Mill vs. Raz - Essay Example

Extract of sample
Mill vs. Raz

Guided by 'one very simple principle' he outlines an argument for a system, which he believed, provided the best possible environment for individual and social progress (Mill, 1991, p.30). Mill advocates for human's shortcoming and their incompleteness of knowledge, which means that the "truth" is not always the truth. Based on Mill's assertions, any one group who attempts to coerce another group or individual is breaching individual liberty, which leads to the stagnation of the intellectual community. The key to progress lies in the condition of seeking the best span of human experience and development. The individual in the Millian liberal society is engaged in 'experiments in living'; attempts to find "new, deeper or merely different sources of happiness in life", uncoerced by the state or fellow individuals. (Ryan, 1991, p.166) The most important aspect of well-being is to note that the individual has complete authority in matters regarding themselves, society does not have the right to restrict the individual, as long as the actions of the individual is not causing harm to themselves or others. Liberty is, therefore, an integral component of well-being; liberty provides the best possible conditions to achieve the "permanent interests of man as a progressive being." (Mill, 1991, p.31)
In Joseph's Raz's The Morality of Freedom, his theory does not rest on a human being's fallacies but instead he argues that the individual's w ...
Download paper


In John Stuart Mill's publication On liberty, Mill describes his principles on the individuals well being. He stresses that the only reason power should be exerted over any member of a civilized community, against their will, is if it is to prevent harm to others…
Author : bobby14
Download 1

Related Essays

Kant and Mill
Kant does not disregard practical anthropology in the Foundations because he believes it is unimportant.As we know,Kant did discuss practical anthropology in numerous works on ethics and education.However,in order to understand moral action in the empirical world,Kant contends that moral action as such has to be understood first. Thus Kant ventures into a study that tries to supply the principles of moral action as such, or tries to supply the principles for "rational beings in general," which we can interpret in this context as moral subjects. One can found the same tension in Kant's ethical...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Theories of Karl Marx and John Stuart Mill
Each of these theorists have contributed towards twentieth century political influence, with both socialists and libertarians using these works as cornerstones of activism and individual beliefs. Marx's supporters tend to believe in community support, with individual needs oppressed in favor of the society; Mill's theories are concerned with the right of pursuit of individual happiness, against the demands of a society for conformity and participation in accepted beliefs.
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
John Stuart Mill and Liberty. How morality is related to liberty?
Before discussing the justification of liberty, we would talk about the idea behind liberty and how Mill links liberty to morality1.
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Moral Dilemma: Culture vs. Heroism
The scope of this paper is to choose a moral dilemma from literature and apply both Mill's and Kant's ethical philosophies to the character in question, and then draw some conclusions on that application. For these purposes, I have chosen to examine the moral conflict confronting J.R.R. Tolkien's character Bilbo Baggins as he is forced to choose between cultural correctness and heroism.
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot
Again, time is presented as a situational variable from the legal conflict over the mill in the beginning of the novel to the resolution in the end. This essay proposal is going to closely look into the role of time in The Mill on the Floss.
9 pages (2259 words) Book Report/Review
john stuart mill (for history of psychology class)
He left Scotland four years later and went to London. James Stuart's London life has been divided into three periods: that of struggle - 1802-1819, the period of his most successful works - 1819- 1829 and the last one, from 1830 to his death, in 1836, when he both enjoyed fame and had been made Head Examiner in the India House.
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
Kant vs. Mill
In other words, he says that one must act in a manner that one would expect others to act towards oneself. This Kantian ethical theory is popular because it is widely respected and consequently upheld by others.
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!