StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

EU Law Studies - Case Study Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
EU Law Studies

Astrid, Klaus's wife, had every right to apply for a job as an estate agent. The fact that Astrid was discriminated against because she did not pass a Spanish language test in Spain-although she had completed and passed a similar test in Germany-is illegal because member EU states must treat other EU member citizens equally.4
The fact that Klaus did not receive the same company pension entitlement as Spanish nationals who also worked as his company is a blatant form of discrimination against Klaus as a German national living in Spain, again because EU members are supposed to receive the same social benefits of domestic members.5 Another social benefit6 Klaus should have received based on the fact that he is an EU members was his five extra holidays, just as his Spanish national counterparts.7
Similarly, in Astrid's case, she was discriminated against by not being able to receive the same social advantage8 of receiving free banking as her Spanish national counterparts who worked at the bank as well.
Sophie was discriminated against on the basis of nationality9 due to the fact that, at college, only students in her course who had lived in Spain for at least ten years could claim a special financial payment to cover the enrollment fee. This is because Sophie had only been in Spain for a few months. Still, however, this was a discriminatory practice.
Additionally, since Heinrich wanted to apply for a student maintenance grant but was told that it was only available to Spanish nationals, this is another form of discrimination based on nationality.10
Klaus and Heinrich, respectively-had prior convictions in Germany for handling stolen motor vehicles and dealing illegal drugs-can argue that they were trying to start a new life in Spain but were discriminated against in their pursuits of operating legally in the country of Spain. Klaus could not receive social security benefits or the same company pension as the other workers at his job who were Spanish nationals.
Heinrich needed a grant to go to school. Based on these exclusion from receiving the proper compensation and remuneration, which is a legal right of EU member citizens,11 it could be argued in court that Klaus reverted to an illegal venture in order to make ends meet.
Similarly, the same argument could be made of Astrid-that she was forced into a bank job by virtue of discrimination12 as a German national and was forced to resort to illegal methods to help ensure her family's well-being in Spain. Freedom of establishment13 in another member EU country is a right guaranteed to individuals who are EU citizens. In court, it could be argued that Klaus and Astrid were denied this basic right.14
Regarding Heinrich, it could be argued in court that-because he was not allowed to get a grant based on discrimination due to him being a German national15 while residing in Spain-Heinrich turned to dealing illegal drugs as an activity to pay for his schooling, which would not have been an issue had he not been discriminated against.16
With regard to Sophie, the political group which she had joined was under surveillance by authorities in Spain, however she was not committing an illegal act ...Show more

Summary

The following is the advice for Klaus, Astrid, Heinrich, and Sophie with regards to their status as German nationals living in Spain within the boundaries of EU law relating to the free movement of persons as stated in Article 39EC.1
Klaus, as a car mechanic, when he first came to Spain, only managed to find temporary work for three months at a garage selling petrol…
Author : faheylaverne
EU Law Case Studies essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"EU Law Case Studies"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Human Resource Case Studies
The act protects individuals performing their jobs satisfactorily against discrimination by employers hiring 20 or more workers and labor organizations with 25 or more members. Zimpfer was 52 years old and, therefore, was under the protection of ADEA and should have been employed instead of the 33 years old Brad.
5 pages (1250 words) Case Study
Case Studies Assignment
However, these two clinics differ in terms of health care provision and the costs of delivering services to the patients that frequent these establishments. The management style of both of these hospitals also differ in principles as one is keen on minimizing operational cost while the other has invested widely in order to ensure that they deliver quality.
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
Case studies Case Study
In Board of Regents of State Colleges v. Roth, the Supreme Court held that a non tenured teacher does not have a property interest in his or her teaching position. Likewise, the Supreme Court also found that a public college professor dismissed from an office held under tenure provisions, and college professors and staff members dismissed during the terms of their contracts, have property interests in continued employment.
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
Constitutional Law of the EU
The European Community had a significant impact upon the legal systems of the Member States. It regulates the rights and interests of its members by developing its own institutions and a unique and autonomous legal system that bind each member. This is accomplished fundamentally through Treaties, a crucial form of EC legislation that has become the root of all other European Law.
12 pages (3000 words) Case Study
EU Law
"organizations or bodies which were subject to the authority or control of the State or had special powers beyond those which result from the normal rules applicable to relations between individuals."1 Charles clearly falls under this head. The next step would be for him to establish that the Directive is "clear, negative, unconditional, containing no reservation on the part of the Member State and not dependent on any national implementing measure,: Alfons Ltticke GmbH v.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
EU Law Assignment
The better part of the answer will however discuss whether S and A can rely on the direct effects of the Directive. This will be followed by a discussion of vertical and horizontal direct effect, the rules and regulations in applying this, the differences between the enforceability of rights contained in regulations and directives.
6 pages (1500 words) Case Study
Case studies
the diagnosis that as to whether the patient has lung cancer, he/she could have sought a second opinion there and then rather than holding the decision for two years. It could have been that the diagnosis could be unreliable in the first place and that the current medical
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
Business case studies
The issues to be determined in the case is existence of a valid contract between General and Honi and validity of specific performance, and not an alternative remedy, should a valid contract had existed between the two parties. A valid contract exists
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
Case Studies
In addition, they chose wrong a person to make trades for the Bank because he turned out to be a rogue trader. Their lack of oversight made them realize the bank was running a loss
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
2 case studies
Net sales of the company as at September 27 2014 were at 182,795 million dollars. Net income for the business as at September 27 2014 were at 39, 510 million dollars. Total assets as at September 27 2014 was at 231, 839 million dollars. Total cash flow that was obtained from
12 pages (3000 words) Case Study
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment