Evaluation of Marx's and Weber's concept of class relevant to understanding contemporary societies - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Evaluation of Marx's and Weber's concept of class relevant to understanding contemporary societies

This leads to a relatively impoverished conception of the nature of antagonistic interests generated by class relations.
Key readings from Marx ("The Communist Manifesto" and "On Classes") and Weber ("Class, Status, and Party") help us understand the sociological analyses of inequality in the concepts of social class, exploitation, surplus value, markets, status, and power. But there is always a difference of opinion between these two thinkers that clearly contrasts Marx's historical materialism and emphasis on class conflict with Weber's exploration of the overlapping sources of inequality in economic, social, and political spheres. (Chatterjee, 83)
The importance of production relations in Marxian theory with Weber's emphasis on market relations could be a key prospect in understanding the basic or fundamental influence on modern European society. It could well be suggested that both property and market dynamics are important by relating each to the concepts of class composition. ...
Download paper

Summary

To understand the foundations of Marx's and Weber's class analysis one must look beyond their synoptic treatments of class in their well-known and much appreciated works on economy, party concept and class systems. These perceptions and concepts of class are intimately linked to their investigations of the broad problem of rationalization in modern society…
Author : kali23

Related Essays

How does Webers concept of status group challenge Marxs views on polarization of classes in societies
(Giddens, 1971, p. 37). Weber notes that there is class conscious organization where (a) there are no groups between the real adversaries, (b) large numbers of persons are in the same class situation, (c) it is technically easy to organize those in the common class situation, and (d) where the goals of the class are well understood, and this understanding is led by those outside the class (intelligentsia). (Giddens and Held, p. 72)
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Middle Class Societies Of America And England
Therefore Roosevelt became the first president to support the labor and assigned the government a direct role and duty to all the people.…
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Marxist Account of Class in Contemporary Society
During the twentieth century the working class has been shaped by three trends. In the workplace the displacement of craft and skilled labor by mass production techniques has allowed the employment of large numbers of unskilled workers; culturally, the integration of diverse ethnic strains produced by the centralization of production facilities and the constant infusion of petty bourgeois ideology has precluded the development of a clear-cut working-class consciousness; politically, the increasing intervention of the state in the regulation and management of the economy has added to the…
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Societies
It is complex play of power and dominance over the weaker defenseless sex, for superiority and satisfaction. The relationship between man and woman, and the significant role that a woman plays to keep the social and the family scene moving accounts for the hidden power with which women perform her duties regardless of time and age, in 20th century Muslim society or 17th century Chinese society. Men reserved the right to betray, women remained faithful, virtuous and honorable before marriage and even after husbands death.…
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Weber's and Marx Capitalism.
This so-called Protestant ethic was the primary impulse for an almost accidental massive social phenomenon that led to the emergence of capitalism. …
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Compare and contrast Karl Marx's and Max Weber's ideas about capitalism. Which points does Weber against to Marx?
Class divisions persevere as a vital structural characteristic of modern human culture, influencing an individual’s life chances. The study of capitalism by both Marx and Weber related directly to its affect on society. Their works have been viewed by many as the basis by which the structure of society within a capitalist system is best comprehended and have become the subject of much sociological debate.…
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Is the Marxist account of class still relevant in contemporary society? Why, or why not?
Thesis The Marxist account of class is still relevant in contemporary society because it reflects and supports the main social, political and economic relations between the state and social classes, and between upper and low classes of modern society.…
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!