) Sometimes these beliefs are so powerful that they affect person's emotional conditional. The purpose of emotive behaviour therapy is to make these emotions less powerful and not badly influence person's emotional condition. (Clark). According to the concepts of cognitive theory, specialists counseling in mental disorders, should focus on mental condition of the client and investigate…
5 pages (1255 words)
Mental Health and Disability
Social work practice with those who were labeled "insane" in the parlance of the early 20th century (individuals found to meet the legal definition of "insanity" at a "lunacy" court hearing and committed to institutions), arose from a socially progressive reform effort known as the aftercare movement. As the earliest form of "psychiatric" social work practice, aftercare functions became the vehicle for linking the emerging methods and tasks of social work with the existing structures of psychiatric care. That link proved to be an important one for widening the perspective on what constituted…
12 pages (3012 words)
Promoting Mental Health and Adaptation: A Case Study and Analysis
John initially tried to fight with his problem. He was very much eager to accept life events that came on his way and to become happy again. Support of two sisters and an aunt, with whom he is living in two-bedroom house were supposedly to be helpful. However, the contact with relatives did not input to Johns' post-trauma healing; he rather became more annoying and lost. Taking medications for one year after the death of parents was not approved by doctors as well. Under the effect of anti-depressants, his state was only temporarly improved. In a while, he became depressed again and faced the…
10 pages (2510 words)
Mental health and mental illnesses
It is extremely difficult for us mortals to attain complete physical, mental or social wellbeing.…
16 pages (4016 words)
mental health
Due to this broad concept of mental health there have been a set of studies but a number of writers out of which some are supporting each other and some are contradictory. Mental health has been studies in the different form it gets manifested and with different factors that either directly or indirectly influence mental health. These studies have focused on different influential factors from the society, personal, and cultural components of a living being. We will be focusing on the work done by four writers Pedersen, Patterson, Weinrach, and Speight. All these writers have written a number…
3 pages (753 words)
case study for client with bipolar disorder mental health assessment
Experiencing the growing disharmony in their married life, the husband has decided that it is time for an intervention for Sarah. Threatened with divorce, Sarah has now understood her position and agreed for an assessment: she really wishes to put an end to the troubles she is causing and agreed to take therapy to reduce the risk of harmful behavior.…
7 pages (1757 words)