StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Miscellaneous
  • QUESTION What issues of the convention of ministerial responsibility do the facts of the above scenario raise

QUESTION What issues of the convention of ministerial responsibility do the facts of the above scenario raise - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
QUESTION What issues of the convention of ministerial responsibility do the facts of the above scenario raise

The office bearers are answerable to the parliament in general and the constitution of UK is strong enough to keep a check on everyone who has power and who is holding the offices in various ministries. To ensure the departments and governing bodies work properly, the government has a set of rules, and the responsibilities of these ministries are known to the general public. Thus if anyone goes against the norm, it is noticed and pointed out by the general public.
The scenario created in the case is a very interesting one. First, the family minister who is supposed to protect the family unit and its respect is having an extra marital affair. Then the minister of social welfare is not willing to accept her fault and as a result lots of people are kept waiting for their social welfare funds. Thirdly, the prime minister simply finds it easy to ignore the no confidence vote!!! If for a moment one believes that this could happen in the UK government and House of Commons, it means that there practically would be no constitution to stop the powerful from destroying those who are powerless against them. Well, thanks heavens, this is not the case in general. The case is a piece of fiction which is too far fetched. In the past we do have examples of ministers who have abided by the rules and legislations provided to them by the constitution. Constitution for any elected government is the supreme authority. With the constitution in place, the ministers have the guideline for them to work upon.

The Crichel Down Affair (1954) is one case that proves the importance of ministerial responsibility. : "Crichel Down was a piece of farmland in Dorset compulsorily bought by the government for defence use. Commander George Martin, son of the original farmer, wanted to buy the land back in the 1950s now that it was no longer used by the MoD. However the Ministry of Agriculture resisted, wanting to use the land for experimental farming in a time of rationing and agricultural development. However, Martin, a former equerry in the Royal Family, had very influential friends and stirred up much trouble in the local Conservative Party and government backbenches. There followed a public inquiry which criticized the department's decision and civil servants, especially their methods. It was seen as an example of an over-powerful state. Finally Dugdale announced that Martin could buy the land back and told the House of Commons he was resigning." Dugdale's resignation went down in history as an honourable, even heroic, one: a minister taking responsibility for civil servant's actions. (

The issues raised by the scenario: Keeping this incident in view, the question that comes to my mind to carry forward this debate is that what are the measures taken by the government to ensure that the ministers are able to meet their responsibilities Is it just natural that the personal affairs of a minister can be a real concern in the dispensation of his or her public duties What are the ministerial ethics we are looking for Do the media have any role in pointing the faults of ministers out to them Also, we need to know if collective Ministerial Responsibility myth or a reality

With reference to the scenario stated, an extra marital affair, which is specifically in the personal interest of the ...Show more


In the countries that have elected governments, the elected executive body is not only powerful to take decisions on behalf of a common man, but they are also responsible for the offices they hold. Every ministry has its own responsibilities. Off course the Ministers have lots of staff working under them, but still it is a ministerial responsibility to make sure that everything goes well…
Author : altenwerthalver
QUESTION What issues of the convention of ministerial responsibility do the facts of the above scenario raise essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"QUESTION What issues of the convention of ministerial responsibility do the facts of the above scenario raise"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

The structure of marketing plans used by companies worldwide is not standardized. Different criteria are likely to be used by each firm when designing its marketing strategy; the availability of resources and the firm’s mission/ objectives are critical factors that influence a firm’s decision in regard to the promotion of its products/ services.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Scenario question
The instant case shall test once again, the feasibility of the Statute of the ICJ particularly the Optional Clause which allows a party to accept the jurisdiction of the Court ipso facto, subject only to any reservation it may incorporate along with its Declaration of Acceptance, to end or settle a dispute.
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
Scenario question Essay
r coastlines.( In force 16 Nov 1994).The law under LOS Convention, Art 76.allowed the a country to claim a continental shelf out to a minimum of 200 nautical miles.The concept of the newly recognized Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) also extended this to 200 nautical miles under Article 57 LOS.1
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
How Supply Chain Management Best Practice is assisting organisations with the above scenario
(Agrawal, 2001). The best practices would embrace systems thinking and do away with the silo mentality of isolated departments in an organization, i.e., marketing, accounting, sales, etc.. The best emerging practice of SCM is a combination of Lean
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Scenario Question: Law of the Sea
The researcher uses examples and relevant case law as well as recent developments, such as 2007 Japanese fishing vessels and the Volga case to accordingly discuss and evaluate the field of study. The essay then describes the procedure for State A of the case and the procedure for State B of the case.
19 pages (4750 words) Essay
Scenario question
Although the Vienna Convention may have no legal force for non parties, most States regard it as the authoritative declaration of international treaty law, and therefore hold themselves
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Successive governments have sought to alter the meaning of ministerial responsibility by emphasising the distinction between a ministers role in creating policy
The administrative supremacy within delegated areas is implemented by the Scottish Ministers, at the same time as the UK Government at Westminster has kept hold of direct responsibility for
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Intellectual Property Law, Scenario based question
An intellectual property offers companies and individuals the benefit of protecting their assets and inventions from potential misuse and helps them use such assets for marketing and branding. The current paper is aimed at discussing
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
The European Convention on Human Rights & a scenario type of question
It is worth mentioning in this context that moral rights endure few basic characteristics and are natural and by virtue pertaining to the humanity. Moral rights are also universal and exist within the
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
The Raise interactive scenario
Thus, when they are mistreated or treated rightly, it is the whole society that benefits in equal measure. It is worth to note and record that the society depends on them out rightly and directly since they represent the hope of the future and
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment