Critical Review Essay

Masters
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 6 (1506 words)
Download 0
In this essay I have discussed and compared the ideas and arguments of the various authors in relation to the military leader's role in defining national interests and military objectives in war. Sun Tzu, Machiavelli, and Clausewitz have differing views on the attributes of a good military leader…

Introduction


Sun Tzu has a praiseworthy approach when he propounds the attributes of a good military leader and it seems he is able to state his case in the best way possible. In my view Clausewitz has also given some interesting views which have allegations of bias against them. In the paragraphs below I have analysed the approaches of all these military leaders and whether or not their ideas can be reconciled with each other as well as my own views on the issue.
For Clausewitz, by the time he was writing his book "On War" his thoughts on war had evolved towards notions like "War is a continuation of politics with an admixture of other means" and that there could be different ways and means of warfare. Here the concern is particularly towards his views on the practical uses of military history to and his "critical analysis" where he distinguished carefully between the historian and the military critic, despite his admission that both roles were often complementary.According to Clausewitz for a military historian there had to be a use of the critical analysis which would involve the tracing of effects back to their causes which would be essentially an investigation into what military steps were taken and whether they were effective at a tactical,operational,strategic and political level. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Essay Editing Critical Review of transport's adverse impact
According to the Kyoto Protocol, which is emphasized in this chapter, it outlined "To reduce the effect of human activity on climate, 168 countries have ratified the Kyoto protocol, which requires 40 of them - as listed in Annex 1 of the protocol - average about 5% below the overall 1990 level."ii I have read some of the documents on this protocol. Interestingly, some of the points are critical.…
Cloning: A Critical Review
In more simple terms, cloning is the process of creating an identical copy of something original.…
Sociology essay Book Report/Review
Central to Durkheim's analysis of social sciences is the way in which societies evolve. To him, society was to be identified as something independent, and as one consisting of social forces with social dimensions (Filloux 1993, p.2). They are particularly different social traits and factors, which are beyond the fields of psychology, or biology. These traits or forces are nothing but 'Social…
Ecology: A Critical Review
There is strict mathematics involved with the carrying capacity issue, and depending on the particular situation, the impact of famine, for instance, could be quite moderate or extreme. In terms of what the possibilities are for the continued growth of a population once it has approached its carrying capacity, this really depends on the particular population being discussed, but it is very…
Critical essay
Class, in these terms, is the way economic power is distributed when economic action is organized in an instrumentally-rational manner to the greatest degree. The problem of exploitation the extraction of labor effort from workers is treated, in this framework, primarily as a problem of technical efficiency and economic rationality in creating work incentives and effective discipline. This leads…
Critical Review Essay
Sun Tzu has a praiseworthy approach when he propounds the attributes of a good military leader and it seems he is able to state his case in the best way possible. In my view Clausewitz has also given some interesting views which have allegations of bias against them. In the paragraphs below I have analysed the approaches of all these military leaders and whether or not their ideas can be…
Critical Book Review
Review. Ms. West presents this book using dialogue and from the very beginning she writes as if speaking to the reader. Her first sentence sets the stage for an argument that would not come from the perspective of an author of another race. Her idea that western society has been socialized to believe individual thinkers perspective on social problems is a unique take on a long standing problem in…