Explain how Machiavelli's discussion of virtue (virtu) in The Prince differs from that of the ancients like Plato and Cicero. Give examples. - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Explain how Machiavelli's discussion of virtue (virtu) in The Prince differs from that of the ancients like Plato and Cicero. Give examples.

It is immoral and unethical, maintains Plato, for a ruler to rule solely by might.
Machiavelli has stated, ""A Prince, therefore should have no care or thought but for war, and the regulations and training it requires, and should apply himself exclusively to this as his peculiar province; for war is the sole art looked for in one who rules" (Machiavelli, P. 70)."
Therefore, it is clear that Machiavelli's idea of virtu' is not one that is based on moral character, but rather, based on utility. For Machiavelli, virtu' outweighs morality when the needs of the situation demands it; for Plato, one must preserve morality at all times. Plato believes in utopian ideals and propositions; Machiavelli, was a realist.
Cicero, on the other hand, maintains that there was no distinction between that which was morally good and what was useful to man. His concept of duty is directly opposite the concept of duty as forwarded by Machiavelli. Cicero believed that pleasure may be enjoyed by man, but that there is a right and moral way to enjoy pleasure. For example, sex is an enjoyable activity and may thus be engaged in by man, but it is wrong to have sex with another man's wife. To quote from Cicero, "Virtue is a habit of the mind, consistent with nature and moderation and reason." Even their concepts of government are markedly different. ...
Download paper

Summary

Platonic philosophy is hinged on moral virtue as practiced by just rulers. Man served the State and hence, ethics and politics were the same. This is to be contradistinguished with Machiavellian principles, which states that the State should serve the people…
Author : mcculloughmalco

Related Essays

Virtue in Machiavelli's Philosophy
"It is necessary for a prince, wanting to maintain himself, to learn how to be able to be not good and to use this and not use it according to necessity"(Machiavelli 57). He believes that one good man is surely going to suffer among those who are not good. Thus, the virtue of goodness is meaningless for Machiavelli. If a price is imagined to be just as what Machiavelli conceptualizes, he would not be less than a criminally wicked tyrant. On contrast, the Discourses is a good usable book, though being long, nostalgic, and difficult as well. Here, Machiavelli's advices go to not just the rulers...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Machiavelli's The Prince
7, 2006) These principles have become insightful and meaningful political policies in the 16th century onwards in the European society. (http:/www.123helpme.com/view.aspid=23518, Nov. 7, 2006)...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
The Prince
Thesis These principles can be applied to military conflict in Iraq and can help to explain the main problems and strategies followed by the US government and military men....
4 pages (1004 words) Book Report/Review
Magic Realism and how it differs from surrealism
The paper "Magic Realism and how it differs from surrealism" focuses on the realism and surrealism. This final unification is the supreme aim of surrealism: interior reality and exterior reality being, in the present form of society, in contradiction (and in this contradiction is the very cause of man’s unhappiness)…” From this definition, it is clear that surrealism delves into the conscious and subconscious of the human mind. Thus the element of reality is the social reality in which the character in the film is immersed in. The fantastic element is depicted in the subconscious state...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Modern leaders still use Machiavelli's The Prince approach to, politics
This classic of political science has retained its relevance down the five centuries it has survived to come down to us, and leaders of various reputes have been acquainted with it, and consciously or sub-consciously followed its principles. Modern leadership in the twentieth and twenty-first century are no exception, and examples of Machiavellian wisdom abound from Stalin and Hitler, to Ronald Reagan, Nixon and George Bush....
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Machiavelli's "The Prince" and Castiglione's "The Courtier"
Unfortunately, for Niccolo Machiavelli, this was not to be. He never gained the favor of the new prince and was never reinstated into any governmental positions. Machiavelli’s The Prince was not published until after the author died....
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Critically assess how extract from Machiavelli's Prince relates to the contemporary issues concerning globalisation and the business activities of MNCs
s and wise princes have always taken great pains not to make the nobles despair, and to satisfy the people and keep them content; this is one of the most important tasks a prince must undertake.’1...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!